banner
Joe Ovies

Resistance to player pay shows lack of imagination

Posted July 18

"If you want to be a professional, be a professional," UNC athletic director Bubba Cunningham said during a discussion of whether student-athletes should be compensated.

Athletic directors from North Carolina, Duke, NC State and NC Central participated in Capitol Broadcasting's inaugural "Fan Town Hall" on Thursday. The discussions ranged from academic compliance, Title IX, "Power Five" conference autonomy and financial compensation for student-athletes. It was the rhetoric over that last issue that truly peaked my interest.

Dr. Kevin White, athletic director for the Blue Devils, made it clear that straight up payment for student-athletes was not on his priority list. In White's view, incoming players are getting a great deal considering the financial commitment already in place thanks to the scholarship and support staff.

"$62,000 plus strength coach, academic advisement, travel, per unit, who knows what it is – a half a million dollars per student-athlete at a private [institution]," said White. "I mean it's a pretty sizable investment."

Bubba Cunningham, athletic director of the Tar Heels, was a little more blunt on why paying student-athletes was a non-starter issue.

"If you want to be a professional, be a professional," said Cunningham. "The option here? Room, board, books, tuition and fees. The cost of attendance, the opportunity fund. We have Pell Grants. and you're going to get a great education. That's what we offer and if there's something better then I would love to have you do it."

However, the options for those interested in succeeding in the revenue sports of football and basketball don't have legitimate alternatives to playing at the collegiate level. There is no minor league football system for players to join and work on their skills as they wait for the NFL entry limit to expire. And do we really expect 18 year olds to go head-to-head against adults in Arena League Football or the CFL? Same goes for expecting high schoolers to head overseas to play basketball before they're eligible for the NBA.

Debbie Yow, athletics director for the Wolfpack, at least acknowledged schools are making money off the likeness of players.

"We're making money off the jersey, and they're not getting any of the money," said Yow. "I would be okay about the option of their having an escrow account. Maybe it's something small – 2 or 3  percent of the net or gross costs of that jersey goes into that escrow account, and once they either leave school to go pro or graduate he gets that money."

Dr. Ingrid Wicker-McCree, athletics director for the Eagles, echoed those sentiments. However, she was concerned about fairness.

"I wouldn't want to see that student-athlete not be able to capitalize off of their talent but at the same time keeping in mind it's much larger than that," said Wicker-McCree. "It's a fairness and equity issue for me."

White took it a little further.

"If Johnny (Manziel) gets to make a lot of money off of his celebrity, does he give a little to the offensive line? Where does it stop?" asked White. "What is Johnny without the offensive line? I'm not sure."

Actually, we can be sure how this plays out. We see it every day in the real world. Peyton Manning gets more than his offensive line. So does Cam Newton. This is how capitalism works, and there's no reason why student-athletes can't be exposed to it.

"How do you think this is for team morale," pondered Yow. "So you going to be passing the ball to me the next game or not because you were counting on that money from your jersey sale. The retailers didn't pick you, in fact you're pretty certain in your mind that your coach was the difference maker. You knew he didn't like you, you knew he liked me better, that's what you thought."

Except these issues already exist within a team dynamic without the involvement of money. Coaches overcome internal team politics by building trust and setting up concrete consequences for those whose grudges adversely effect the room. Coaches already manage assistant coaches and coordinators, how would this be any different? Especially when you consider all these issues are sustainable in the pros.

At best, the cautionary tales posed by White and Yow come off as either distractions from the real issue or a sign they haven't come up with workable solutions. At worst, it shows the athletic departments simply want to preserve the bottom line.

32 Comments

This blogpost is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • dbretz Jul 20, 9:24 p.m.

    I think the word you were looking for is piqued.

  • dmccall Jul 20, 2:51 p.m.

    Actually, support of player pay show "lack of imagination". Some people just don't understand the financial end of things.

  • jjackflash1966 Jul 18, 10:10 p.m.

    Bubba has some nerve claiming they will get a great education at eweNc. Let's just state the fac... View More

    — Posted by otis4411

    Otis, YOUR's is simply the dumbest, most ignorant post I've ever seen. Hate on, bro. It won't help you, one iota, which is why I want you to keep on hatin'.

  • huxter72 Jul 18, 10:10 p.m.

    The 4 baboons.

  • Hammerhead Jul 18, 9:25 p.m.

    This is so tired. The ultimate lazy media host simpleton topic. Tomorrow Pete Rose HOF?. If free... View More

    — Posted by canz

    It is not free. Steve Logan even admits it is a full-time job. But you well know there is... View More

    — Posted by uBnice

    They are compensated with what would be considered full time pay or more for their efforts.

  • uBnice Jul 18, 9:10 p.m.

