Joe Ovies

Closing the book on Mary Willingham

Posted August 5, 2014

Mary Willingham

Let's go ahead and put this on the table before discussing anything else. The ongoing story about North Carolina and lecture-style courses that either rarely met or didn't see the inside of a classroom at all should have been wrapped up by now.

Instead of thoroughly investigating the academic issues that were discovered in the wake of an NCAA investigation into the football program in 2010, the university did what most institutions do in these situations. North Carolina tried to box the issue, put a lovely bow on top of it and hope everyone moves on to the next thing. Except that didn't happen. Here we are in the summer of 2014 and waiting for Kenneth Wainstein, a former federal prosecutor who is working independently from UNC, to deliver what should be the definitive story of how the Department of African and Afro-American Studies became the center of an academic scandal.

Along the way, we've seen different story arcs and a wide array of characters emerge from the fateful day Marvin Austin tweeted Rick Ross rap lyrics. It all plays out like a boring version Marvel's Cinematic Universe without the payoff of "The Avengers." Rather than ridiculous characters like Star-Lord and Rocket Raccoon, we're stuck with Mary Willingham and Bradley Bethel playing out some sort of "Guardians of the Academic Galaxy."

In fairness to Willingham, she's long been an outspoken critic of the NCAA. Considering her work with student-athletes, her anecdotal behind the scenes perspective was helpful in counterbalancing the platitudes of amateurism spun by NCAA president Mark Emmert.

It wasn't until CNN morphed Willingham into a whistle-blower that her role in North Carolina's academic scandal became unsuitable for her particular experience. Both Willingham and the university locked horns over the research. It was always going to be an unfair matchup, given the backing of an entire institution versus an individual, but Willingham made it easy for the university to discredit her level of expertise.

Regardless, Willingham started doubling down on Twitter and ESPN's "Outside The Lines" to mixed results while North Carolina hired three outside research experts in an attempt to debunk her conclusions.

Only Willingham knows when the switch flipped to scorched Earth mode from NCAA critic with an eye on reform. On one hand, it was certainly red meat for the folks who took great pleasure and delight in North Carolina's embarrassments. On the other hand, Willingham made it easy for her detractors to question her motives.

If North Carolina's expert review of Willingham's student-athlete reading level research was the first strike against her credibility, she has to sit down following questions over her IRB application and alleged masters thesis plagiarism.

“Academics & Athletics – A Clash of Cultures: Division I Football Programs," completed in 2009, yielded four notably lifted segments after WRAL ran the thesis through four different plagiarism checking websites. Willingham told Dan Kane of the N&O these instances were inadvertent cases of improper citations.

Given North Carolina's piñata status last four years, the folks who feel the university was unfairly hammered thanks to her claims are entirely justified getting their ya ya's out discrediting Wilingham. It's also understandable for the same people to clown any media that simply ran with Willingham as their only source of information.

But keep in mind, North Carolina isn't mired in this mess because of Willingham. UNC did most of it to themselves with countless investigations that did little more than contain it.

“Whatever I did, I did, and, you know, whatever,” Willingham explained to the N&O. “There’s nothing I can do about it.”

There's also nothing she can do at this point to regain her credibility.

89 Comments

Please to add a comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Hill55 Aug 10, 9:21 a.m.

    [/b]"There's also nothing she can do at this point to regain her credibility."

    Except if UNC were to ultimately tell the truth.

  • 903 Born To Be Hateddd Aug 6, 4:14 p.m.

    That's about what it boils down to... The majority of fans of college teams pick them for the... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    I disagree. Many of my friends who are State fans have children following in their foot steps... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    State has an extremely small number of fans compared to UNC. Just look at 2013 merchandise... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    I saw that very same information earlier today on a thread and it was pointed out that state... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    Yep, UNC is up there in the Top 10 with all those big-time football SEC schools, UK, and Notre Dame.

    Like the Yankees, Lakers, and Cowboys in pro sports, those teams attract the Wal*Mart/bandwagon/non-affiliated fans...

  • heelsforever Aug 6, 3:42 p.m.

    Well, then I guess the overwhleming majority of sports fans are wal-mart/bandwagon fans. Must be... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    That's about what it boils down to... The majority of fans of college teams pick them for the... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    I disagree. Many of my friends who are State fans have children following in their foot steps... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    State has an extremely small number of fans compared to UNC. Just look at 2013 merchandise... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    I saw that very same information earlier today on a thread and it was pointed out that state does not license through CLC, so probably not a good indicator of how many fans there are. I don't disagree that Carolina has more fans than State, but I'm sure State has more than Wake.

  • 903 Born To Be Hateddd Aug 6, 3:18 p.m.

