banner
Mike Maniscalco

Baseball HoF voting highlights sports media flaws

Posted January 11

The legendary Howard Cosell once said, “What's right isn't always popular. What's popular isn't always right.”

I don’t think that is what ESPN personality Dan Le Batard was thinking when he gave his Baseball Hall of Fame vote away to the patrons of Deadspin.com, but his intent was in the right place. What has disturbed me is the fallout of his actions amongst other media types. I am not trying to bite the hand that feeds me, but the circus that followed a decision to turn a hall of fame vote over to sports fans has really shown a poor light on the sports reporting business.

Columnists and talking heads all across America have condemned Le Batard for calling attention to himself, instead of the incredibly flawed and antiquated system that determines who shall live in baseball immortality. He has been called sanctimonious, an attention grabber and some people have gone as far to call him idiotic. Well here is a newsflash for every columnist and TV and radio personality out there, he did what all of us try to do on a daily basis: get attention for HIS actions.

A long time ago, sports reporting stopped being about the sports and became all about the REPORTERS.

I do not know Dan Le Batard. I have never talked to him, met him in a social setting or even bumped into him at a media buffet line covering a game. I do not think he needs, or wants, me defending what he did. But I felt the need. I do see the logic in what he was doing by turning over what should be a coveted task to try to promote a change.

One, he was trying to say as a group of media we have broken something and he doesn’t know how else to fix it. Two, for years I have read writers and heard hosts say, “Change the system!” without doing anything more than saying it.

It was amusing and sad to see the sports writers that are household names thanks to their TV shows or national website platforms rail on Le Batard, instead of trying to bring about change to how baseball elects the greatest players to be enshrined in Cooperstown.

How many celebrities have been made of writers that have a forum on TV and let them scream about what changes need to be made or what coach needs to be fired? When someone finally took a different route to bring about a change that we as media have said needs to happen for years, what happened? The media ate their own. There are a few reasons behind it, but one I truly believe is because Le Batard gave his vote to Deadspin, not a reputable sports reporting outlet.

Now, take a look at how those ‘traditional’ outlets have blog sites there are an awful lot like Deadspin.

Full disclosure, I am not a fan of how sports media has a TMZ quality to it now, and Deadspin lead the way. Box scores have been replaced by blood-alcohol levels. I don’t want to be old-timey sports man here, but I still care more about the games than who is dating who in the sports world (Before you lose your mind, I didn’t say I don’t care about what super model Derek Jeter dates, just not as much as!!!).

What angered me the most at the media cattle was how hard they charged after Le Batard. I am not going to call out individuals, but guys, we all do the same thing as he does every day: we try to draw attention to what we just said about sports. If you haven’t noticed, every columnist is attempting to say, “This is how I would rule the sports world, so tell all your friends about my way!!!”

We are supposed to point out when things aren’t working and try to get people to see that maybe a change needs to happen, and change is never easy. Being a media member is a wonderful privilege, one that I try not to abuse. I can’t tell you how many press conferences I have been at where the reporter asking the question wants the attention, not the question they ask.

I am a sports talk show host, and every time I address a topic, the idea is to get people to see my point of view and the more people who tune in to my show the better for ME. If you know my name (Mike Maniscalco) and you tune in to what I say, that is good for me. I want you to, my bosses want you to. If you agree or disagree, it doesn’t matter as long as you are listening or reading. It is my job to bring up how I see a game, team or coach, and we aren’t going to see eye-to-eye on everything.

So did Le Batard do something that would put the spotlight firmly on him? Yes, of course he did. And I would assume he knew there would be this attention and fallout. Would it have been better had he stayed anonymous? Hard to say. Maybe the point, instead of the man, would have gotten more attention.

This week I have heard that he should have just given back his vote. Would that have changed anything? Would the average fan have even noticed? A returned vote would not even cause any of the other voters to take notice.

