banner

Should ECU declare its independence?

Return to Forum
Newest First
  • Ken D. Jul 5, 1:27 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    Time seems to be running out on ECU's chances to join a BCS conference. Is it time they start to consider whether membership in C-USA is really worth it? I'd like to know how much money they actually get from the conference from their share of TV and bowl revenues. Then I'd like to know how much they have to spend for all their sports teams - not just football - to travel to conference games.

    I am quite willing to concede that the chances of ECU winning a NT in football are minuscule, whether they are in a conference or not. So if the Pirates don't want to compete for one at the FCS level, why not play football as an independent, and join a more geographically suitable conference for other sports? There are plenty of potential opponents closer than most C-USA schools that would be attractive home and home football partners.

    What are the pros and cons?

  • sportznut628 Jul 5, 1:53 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    For them it would be a win win....but who will take them......
    man are they going to get slobberknocked by Little Carolina on 9/3

  • blpack90 Jul 5, 2:12 p.m.
    Veteran

    I guess in football only it may make sense. They need C-USA or back to CAA for scheduling the other sports. They are good at setting up quality non-conf games; the league is so weak though. It is tough to be independent. May be easier to wait for the next conference re-alignment and pray someone needs one more team.

  • heelman73 Jul 5, 2:33 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    Didn't they go that route at some point before joining CUSA? Or, is my memory failing me again?

  • Ken D. Jul 5, 3:00 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    Didn't they go that route at some point before joining CUSA? Or, is my memory failing me again?... View More

    — Posted by heelman73

    The Pirates were independent from 1976 until they joined C-USA in 1997. The previous year, they were 8-3, with wins over South Carolina, Miami and NC State but were not invited to a bowl. Even in 1983, when they were also 8-3, losing by a combined 13 points to Florida State, Florida and Miami, and were ranked #20, they did not go to a bowl. I expect that had a lot to do with their decision to join a conference that had contractual bowl tie-ins.

    But what does that say about their attractiveness to a conference? Pirate fans talk about their dedicated fan base as a selling point for why a conference should want them. But repeatedly, bowls whose motivation is bringing fans to their city, have considered them an unattractive choice. Conferences notice things like that.

    If ECU were to be independent again, why would it be different now? And if it wouldn't be different, would independence be suicidal?

  • heelman73 Jul 5, 3:28 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    Didn't they go that route at some point before joining CUSA? Or, is my memory failing me again?... View More

    — Posted by heelman73

    The Pirates were independent from 1976 until they joined C-USA in 1997. The previous year, they... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Thanks. Good to know my memory is not completely shot.

    I don't think it would be any different now, and independence probably would be suicidal. They're not Notre Dame and just do not have the reputation to be able to pull in attractive bowl bids with 8-4, 9-3 records (although I do think that with the plethora of available bowl slots, they could pull in some of the lower ones - the kind you lose money by attending). I think their best bet is holding on and hoping for an invitation to a more attractive conference at some point.

  • TruthBKnown Banned Again02 Jul 5, 3:34 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    For them it would be a win win....but who will take them......
    man are they going to get... View More

    — Posted by sportznut628

    Maybe, maybe not (on your slobberknocked assertion). :)

  • Pirates of the East Jul 5, 3:46 p.m.
    All Star

    NO! Unless your Notre Dame and can force the BCS to give you an automatic bid if you finish in the top 10 (i think?), you will not have success as an indy. I would rather go 8-4 and be CUSA champs playing in the Liberty bowl, then have 10 wins and end up in the Armed Forces bowl like BYU will.

  • Ken D. Jul 5, 3:51 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    Didn't they go that route at some point before joining CUSA? Or, is my memory failing me again?... View More

    — Posted by heelman73

    The Pirates were independent from 1976 until they joined C-USA in 1997. The previous year, they... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Thanks. Good to know my memory is not completely shot.

    I don't think it would be any different... View More

    — Posted by heelman73

    You're right about the plethora of bowl spots. There aren't a lot of eligible teams getting left out these days. But a lot of the ones who go lose money as you point out. Their motivation for accepting those bids is the TV exposure and the extra practice time bowl teams are allowed.

    But what if ECU could put together an attractive slate of regional opponents that would boost their regular season attendance by 50,000 or so? That would require another stadium expansion probably, but it would yield more money than a bowl would.

