Caulton Tudor

Hairston could be difference between top seed, .500 finish for Tar Heels

Posted August 2, 2013

— When North Carolina basketball coach Roy Williams put embarrassing junior forward P.J. Hairston on indefinite suspension earlier this week, it was the strongest indication yet that the Tar Heels 2013-14 season could be as unpredictable as Hairston’s eventful summer.

The 6-foot-5, 220-pounder from Greensboro has been in and out of trouble since May but was the offensive leader on last season’s 25-11 (12-6 ACC) team averaging 14.6 points and converting a team-high 89 three-point shots.

Although the details of Hairston’s relationship with Durham resident Haydn (Fats) Thomas haven’t yet been clarified, there seem to be three distinct end-game possibilities for his availability to the team in the coming season. Here’s the breakdown:

SCENARIO 1: Hairston plays the entire season

This is the least likely but obviously the most optimal outcome in terms of wins and losses.

In a likely lineup with James Michael McAdoo, Marcus Paige, Leslie McDonald and Brice Johnson – plus five or six additional contributors – Hairston and the Tar Heels would be a national top 10 team and probably the ACC’s best.

By far, Duke’s the popular pick. But don’t forget the Blue Devils lost their three top scorers (Mason Plumlee, Seth Curry, Ryan Kelly) and will have to forge a new offense, not to mention a new chemistry, around transfer Rodney Hood, freshman Jabari Parker and returnee Andre Dawkins.

If the Heels could have Hairston for the entire run, they would be my preseason league favorite over Duke, Syracuse and Notre Dame and a near lock for a No. 1 NCAA regional seed.

SCENARIO 2: Hairston is suspended for 10-14 games

This would be a situation marginally similar to last season, when Hairston really didn’t emerge as a consistent force until the final 15 or so games.

But unlike a year ago, there would be no Reggie Bullock around to shore up the perimeter offense unless McDonald (36 percent on 3s last season) surfaces as a first-team all-conference candidate.

If Hairston were to sit out 10 games, he’d be back in time for the entire ACC schedule but wouldn’t play against Louisville (Nov. 24), Michigan State (Dec. 4), Kentucky (Dec. 14), Texas (Dec. 18) and Davidson (Dec. 21).

But should a suspension extend to 14 games – or more – he would start to miss conference play. The impact of a 10-14 game penalty would likely do a great deal of harm to the team’s NCAA fate and certainly its seeding.

Williams would still have a lot of options with Johnson, J.P. Tokoto, Joel James, Jackson Simmons and Desmond Hubert, in addition to newcomers Nate Britt, Isaiah Hicks and Kennedy Meeks.

But with Hairston sitting for such a prolonged period, there would be a chemistry adjustment upon his return and the 25-win total of last season virtually impossible to match.

A reasonable projection would be an 11-7 ACC record and 20-10 overall.

SCENARIO 3: Hairston doesn’t play in 2013-14

It is  very possible that Williams' patience has reached an end and Hairston won't see the court at all this season.

At best, Hairston has made enough irrational decisions to become an ongoing problem for the school and the program. At worst, he’s a perpetual dumpster arsonist whose potential for mayhem is limitless in and outside the locker room.

Clearly, the Tar Heels could be a second-division ACC team without his perimeter shooting and offensive rebounding abilities.

On the other hand, Williams eventually will return the Heels to an inside-oriented offensive attack, and the loss of Hairston for the entire season would jump-start that process.

Hairston’s sudden emergence as a dynamic scorer late last season lifted the team but it also blurred the mural.

UNC's strong finish – 6-1 to end the regular season – overshadowed the fact that Heels failed to score 70 or more points 10 times, were held to 53 by Duke in the final regular-season game and needed overtime to defeat hapless Virginia Tech, 72-60, in Chapel Hill.

Why? There was no inside scoring punch, which has been the program’s passport to big winning for the past half century.

Like all teams, UNC needs perimeter shooters, but Williams understands better than anyone that offenses function best when they operate on a inside-first foundation.

Without Hairston for an entire season, the Heels would have the look of a 9-9 ACC, 18-12 overall team but the low-post rebuilding process could start one season ahead of schedule.


Please with your account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Newest First
View all
  • Dooksucksv8 Aug 2, 2013

    UNC would not be a #1 seed even with PJ, they still have a core of very young guys.
    They will not finish .500 either even if PJ does not play. This guy simply does not know UNC basketball very well.

  • TarHeel4Real Aug 2, 2013

    So, Carlton Tudor thinks Hairston playing or not playing would be a big difference?