Others suggested the idea that he should have brought on every writer to his radio show and demanded change. I love baseball, but even I don’t want to hear 570 interviews about that. Also, wouldn’t that be sanctimonious preaching to his listeners and the other voters to how they should do things?

He has since said publicly he has regretted his decision, I wish he hadn’t. His choice to let the Deadspin readers choose his ballot should have had the right outcome. The BWAA should have seen that the average fan picked a better class than 16 of its members (I’ll explain in a minute). I promise you that the ballot that was turned in under his name was better than at least 200 that were counted. The fans didn’t vote on if a player talked to them or not, which some writers really do take into consideration.

Media types should have seen this as one of theirs saying that you don’t care about my vote, so I gave it to people who do care, the fans.

The real outrage of the media should have come against the 16 voters that left Greg Maddux off the ballot. How do these people get a vote? I almost do not want to hear what logic they have for excluding the best pitcher, yes best pitcher, of a generation from their Hall of Fame ballot. Those people should be banned from covering baseball and never be allowed to vote again. Yet, that won’t happen, but one can dream can’t they? I heard only a smattering of railing against that, and of course the steroid argument which is a separate column.

There are 571 hall of fame voters and there is no changing the ones that hide behind archaic reasoning or honestly don’t understand that there have always been different eras of the game. The fact that Babe Ruth didn’t get 100 percent of the vote shouldn’t mean that Cal Ripken Jr didn’t either.

It’s hard to bring about change if you do nothing. Too bad the person received the attention over the nothing that he was trying to point out.

3 Comments

This blogpost is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • timetochange Jan 13, 10:38 a.m.

    I meant to type, " if you DIDN"T report it".

  • timetochange Jan 13, 9:32 a.m.

    "Columnists and talking heads all across America have condemned Le Batard for calling attention to himself, instead of the incredibly flawed and antiquated system that determines who shall live in baseball immortality. He has been called sanctimonious, an attention grabber and some people have gone as far to call him idiotic. Well here is a newsflash for every columnist and TV and radio personality out there, he did what all of us try to do on a daily basis: get attention for HIS actions."
    I just love the hypocrisy. Sports reporters blaming a reporter for calling attention to himself. News flash, you pseudo-intellectuals. He wouldn't have gotten ANY attention if you did report the story!!! ......sports reporters, sheesh, what a group of self serving hypocrites.

  • Hammerhead Jan 13, 8:54 a.m.

    Agreed Mike, this has been evident for some time now. There are so many outlets and forums that the media has become paparazzi and in many cases, cannabalistic. Each accuses the other side of the same things that they themselves are guilty of. Sanctamonious? Pick a side. Everything has a become a debate, ESPN currently has several shows based on this fact.

  • HSFB: Football Friday with Tom Suiter

    Tonight at 11:35 on WRAL-TV

  • ACC: NC State at UNC

    Tomorrow at 12:58 pm on WRAL-TV

  • SEC: Mississippi State at Ole Miss

    Tomorrow at 3:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: San Diego at Baltimore

    Sunday at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CFB: NC State at UNC

    Tomorrow at 12:30 pm on WRAL-FM

Scoreboard
Local
Final
NCCU 65
EILL 40
 
2nd
NCSU 33
BSU 23
 
2nd
PIT 1
CAR 2
 
Half
CHA 55
GSW 49
 
1st
UF 0
UNC 3
 
8:30pm Tonight
TULSA
ECU
Final
BOS 102
CHI 109
Half
CHA 55
GSW 49
 
2nd
TOR 21
DAL 26
 
2nd
DET 31
MIL 30
 
2nd
ATL 25
NOP 15
 
8:00pm Tonight
HOU
LAC
8:00pm Tonight
OKC
NYK
8:00pm Tonight
IND
ORL
8:30pm Tonight
SAN
SAC
9:00pm Tonight
DEN
PHO
10:00pm Tonight
POR
MEM
10:30pm Tonight
LAL
MIN
Final
WMICH 21
NILL 31
Final
SMU 9
HOU 35
Final
IOWA 34
NEB 37
Final
SFLA 0
UCF 16
Final
MARS 66
WKENT 67
Final
KSU 27
AKR 24
Final
BGU 24
BST 41
Final
UMASS 21
BUF 41
Final
EMICH 16
TOL 52
Final
MIZZ 21
ARK 14
Final
SALABAMA 40
NAVY 42
 