  • Ken D. Jul 5, 4:03 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    NO! Unless your Notre Dame and can force the BCS to give you an automatic bid if you finish in... View More

    — Posted by Pirates of the East

    If my math is right, last year ECU's payout from C-USA for bowl revenue was about $500M. From that, they had to deduct their travel expenses, which means they netted very little, if anything. Central Florida went to Memphis and ECU went to Washington. I don't see one of those trips as all that much better than the other.

    It will be interesting to see how BYU does as an independent. If it pays off for them, more schools may try it (although there's no guarantee independence works the same for everybody).

  • heelman73 Jul 5, 4:09 p.m.
    Sports Legend

    ^^ But, could they put that slate together. They can be tough in Greenville, and most schools might view going there as not worth the risk. ECU may have to pay out more than they take in to entice schools to come. If so, have they gained anything (other than the exposure you mention). And, how long before even a higher payout fails to attract schools if ECU does manage to beat a few of them early on?

Newest First

Please to post.

  • NFL: Dallas at NY Giants

    Tonight at 8:30 on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
Local
Final
CREI 65
NCCU 45
 
Final
NCSU 68
SFLA 65
4th
MIA 92
CHA 93
 
4th
MIA 92
CHA 93
 
4th
MEM 105
LAC 88
 
Final
BOS 88
POR 94
 
Half
OKC 47
GSW 52
 
9:30pm Tonight
LAL
DEN
Final
GMAS 60
COC 61
Final
FSU 69
UMASS 75
Final
SHSU 53
WOFF 64
Final
UNCG 67
YOUNG 76
Final
CMICH 75
ARKPB 43
 
Final
ILLCH 60
SILL 67
Final
MORE 46
AMER 51
Final
CORN 59
DREX 61
Final
CCST 60
COOK 65
Final
ARKLR 94
CSNO 88
Final
LEH 44
CLMB 54
 
Final
USB 89
MERMAR 54
 
Final
NMU 51
TEXAM 64
Final
STLU 56
TAMCC 62
 
Final
FAIR 80
SD 72
Final
EMICH 79
LONG 48
 
Final
ND 74
PROV 75
Final
RAD 88
CATAWBA 52
 
Final
DEN 80
COPST 54
 
Final
UAB 58
JST 50
 
Final
WICHS 105
NWM 57
Final
OKLA 90
NWST 68
Final
KSU 59
YALE 66
Final
CREI 65
NCCU 45
 
Final
NCSU 68
SFLA 65
Final
UCR 102
STKAT 49
 
Final
PSU 63
USC 61
 
Final
HC 101
NICHOLSCOL 70
 
Final
BC 53
DAY 65
Final
MON 75
TOWS 79
Final
HOF 93
WAGN 71
 
Final
CIN 54
EILL 49
Final
UGA 74
FATL 61
 
Final
BRAD 58
NCAT 50
 
Final
LATU 76
PBY 48
 
Final
RUTG 76
Terriers 73
 
Final
SAMF 64
UMKC 55
 
Final
NAVY 70
BING 68
 
Final
SHU 85
GWEBB 67
 
Final
UNT 58
IONA 78
 
Final
KENT 86
MNTST 28
 
Final
FORD 57
MLOWELL 64
 
Final
UCF 76
USCU 69
 
2nd
SCAR 58
AKR 59
 
Half
WVU 47
UCONN 32
 
2nd
CALST 42
DEL 28
 
Half
HOW 46
HOOD 17
 
2nd
OSU 71
SHU 33
 
2nd
VANDY 46
TENST 25
 
1st
NE 15
MAN 14
 
1st
COLST 15
MERC 8
 
1st
MISS 10
NARZ 10
 
1st
WASH 14
PAC 9
 
8:00pm Tonight
LMU
SDCHR
 
9:00pm Tonight
CHAR
MIAMI
9:00pm Tonight
ILLST
ODU
9:00pm Tonight
GAELS
UCI
10:00pm Tonight
UCLA
LBSU
10:30pm Tonight
SEAT
MONT
 
Final
WIN 2
STL 4
2nd
NYR 2
MON 0
 
1st
ANA 0
ARI 0
 
9:30pm Tonight
VAN
CHI
Final
HOU 13
CIN 22
Final
ATL 24
CLE 26
Final
NEP 34
DET 9
Final
MIN 21
GBP 24
Final
IND 23
JAC 3
Final
CHI 21
TAM 13
Final
PHI 43
TEN 24
Final
SEA 19
ARI 3
Final
SDC 27
STL 24
Final
DEN 39
MIA 36
 
Final
SFX 17
WAS 13
8:30pm Tonight
NYG
DAL