Caulton Tudor

Maryland v. ACC could have far-reaching precedent

Posted January 15, 2014

The case may take months or years to be completely decided, but Maryland’s lawsuit against the ACC will be closely monitored by colleges and their lawyers throughout the nation. At stake, potentially, is the perceived stability conferences thought they had achieved through the relatively recent arrival of grants of television rights covenants.

The ACC formed such an union in April of 2013, roughly six months after Maryland announced it would leave the league after 2013-14 to join the Big Ten, which also has a grant of rights treaty among its members. So does the Big 12 Conference. The ACC pact runs through the length of its television contract with ESPN in 2027.

In theory, grant of rights agreements bind each conference member to its partners through what roughly works like a communal banking account.

The $156.8 million lawsuit filed Tuesday by the Maryland attorney general’s office is not related to any sort of grant of rights agreement. It originated with Maryland's resistance to a $52.2 million ACC exit penalty – an agreement Maryland ratified as an ACC member in September of 2012. 

The state and the school allege that the exit penalty should not apply as a result of procedural incidents and that the ACC has no right to withhold revenue shares from the school as the case plays out. But since the crux of the suit goes to the subject of conference/school agreements, it’s not out of the question that grant of rights pacts could be tangentially affected by the eventual court ruling or even an out-of-court settlement. 

Here’s why, through a completely hypothetical example:

Let’s say UNC, just to pick an ACC school, leaves the league and is accepted as a member of the Big Ten two or three years from now.

The ACC obviously would sue, claiming its authority via the grant of rights television covenant. But in joining the Big Ten, UNC would have entered a second grant of rights union and there are few, if any, legal precedents in such matters involving television networks, colleges, conferences and chain of command. At some point, given that scenario, the NCAA would be drawn into the fray since members of both the ACC and Big Ten are also bound to NCAA agreements regarding sports eligibility.

It’s entirely possible that after a long court fight, judges could rule any number of ways:

  • UNC’s media income could be ruled to be jointly owned by the ACC and Big Ten.
  • UNC could be ruled a sovereign sports entity and the sole owner of its product rights.
  • The entire matter could be shipped directly to arbitration, thereby assuring that both conferences would suffer some degree of disappointment.
  • Both conference covenants could be ruled illegally restrictive on free trade and completely voided.

There’s an old saying that no contract is ironclad. Whether that statement is accurate or not, it’s certain that there’s no way to stop any school or any conference from suing for its freedom (in the case of a school) or antimony (conference).

If recent history has taught us anything, it’s that there is no predicting where and when the conference realignment process will go, much less where and when it will end.

The outcome of Maryland’s suit over the exit-fee issue will serve as an important indicator of how the courts will view what has become a collegiate sports wild west show, complete with border raids, shot-gun weddings and financial range wars.

Collectively, college sports has become a billion-dollar-a-year industry that shows no sign of tapering. In fact, given the current growth rate of sports marketing and likelihood that more sports-oriented media outlets will emerge as technology advances, current TV contracts could be seen as pocket change in the future.

With so much money on the table, more lawsuits are likely to flare up. That much is inevitable, which is why Maryland v. the ACC will be must-see action in the boardrooms. And, of course, for law students from the Ivies to the Pac-12.

7 Comments

Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Steven Jan 16, 2014

    Maryland was sold a bill of goods thinking they were going to make more money and save them in the Big Ten. All their old rivals are going to be gone and they are going to have less folks show up for their games. They are crazy if they think the Big Ten Network is going to make them as much money as they think it will. Hope they crash and burn for abandoning the ACC and have serious regrets about it down the road. Outside of forced matchups, their old ACC rivals will never play them.

  • StunGunn Jan 15, 2014

    I think the ACC will do everything in its power to ensure Maryland does pay the $52 Mill, as the decision in this case will set a precedent. The penalty was set high deliberately, to discourage schools from bolting. I do remember Maryland (and I believe Florida State) voted against the exit fee, but the majority of schools voted in favor of it, so it was ratified.

    I have no bad feelings toward Maryland; they are in a terrible financial bind and leaving the ACC seemed like a viable solution to their financial woes.

    This situation has the potential to get quite ugly before it's over, and that's a shame, because there will be no winners, only bitter feelings and more financial issues.

  • 903 Hail Providence Jan 15, 2014

    View quoted thread


    Would you rather have had the Big East raid the ACC and survive and then have the ACC deteriorate to the American conference or whatever it is? (Gtown, Butler, Nova and a bunch of other mid-majors)?