    So at 10 years old, what made you a UNC fan? Because they were good at sports?
    Selecting a school... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    Well, then I guess the overwhleming majority of sports fans are wal-mart/bandwagon fans. Must be... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    That's about what it boils down to... The majority of fans of college teams pick them for the... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    I disagree. Many of my friends who are State fans have children following in their foot steps... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    State has an extremely small number of fans compared to UNC. Just look at 2013 merchandise sales. State isn't even in the Top 75...

    http://www.clc.com/news/archived-rankings/rankings-annual-2012-13-rankings-section.aspx

    Top-75 Universities
    (1.) The University of Texas at Austin (2.) The University of Alabama (3.) University of Notre Dame (4.) The University of Michigan (5.) University of Kentucky (6.) Louisiana State University (7.) University of Florida (8.) University of Georgia (9.) University of North Carolina (10.) The University of Arkansas, Fayetteville

  • Objective Scientist Aug 6, 3:13 p.m.

    Of course it matters. Those of us who attended the school have a greater attachment to the... View More

    — Posted by rush

    Believe what you want about investment. My point is that those who have this opinion that non... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    This "investment" notion is interesting. I have earned 3 degrees from UNC-CH, bachelors,... View More

    — Posted by Objective Scientist

    OS, my original point was simply about how silly it is to suggest someone has no right to be a... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    Heelsforever... I have no issue with you, and it seems we are "on the same page". If it seems otherwise on this matter, perhaps I was not as clear as I should have been. As far as I'm concerned NO ONE has to have a "reason" for why they are a Carolina fan, Duke fan, State fan... or whatever fan. There are lots of decisions in all of our lives for which a reason for our choice may be necessary... that one chooses/decides to be a "fan" of a particular college or pro team in any sport is not a choice/decision that requires a reason. We need not "justify" our choice of teams... school or pro. (Hell... my father was a Duke fan although he never attended a college class anywhere... and then I got 3 degrees from UNC!)

    And - ABSOLUTELY - I've stated this before in WRAL postings - the football/basketball programs and the AFAM Dept are only very small parts of a very large and truly GREAT University. I'll put my degrees up against any others!

  • StunGunn Aug 6, 3:12 p.m.

    Of course it matters. Those of us who attended the school have a greater attachment to the... View More

    — Posted by rush

    Believe what you want about investment. My point is that those who have this opinion that non... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    This "investment" notion is interesting. I have earned 3 degrees from UNC-CH, bachelors,... View More

    — Posted by Objective Scientist

    OS, my original point was simply about how silly it is to suggest someone has no right to be a... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    Well said.

  • StunGunn Aug 6, 3:08 p.m.

    Willingham's thesis? Plagiarism? Improper citations? How are each of those defined? I do not... View More

    — Posted by Objective Scientist

    "As a holder of 3 earned degrees from UNC I am DISGUSTED with what has happened at "my... View More

    — Posted by uBnice

    As an alum, you have more of a right to be pizzed at the University for their behavior. Not sure... View More

    — Posted by Hammerhead

    Agree, Hammer. I understand graduates may have more "skin in the game", but I thought the term "bandwagon" meant a fan who only supported a team when they were winning.

  • heelsforever Aug 6, 3:05 p.m.

    Believe what you want about investment. My point is that those who have this opinion that non... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    So at 10 years old, what made you a UNC fan? Because they were good at sports?
    Selecting a school... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    Well, then I guess the overwhleming majority of sports fans are wal-mart/bandwagon fans. Must be... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    That's about what it boils down to... The majority of fans of college teams pick them for the... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    I disagree. Many of my friends who are State fans have children following in their foot steps and it's certainly not because State has been tearing it up in any sport over the last 20 years. Dad is a fan, watches the games on TV, takes the kids to the games, buys them t-shirts and all kinds of other team gear. They have the experience of that team growing up and most naturally become fans of the same school.

  • 903 Born To Be Hateddd Aug 6, 2:59 p.m.

    Of course it matters. Those of us who attended the school have a greater attachment to the... View More

    — Posted by rush

    Believe what you want about investment. My point is that those who have this opinion that non... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    So at 10 years old, what made you a UNC fan? Because they were good at sports?
    Selecting a school... View More

    — Posted by 903 Born To Be Hateddd

    Well, then I guess the overwhleming majority of sports fans are wal-mart/bandwagon fans. Must be... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    That's about what it boils down to... The majority of fans of college teams pick them for the same reason they pull for the Yankees, Cowboys and Lakers... That's why colleges like UNC have more of them than say Wake Forest...

  • heelsforever Aug 6, 2:58 p.m.