Final
ARZ 42
ARST 35
Final
AFA 27
COLST 24
Final
UCLA 10
STAN 31
1st
VT 0
UVA 0
 
8:30pm Tonight
TULSA
ECU
Final
NCCU 65
EILL 40
 
Final
KU 82
TENN 67
Final
TEXAM 87
NO 65
 
Final
NCAT 57
RAD 65
 
Final
GEOR 58
BUT 64
Final
BRO 81
PVU 71
Final
RIU 66
SCU 44
Final
NARZ 70
SOUTH 63
Final
DART 68
MAST 67
Final
WRST 59
FIU 61
Final
XAV 73
UTEP 77
Final
OSU 73
JMU 56
Final
TXSOU 71
LAM 59
 
Final
TAMCC 75
MVSU 66
 
Final
AKAN 51
MIZST 55
Final
BUCK 80
PSU 88
 
Final
PROV 72
YALE 66
Final
UGA 62
MINN 66
Final
WISC 69
OKLA 56
Final
Terriers 70
NORST 72
 
Final
PEAY 62
STEPH 83
 
Final
FSU 58
CSOU 47
 
Final
VALPO 66
DRAK 46
 
Final
CIN 69
MTST 51
 
Final
SDU 75
PRIN 65
 
2nd
WASU 74
RICE 71
 
2nd
CSFU 56
USCU 65
 
2nd
GT 47
RIDE 41
 
2nd
TXPA 52
ALAST 59
 
2nd
NCSU 33
BSU 23
 
Half
TCU 31
BRAD 24
 
2nd
WAKE 39
DELST 36
 
2nd
HART 46
EMERSON 31
 
Half
STJ 28
GONZ 33
 
2nd
CLEM 31
HIGH 24
 
2nd
SYR 39
HC 17
 
2nd
MD 36
MON 30
 
2nd
JVST 42
SAV 33
 
2nd
MIAMI 51
SALA 31
 
Half
RUTG 31
VANDY 31
 
1st
PETE 29
TENST 20
 
1st
MARS 0
CLST 3
 
1st
JST 2
HOF 3
 
1st
INDST 9
MEM 5
 
1st
UF 0
UNC 3
 
8:00pm Tonight
LATU
SAMF
1st
TULA 9
SELA 10
 
1st
NEB 9
TENNM 7
 
8:30pm Tonight
MISS
CREI
8:30pm Tonight
PORT
MURST
9:00pm Tonight
MARQ
MSU
9:00pm Tonight
ARK
UNT
9:00pm Tonight
NCOL
STET
 
9:00pm Tonight
IND
UNCG
9:00pm Tonight
SJST
WMICH
9:05pm Tonight
MNTST
TXARL
9:30pm Tonight
UVA
LAS
9:30pm Tonight
STLU
MSST
9:30pm Tonight
COLST
PAC
10:00pm Tonight
UTAH
NDAK
10:30pm Tonight
ILL
BAY
10:30pm Tonight
UAB
UCLA
11:30pm Tonight
WASH
LBSU
11:59pm Tonight
UCSB
MERC
Final
PHI 0
NYR 3
Final
ANA 1
CHI 4
Final
WAS 5
NYI 2
2nd
PIT 1
CAR 2
 
2nd
NJD 4
DET 1
 
2nd
BUF 1
MON 0
 
2nd
CLB 0
VAN 0
 
2nd
BOS 0
WIN 1
 
1st
FLA 1
OTT 1
 
1st
STL 0
EDM 0
 
8:30pm Tonight
DAL
MIN