    This is so tired. The ultimate lazy media host simpleton topic. Tomorrow Pete Rose HOF?. If free... View More

    — Posted by canz

    It is not free. Steve Logan even admits it is a full-time job. But you well know there is nothing free.

    Not everyone can be a D1 athlete. If they could they probably would. As much as we may think of the athletes as plentiful, they are not for this level of play.

  • vt94hokies Jul 18, 9:07 p.m.

    Bubba has some nerve claiming they will get a great education at eweNc. Let's just state the fac... View More

    — Posted by otis4411

    Solid one.

  • Objective Scientist Jul 18, 8:38 p.m.

    Bubba has some nerve claiming they will get a great education at eweNc. Let's just state the fac... View More

    — Posted by otis4411

    Michael McAdoo - most likely - could NOT have succeeded in any major on his own. He should never have been admitted as a student! All this talk about "opportunity"? The opportunity is focused 100% on ATHLETICS... not academics. Admit the kid - even if he is not even close to being academically equipped to succeed in the classroom - so that he can have the opportunity to play and partake of the "riches" of the NBA/NFL! The focus is NOT on the opportunity to obtain a degree or "get an education" - it is the opportunity to play ball at the next level!

  • roberttherugguy Jul 18, 8:36 p.m.

    500,000 per student, maybe at Duke Dr. White? And then there Is Ms. Yow "he" gets the money, so the women do not get paid? That will go over well.

  • otis4411 Jul 18, 8:20 p.m.

    Bubba has some nerve claiming they will get a great education at eweNc. Let's just state the facts here. Michael McAdoo lost his eligibility and also lost in court submitting plagiarized papers. (uncovered by packpride) eweNc released a statement saying they would still honor his scholarship so he could continue his education. When they said "continue" they meant it. They then stuck him back in those fake no show classes where he got no education. That is the Carolina Way and they have no shame talking about a great education.

More...

 

 

TV
  • The Logan Zone

    Tomorrow at 11:30 am on WRAL-TV

Scoreboard
Local
Final
NCCU 21
NCA 14
 
Final
DAVID 72
UNC 90
Final
ECU 34
TULA 6
 
2nd Intermission
COL 2
CAR 3
 
Half
DUKE 40
STAN 29
 
Final
ORL 92
MIA 99
 
Final
IND 83
PHO 106
 
Final
NYK 91
PHI 83
 
Final
CLE 93
TOR 110
 
4th
HOU 95
DAL 92
 
Final
MIN 101
SAC 113
 
Final
SAN 99
BRK 87
 
4th
MIL 86
WAS 97
 
3rd
UTA 61
NOP 72
 
Final
UGA 55
CHSO 9
Final
UF 52
EKU 3
Final
OSU 42
IND 27
Final
OKLA 44
KU 7
 
Final
UAB 18
MARS 23
Final
NEB 24
MINN 28
 
Final
PURD 14
NW 38
 
Final
ILL 16
PSU 14
Final
MSU 45
RUTG 3
Final
UCF 53
SMU 7
 
Final
SCAR 37
SALABAMA 12
Final
WKENT 45
TXSANANTO 7
 
Final
WAKE 6
VT 3
 
Final
ODU 30
LATU 27
Final
ARST 52
WASU 31
 
Final
CMICH 20
WMICH 32
 
Final
COLST 58
NMU 20
Final
LALAF 16
APPST 35
Final
BST 45
EMICH 30
Final
HOU 38
TULSA 28
Final
UTAH 10
ARZ 42
 