    Who gives a flying Wolpfack if Carolina fans who post here are UNC grads or not. You along with... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    Of course it matters. Those of us who attended the school have a greater attachment to the... View More

    — Posted by rush

    Believe what you want about investment. My point is that those who have this opinion that non... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    This "investment" notion is interesting. I have earned 3 degrees from UNC-CH, bachelors,... View More

    — Posted by Objective Scientist

    OS, my original point was simply about how silly it is to suggest someone has no right to be a fan and express an opinion because they don't have the sheepskin from that school. It's primarily State fans who cling to this ridiculous notion. I grew up in rural eastern NC and I can assure you that a very small percentage of State, Carolina, and to a much greater degree Duke fans didn't go to college at all. Nothing wrong with that IMO. Most of them became fans of those schools because someone of influence during their childhood was a fan of the school; parents, coaches, teachers, uncles, etc.

    I don't disgree that a lot of people at UNC have made some very bad decisions. I also agree that it's embarrassing and must be corrected. However, I absolutely disagree with those who would have us believe that all UNC degrees and programs are worthless due to issues related to AFAM and athletics. I should hope that you do too.

More...

 

 

  • ACC: NC State at Georgia Tech

    Saturday at 12:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • SEC: Arkansas at Florida

    Saturday at 2:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • PGA: Waste Management Phoenix Open

    Saturday at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • Big 10: Michigan at Michigan State

    Sunday at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NHL: Hurricanes vs. St. Louis

    Tomorrow at 7:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • ACC: NC State at Georgia Tech

    Saturday at 12:00 pm on WRAL-FM

  • NHL: Carolina Hurricanes at NY Rangers

    Saturday at 7:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
NBA
Final
ORL 100
MIL 115
 
Final
IND 103
NYK 82
3rd
MEM 71
DEN 47
 
10:30pm Tonight
LAL
CHI
Final
PROV 83
DEP 72
Final
RUTG 51
MSU 71
Final
ARMY 71
BU 67
 
Final
RFLSH 75
BRY 68
 
Final
MERC 75
CHAT 72
 
Final
LIU 67
CCST 55
 
Final
TOWS 74
COC 70
 
Final
UMASS 66
DAY 64
 
Final
FUR 59
ETST 55
 
Final
ODU 71
FIU 56
 
Final
RMU 87
FD 65
 
Final
CHAR 86
FATL 61
 
Final
LIB 53
HIGH 72
 
Final
UNF 86
KNST 67
 
Final
FLGC 78
LIP 62
 
Final
OSU 80
MD 56
Final
Terriers 73
MNTER 67
 
Final
STET 85
NKENTUCKY 75
 
Final
WAGN 75
SHU 64
 
Final
GMAS 68
STLU 60
 
Final
JVU 65
USCU 78
 
Final
VMI 70
WCU 85
 
Final
LATU 69
WKENT 56
Final
UNCG 42
WOFF 58
 
Final
DET 93
YOUNG 87
 
Final
GSOUT 83
APP 46
 
Final
TENNM 81
EILL 51
 
Final
GHND 64
HC 54
 
2nd
CIN 48
UCONN 35
 
2nd
NDST 38
DEN 39
 
2nd
SD 47
MAST 64
 
2nd
UWMIL 50
ILLCH 47
 
2nd
BEL 83
JVST 56
 
2nd
SMISS 46
MARS 66
 
2nd
TXSA 56
MTST 52
 
2nd
PETE 37
RIDE 37
 
2nd
SEMIZ 51
SIUE 59
 
2nd
TENST 58
TENT 50
 
2nd
NDAK 54
WEBER 56
 
2nd
SALA 60
LALAF 60
 
2nd
ARKST 38
ARKLR 37
 
Half
TROY 31
LAMON 21
 
2nd
TXARL 42
UGST 39
 
1st
MURST 19
EKENT 15
 
1st
NCOL 30
IDST 29
 
1st
MIZZ 15
KENT 16
 
1st
GONZ 20
PORT 19
 
1st
UTEP 18
UAB 25
 
1st
GRCN 22
UMKC 15
 
1st
WLVRN 19
CHIST 14
 
1st
USC 2
COL 6
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCI
CPSL
 
10:00pm Tonight
CSNO
HAW
 
10:00pm Tonight
PAC
PEPP
 
10:00pm Tonight
SDU
SCU
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCD
UCSB
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCLA
UTAH
10:05pm Tonight
PORST
MONT
 
10:05pm Tonight
SACST
MNTST
 
10:30pm Tonight
CSFU
LBSU
 
10:30pm Tonight
GAELS
LMU
 
11:00pm Tonight
WASU
CAL
11:00pm Tonight
BYU
USF
 
2nd Intermission
NYI 2
BOS 5
 
3rd
NYR 0
MON 1
 
3rd
PHI 4
WIN 2
 
3rd
TOR 1
ARI 1
 
3rd
FLA 2
CLB 2
 
3rd
TAM 5
DET 1
 
2nd
STL 3
NAS 2
 
1st
CAL 0
MIN 1
 
9:30pm Tonight
EDM
BUF
10:00pm Tonight
SJS
ANA