    No duh, Sherlock!

  • Triumph Aug 2, 2013

    Mr. Tutor's column should correctly be titled "Hairston makes difference between UNC being on probation or not".

  • 903 PJ suspended til NCAA clears Aug 2, 2013

    They'll finish better without him available. He's shown his true colors this summer in terms of his selfishness and how little he values his team and coaches. Without him, the remaining team will have more balance on the floor and one fewer player playing just to pad his stats for the NBA draft...

  • itsnotmeiswear Aug 2, 2013

    I could just as easily make the argument that with Hairston's dismissal that the team becomes more of a team, and they play better. It's basketball. Upper classmen develop their skills and get smarter. Freshmen change the whole dynamic of a team. Every team has the same issues with chemistry.

    I will be surprised and disappointed if Roy doesn't suspend Hairston for at least the first semester. It might hurt the team, but the young man needs some sort of wakeup call before he hurts himself or someone else.

  • BlueDevils00 Aug 2, 2013

    LOL @ Tudor saying UNC would be the ACC's best and a lock for a #1 seed with Hairston!!!!!!

    I needed a good laugh this morning.

    Even with PJ, UNC is not better than Duke or Syracuse, and honestly it's not even very close. Paige is a mediocre PG and McDonald has done nothing in 4 seasons. Brice Johnson is too weak and they still would have nearly no reserve guards.

    What a joke

  • jdupree Aug 2, 2013

    Roy does not have the character/moxie to suspend PJ for the entire season. He will play after a meaningless 9 game suspension.

  • cjw6105 Aug 2, 2013

    I don't buy Scenario 3. Why would Williams suspend a player that he didn't intend to play all season? Logic says if Williams didn't intend to play Hairston, he would have dismissed him from the team.

    The answer as to why Hairston wasn't dismissed is in the title of this story.

  • Road-wearier Aug 2, 2013

    Ol' Roy will knuckle under and put Hairston back in the lineup by the time the League play starts. He doesn't have the courage to kick the kid off the team which what he'd have done to a #12 player down the bench.

    Of course we can hope the new chancellor will lean on him to do the right thing...

  • lanecc Aug 2, 2013

    Hairston will play this season. Otherwise Coach would have dismissed him from the team. Granted, the shenanigans by Hairston were typical college stunts but he is not the typical college student. It would show a lot of character on Coaches' part to dismiss him for the entire season. Put the reputation of the team and the school above all else. Not gonna happen.




  • MiLB: Bulls v. Norfolk

    Tomorrow at 7:00 pm on METV 50.2

  • Bundesliga Soccer: Ingolstadt vs Bayern Munich

    Saturday at 9:00 am on FOX50

  • NHL Playoffs: St. Louis at Dallas

    Saturday at 12:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • Kentucky Derby

    Saturday at 4:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • MiLB: Bulls v. Norfolk

    Saturday at 5:00 pm on METV 50.2

  • NHL Playoffs: Pittsburgh at Washington

    Saturday at 7:15 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NASL: RailHawks vs. Ft. Lauderdale

    Saturday at 7:30 pm on WRAL-2

  • NHL Playoffs: NY Islanders at Tampa Bay

    Sunday at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • MLB: LA Dodgers vs. Toronto

    Saturday at 1:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • Kentucky Derby

    Saturday at 5:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • NASL: RailHawks vs. Ft. Lauderdale

    Saturday at 7:30 pm on 1550 The Ticket

  • NBA Playoffs: Golden State at Portland

    Saturday at 8:30 pm on 99.9 The Fan

ATP Scoreboard
Thursday, May 5
Third Round
(2) A. Murray6 6    
(16) G. Simon4 2    
(8) T. Berdych710 7    
(9) D. Ferrer68 5    
(6) K. Nishikori6 7    
(10) R. Gasquet4 5    
(1) N. Djokovic6 6    
(15) R. Bautista A2 1    
N. Kyrgios77 4 6   
P. Cuevas65 6 3   
(7) J. Tsonga4 4    
(11) M. Raonic6 6    
J. Sock1 77 2   
J. Sousa6 63 6   
(5) R. Nadal6 6    
S. Querrey4 2    
WTA Scoreboard
Thursday, May 5
L. Chirico77 6    
D. Gavrilova61 2    
(6) S. Halep6 0 6   
I. Begu3 6 1   
D. Cibulkova4 6 6   
S. Cirstea6 3 3   
S. Stosur6 6    
P. Tig3 4