  • Ken D. Jan 15, 2014

    It originated with Maryland's resistance to a $52.2 million ACC exit penalty – an agreement Maryland ratified as an ACC member in September of 2012. Maryland did not "ratify" this provision. It opposed it, and did not vote for it. Maryland has claimed in its countersuit that league rules do not allow the conference to impose this penalty immediately upon achieving a favorable vote. I don't know if this claim is, in fact, true. Maryland gave official notice of its intent to leave the conference four days before the date the Terps claim the rule could first be effective.

    I expect the outcome of this case to be determined on such contractual issues, unless it is first settled out of court. Frankly, I think it's in everybody's interest (except maybe fans) that there be a negotiated settlement. Nobody should want any precedents established.

  • Ken D. Jan 15, 2014

    Antimony? Where did you get that word, Mr. Tudor? Are you sure you don't mean something like hegemony instead?

  • baldchip Jan 15, 2014

    University of Maryland-you signed the contract with the other Universities in the ACC !! I guess that does not matter any more. Humm-I wonder what folks at your Law School would say to that. Is the integrity of the University of Maryland that poor???

    That being said-I'm glad you're leaving. Aamen-Aamen!!! Just pay up before you leave-or all the ACC will haunt you forever!!

  • cjw6105 Jan 15, 2014

    The ACC was at the forefront of "conference raiding". Thanks to them, the Big East Conference exists primarily on the basketball court. And ACC football, never much to begin with, is now even weaker than before, with more rivalries being destroyed in order to make sure everybody gets "equal" treatment.

    I've never been much of a Maryland fan, but this is one time I'm pulling for the Terps. The ACC started all this mess, so let them reap what they've sewn.

  • ACC Blitz

    Saturday at 12:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CFB: Liberty at Virginia Tech

    Saturday at 12:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NASCAR: Xfinity Series - Darlington

    Saturday at 3:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • The Logan Zone

    Sunday at 11:00 am on WRAL-TV

  • Golf Special: Road to the Ryder Cup

    Sunday at 2:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • Golf: Deutsche Bank Championship

    Sunday at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NASCAR: Sprint Cup - Darlington

    Sunday at 6:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • Golf: Deutsche Bank Championship

    Monday at 1:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • FanTownHall: Race Relations in American Sports

    Tonight at 7:00 on 99.9 The Fan

  • NFL: Panthers at Pittsburgh

    Thursday at 7:30 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • CFB: NC State vs. William & Mary

    Thursday at 7:30 pm on WRAL-FM

  • High School OT Live

    Friday at 7:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • Fan Town Hall: Athletes, race and social issues

    Tonight at 7:00

    More Info
AP Top 25
Thu, Sept 1
4:00 PT5:00 MT6:00 CT7:00 ET11:00 GMT7:00 北京时间4:00 MST6:00 EST
19
 
4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET11:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST
9
Fri, Sept 2
4:00 PT5:00 MT6:00 CT7:00 ET11:00 GMT7:00 北京时间4:00 MST6:00 EST
12
 
4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET11:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST
23
 
6:00 PT7:00 MT8:00 CT9:00 ET1:00 GMT9:00 北京时间6:00 MST8:00 EST
8
Sat, Sept 3
3
9:00 PT10:00 MT11:00 CT12:00 ET4:00 GMT12:00 北京时间9:00 MST11:00 EST
15
 
9:00 PT10:00 MT11:00 CT12:00 ET4:00 GMT12:00 北京时间9:00 MST11:00 EST
7
 
9:00 PT10:00 MT11:00 CT12:00 ET4:00 GMT12:00 北京时间9:00 MST11:00 EST
6
 
11:00 PT12:00 MT1:00 CT2:00 ET6:00 GMT2:00 北京时间11:00 MST1:00 EST
14
 
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
17
 
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
21
 
16
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
 
5
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
 
2:00 PT3:00 MT4:00 CT5:00 ET9:00 GMT5:00 北京时间2:00 MST4:00 EST
24
 
18
2:30 PT3:30 MT4:30 CT5:30 ET9:30 GMT5:30 北京时间2:30 MST4:30 EST
22
 
4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET11:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST
25
 
20
5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET12:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST
1
 
5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET12:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST
13
 
2
6:00 PT7:00 MT8:00 CT9:00 ET1:00 GMT9:00 北京时间6:00 MST8:00 EST
Sun, Sept 4
10
4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET11:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST
Mon, