Colleges

Landlord, tenant relations grow stale between NC State and Canes

Posted June 4, 2013
Updated June 5, 2013

The PNC Arena Saturday afternoon before the Carolina Hurricanes last Saturday home game. (photo by Wes Hight).

— For more than a decade, the Carolina Hurricanes have played grateful tenant at PNC Arena because the North Carolina State Wolfpack, and its leadership, was amicable in scheduling negotiations with the professional franchise.

Somewhere in the last few years, however, that courteous compromise has been lost and the two sides find themselves in a battle of both words and home.

When asked Tuesday what has changed in the relationship, Hurricanes president and general manager Jim Rutherford responded, “I don’t want to comment on that. I have an answer for it, but I would prefer to try and work through this and make it work for both sides.”

Documents obtained Tuesday by WRAL News show an active record of communication over the past year between Rutherford, NC State administrators – including athletics director Debbie Yow and Chancellor Randy Woodson – and Dave Olsen, the vice president and general manager of PNC Arena.

In those records, NC State representatives repeatedly claim to be going above and beyond in compliance with the terms of the contract dated June 19, 1997. However, a Sept. 6, 2012, letter from Yow to Olsen, which was endorsed by basketball coach Mark Gottfried, paints a different picture.

“We regret that abiding by the contract terms could make scheduling NHL games more challenging,” Yow wrote. “That said, our goal is to build a championship-caliber basketball program and the scheduling terms of the contract are designed to support achievement of that goal.”

The terms of the contract agreement state that NC State shall hold all priorities when it comes to scheduling at PNC Arena. The contract also stipulates that both the Wolfpack and visiting teams get use of the facility for pre-game practice. Furthermore, the contract instructs that the use of the arena “requires coordination between the Authority (arena management) and NC State University to promote its most efficient use.”

The last of those terms has become the major point of contention for Rutherford because the NHL has warned the Hurricanes of potential fines if the team cannot keep scheduled games.

“We respect the fact that NC State gets priority dates. We know Saturdays and Wednesdays are important for them because of televised ACC games,” Rutherford said. “What we don’t respect is that they tie up all the dates to play a minimal amount of games.”

Rutherford added in a January letter to Woodson that if the Hurricanes did not play in the arena, losses to the operating company of the Hurricanes would amount to roughly $10 million annually and millions more would be lost in tax revenues and payment to the City of Raleigh, Wake County and the state.

A regular season NHL schedule requires 41 home dates between October 1 and the first week in April. Per the agreement, PNC Arena may also be booked between the months of September and May for events such as graduation ceremonies, the circus, Disney on Ice, the Harlem Globetrotters and professional wrestling. In 2000, the agreement was amended to block out a week in December and February for the circus and Disney on Ice.

“This is a unique situation,” Rutherford said.

Another controversial point between the two sides is the calendar itself. The NHL requires scheduling dates be submitted in time for a July release date. The ACC does not release their schedules until late August, affording NC State more time but putting the Hurricanes at risk of hundreds of thousands of dollars in league fines.

“Through working together and mutual compromise, we have consistently been able to maximize the utilization, and thereby the financial health, of PNC Arena,” Olsen wrote in a letter dated Sept. 24, 2012. “NC State has now taken the position that we must grant them 100 percent priority over all dates at PNC Arena without regard to the reasonableness of what is best for the Authority, the City, the County, the State, Gale Force, the Hurricanes or fans that attend the events.”

Olsen continued to say that without compromise, the venue risks losing major concerts and would never have hosted the NHL All-Star game.

Rutherford added in a May 14 letter that they were specifically told that the current administration at NC State “will not be as flexible as previous administrations,” and that “the number of events will be significantly reduced as more shows will skip PNC Arena due to the lack of available dates.

Rutherford outlined losses to the venue from August to November because NC State stakes claim to 28 dates while only playing “six to seven” football games. He said NC State claims 42 of 92 dates between October and January despite playing only “eight potential home games.” Then, Rutherford added that from January to the end of basketball season, NC State is claiming 59 of 88 calendar dates for “a total of eight potential basketball games.” In all, Rutherford states that NC State has staked claim to 129 of 214 calendar days, including 26 of 30 days in November, for a combined total of 23 Wolfpack sporting events.

Conversely, Woodson said that NC State has complied fully to the terms of the agreement despite giving up a week in February to the circus, which puts the Wofpack “at a competitive disadvantage.” Woodson added that they have also relinquished 11 of 13 Fridays between October and December, reserving only Oct. 11 for “Primetime with the Pack” and Nov. 8 for the basketball team’s regular season home opener. Dec. 3-4 were also reserved in anticipation of the ACC/Big Ten Challenge.