Final
FSU 20
BC 17
Final
UNT 17
FIU 14
 
Final
CLEM 28
GASTATE 0
 
Final
ND 28
LOU 31
 
Final
MICH 16
MD 23
 
Final
ARK 30
MISS 0
 
Final
PITT 30
SYR 7
 
Final
ISU 31
TTU 34
 
Final
ECU 34
TULA 6
 
Final
IOWA 24
WISC 26
 
Final
MEM 31
SFLA 20
 
Final
CAL 17
STAN 38
 
Final
NMST 17
LAMON 30
 
Final
ALA 48
WCAR 14
 
Final
OREG 44
COL 10
Final
MTST 35
FATL 34
 
Final
UVA 30
MIAMI 13
 
Final
AUB 31
SAMF 7
 
4th
TENN 13
MIZZ 29
 
4th
BAY 42
OKST 28
 
4th
MSST 51
VANDY 0
 
4th
UCONN 0
CIN 41
 
3rd
UCLA 38
USC 14
 
1st
WYO 0
BSU 0
 
1st
NEV 0
FRES 0
 
1st
WASH 0
ORST 0
 
11:00pm Tonight
HAW
UNLV
Final
PRIN 68
INCWORD 79
 
Final
UMASS 68
ND 81
Final
GEOR 80
RMU 66
 
Final
LAS 59
PETE 50
Final
VT 63
APP 65
 
Final
IUPUI 71
BST 69
 
Final
WMICH 91
DRAK 75
 
Final
RICH 80
HIGH 56
 
Final
MSST 71
UTST 63
Final
CAMP 48
COL 54
 
Final
DAVID 72
UNC 90
Final
NIOWA 66
UNF 49
 
Final
CSNO 79
SAMF 72
 
Final
YALE 61
MLOWELL 63
 
Final
NEV 50
CLEM 59
Final
PROV 80
FSU 54
 
Final
MARQ 89
NEOM 97
Final
DET 66
SALA 53
 
Final
TXSA 80
TXST 67
 
Final
CHIST 75
TRINCHRIS 52
 
Final
UMO 63
LIB 52
 
Final
BONA 59
CAN 53
 
Final
SAV 87
CLST 83
 
Final
NW 68
ELON 67
 
Final
RFLSH 57
MDES 53
 
Final
CARK 68
SEMIZ 74
 
Final
AFA 90
WSCO 60
 
Final
YOUNG 82
LONG 72
 
Final
MTST 66
SOUTH 48
 
Final
ARKLR 73
UMKC 68
 
Final
ABCHRIST 81
DUQ 102
 
Final
WEBER 58
LSU 72
 
Final
BUT 80
GHND 39
 
Final
CSFU 70
SJST 66
 
Final
WOFF 72
SD 68
Final
NORST 76
TXSOU 66
 
Final
COOK 42
TOWS 63
 
Final
SILL 46
YALE 53
 
Final
KNST 83
ALCOR 80
 
Final
MAN 78
BING 63
 
Final
JVST 88
MILES 71
 
Final
CSOU 79
WRST 86
 
Final
CITA 81
BOBJONES 50
 
Final
INDST 78
BRO 66
 
Final
WYO 56
COL 33
 
Final
GSOUT 97
FCCOL 41
 
Final
CCAR 76
PIEDINT 33
 
Final
LATU 63
AMER 44
 
Final
MAR 62
ARMY 76
 
Final
TENT 69
CHAT 67
 
Final
EKENT 115
CLERMONT 50
 
Final
SMU 77
EWASH 68
 
Final
NIAG 62
HART 65
 
Final
PENN 77
LAF 83
 
Final
UCSB 91
MASTERS 45
 
Final
BUCK 69
MNTER 73
 
Final
VMI 93
UNCW 110
 
Final
RIU 66
NEB 62
 
Final
NKENTUCKY 98
OHMWSTRN 48
 
Final
GTDNS 73
QUIN 76
 
Final
EMICH 70
UNCG 62
 
Final
ETST 98
UNCA 87
 
Final
TEMPL 50
UNLV 57
 
Final
STJOE 68
VERM 60
 
Final
MON 65
CCST 50
 
Final
KSU 78
ILLCH 60
 
Final
FAIR 60
SHSU 74
 
Final
LIP 74
TRANSYLVAN 63
 
Final
FUR 55
UCD 58
 
Final
WKENT 63
BEL 64
 
Final
NDST 74
HAMP 66
 
Final
IND 85
LAM 72
 
Final
TTU 80
MIZST 68
 
Final
HOU 72
MRGST 57
 
Final
NAVY 44
NE 68
 
Final
ALAAM 81
OAKW 61
 
Final
WILL 60
SELA 57
 
Final
TULA 89
SONO 45
 
Final
TXPA 82
A 77
 
Final
RICE 65
WMARY 69
 
Final
TXARL 87
HOUB 69
 
Final
MINN 69
UMBC 51
 
2nd
UTEP 50
NMST 54
 
2nd
GONZ 98
STTHOM 43
 
2nd
SUTAH 70
WLVRN 76
 
2nd
PBY 27
MORE 40
 
Half
DUKE 40
STAN 29
 
1st
WISC 22
BSU 16
 
1st
PORT 35
SIUE 19
 
Final
OTT 2
STL 3
Final
WAS 1
BUF 2
 
Final
PHI 4
CLB 2
 
Final
TOR 4
DET 1
 
Final
TAM 2
MIN 1
 
Final
BOS 0
MON 2
 
Final
NYI 4
PIT 1
 
Final
NAS 3
FLA 2
 
3rd
DAL 5
LOS 4
 
2nd Intermission
COL 2
CAR 3
 
1st
EDM 0
CHI 3
 
1st
CAL 0
NJD 2
 
1st
SJS 0
ARI 0
 
Final
NCCU 21
NCA 14