NC State football, which shares a parking lot with PNC Arena, requested April 20 for the annual spring game. Woodson said concessions were also made on that date due to a 7 p.m. hockey game that forced the Wolfpack to cancel otherwise planned events.

Rutherford indicated that meetings will be planned in the near future to better deal with the scheduling issue. He said that meetings have occurred in the past with little or no resolution.

125 Comments

This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • jbengel Jun 24, 12:24 p.m.

    Sorry Canes, but YOU are 2nd fiddle here. You deserted Hartford for this chance to make money... View More

    — Posted by morgannyy

    "Free" home? The Canes ownership put up almost 40% of the money to build that barn, and if they hadn't, it would still be on the drawing board. Centennial Authority spent 10 years talking about it before Karmanos announced the move, then suddenly... In any case, it was anything BUT a freebie.

  • evenflow2005 Jun 10, 12:47 p.m.

    Yow, Yow, Yow, Bu, Bu, Yow, Yow, Yow.........

  • WufSkins Jun 6, 1:05 p.m.

    Isn't it ironic that this issue never grew into something this big until Yow was in the picture?... View More

    — Posted by caniac315

    Because she's doing her job unlike Lee Fowler?

  • TsKaMF Jun 6, 12:32 p.m.

    This is still being discussed ? Why ?

    "The terms of the contract agreement state that NC State shall hold all priorities"

    ^^^Contract

  • Ken D. Jun 6, 11:26 a.m.

    The irony in all of this is that State had enough money to build its own arena in the 90's. Lawrence Joel Arena in Winston-Salem, which seats 14,655 for basketball, was built for about $20 million. The price tag for a 23,000 plus facility proved too much, but some State boosters refused to listen to Valvano, who said it was too big. He wanted a facility of no more than 16,000 capacity, which over the years since has proven to be at or above State's actual attendance at the PNC Center.

    State could have had a great venue, with luxury boxes and all, but it wasn't good enough. Instead, they wound up settling for sharing an arena they can't fill consistently. Not great decision making there.

  • common tater Jun 6, 11:04 a.m.

    126 dates reserved for 23 State games...yep...sounds like sound State math to me. This is the capital's only pro sports team...and the only pro sports team in the state with a national title...they don't deserve this type of childish power grab.

  • Ken D. Jun 6, 10:59 a.m.

    NC Sate does not belong in that arena anyway.....why can't they remodel the heck out of Reynolds... View More

    — Posted by cfazio62

    My thoughts exactly. We should go back to Reynolds. In fact, I will go so far as tyo say that... View More

    — Posted by tayled

    Well, the intent was to build a BBall only facility where the PNC currently lies. Then the State... View More

    — Posted by ncstatefan215

    The intent was to build a basketball only facility, but State found out it couldn't afford to do that. State didn't "oblige" anybody. They agreed to share an arena they could not have had otherwise. A large part of that agreement required both major tenants to cooperate. State has now stated publicly that it no longer intends to do that. Eventually, they will realize they have to back down from that, just as they had to back down from their plan to "one up" Carolina with a 23,000 seat arena.

    In the meantime, get used to the huffing and puffing.

  • Bob Sidel Jun 6, 10:57 a.m.

    NCSU is Raleigh, NC! As a lifetime resident I have always been disappointed that we got an NHL... View More

    — Posted by robertporter

    Sounds like it's you that doesn't belong in NC anymore, Robert. Or do you go by Bo?

  • Bob Sidel Jun 6, 10:52 a.m.

    NC Sate does not belong in that arena anyway.....why can't they remodel the heck out of Reynolds... View More

    — Posted by cfazio62

    My thoughts exactly. We should go back to Reynolds. In fact, I will go so far as tyo say that... View More

    — Posted by tayled

    Well, the intent was to build a BBall only facility where the PNC currently lies. Then the State... View More

    — Posted by ncstatefan215

    State ran out of money to build their facility, that's why there was a pile of dirt sitting for years where the PNC now stands until the Canes jumpstarted the actual construction.

  • caniac315 Jun 6, 10:35 a.m.

    Isn't it ironic that this issue never grew into something this big until Yow was in the picture? I am not a Yow fan.

More...

 

 

  • The Logan Zone

    Today at 11:30 am on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Washington at Philadelphia

    Today at 1:00 pm on FOX50

  • NFL: Oakland at New England

    Today at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Denver at Seattle

    Today at 4:25 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Green Bay at Detroit

    Today at 1:00 pm on 620am

  • NHL: Hurricanes vs. Columbus

    Today at 1:30 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • NFL: Kansas City at Baltimore

    Today at 4:30 pm on 620am

  • NFL: Panthers vs. Pittsburgh

    Tonight at 8:30 on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
Local
Final
DUKE 47
TULA 13
Final
ECU 70
UNC 41
Final
TOWSN 31
NCCU 20
 
Final
NCSU 42
PRES 0
 
1:30pm Today
CAR
CLB
 
8:30pm Tonight
CAR
PIT
Final
KAN 2
DET 3
Final
CHC 8
LOS 7
Final
OAK 0
PHI 3
Final
NYY 3
TOR 6
Final
COL 5
ARI 1
Final
BAL 7
BOS 2
Final
PIT 0
MIL 1
Final
TAM 3
CWS 1
Final
MIN 3
CLE 7
Final
ATL 2
NYM 4
Final
HOU 10
SEA 1
Final
MIA 2
WAS 3
Final
STL 8
CIN 4
Final
SDP 3
SFG 2
Final
ANA 8
TEX 5
1:05pm Today
NYY
TOR
 
1:10pm Today
MIA
WAS
 
1:35pm Today
BAL
BOS
 
1:35pm Today
PIT
MIL
 
1:35pm Today
ATL
NYM
 
1:40pm Today
TAM
CWS
 
2:10pm Today
MIN
CLE
 
2:10pm Today
KAN
DET
 
2:10pm Today
HOU
SEA
 
2:20pm Today
CHC
LOS
 
3:35pm Today
ANA
TEX
 
4:05pm Today
OAK
PHI
 
4:10pm Today
COL
ARI
 
4:10pm Today
SDP
SFG
 
8:05pm Tonight
STL
CIN
 
Final
WISC 68
BGU 17
Final
MSU 73
EMICH 14
Final
VT 24
GT 27
Final
PITT 20
IOWA 24
Final
RICE 42
ODU 45
Final
UGA 66
TROY 0
Final
SYR 20
MD 34
Final
DUKE 47
TULA 13
Final
COL 21
HAW 12
Final
AKR 17
MARS 48
Final
WAKE 24
ARMY 21
Final
KU 24
CMICH 10
Final
ALA 42
UF 21
Final
FIU 3
LOU 34
Final
ECU 70
UNC 41
Final
NAVY 24
RUTG 31
Final
SMU 6
TEXAM 58
Final
MICH 10
UTAH 26
Final
BYU 41
UVA 33
Final
WYO 20
FATL 19
Final
MIZZ 27
IND 31
Final
PSU 48
UMASS 7
Final
MINN 24
SJST 7
Final
ILL 42
TXST 35
Final
WASH 45
GASTATE 14
Final
SMISS 21
APPST 20
Final
TOL 34
BST 23
Final
OHIO 36
IDAHO 24
Final
CIN 31
UMO 24
Final
MEM 36
MTST 17
Final
LSU 29
MSST 34
Final
ARK 52
NILL 14
Final
ARKST 21
UTST 14
Final
SALABAMA 6
GASO 28
Final
WVU 33
OKLA 45
Final
VANDY 34
SCAR 48
Final
NEB 41
MIAMI 31
Final
NMST 35
NMU 38
Final
HOU 47
UNLV 14
Final
FSU 23
CLEM 17
Final
ARZ 49
CAL 45
Final
ORST 28
SDST 7
Final
WASU 31
OREG 38
Final
BSU 34
LALAF 9
1:30pm Today
CAR
CLB
 
5:00pm Tonight
WAS
BUF
 
6:30pm Tonight
CLB
STL
 
8:00pm Tonight
EDM
CAL
 
8:00pm Tonight
CAL
EDM
 
1:00pm Today
CLE
BAL
1:00pm Today
STL
DAL
1:00pm Today
DET
GBP
1:00pm Today
NYG
HOU
1:00pm Today
JAC
IND
1:00pm Today
NOS
MIN
1:00pm Today
NEP
OAK
1:00pm Today
BUF
SDC
1:00pm Today
CIN
TEN
1:00pm Today
PHI
WAS
4:05pm Today
ARI
SFX
4:25pm Today
SEA
DEN
4:25pm Today
MIA
KAN
8:30pm Tonight
CAR
PIT
Final
TOWSN 31
NCCU 20
 
Final
NCSU 42
PRES 0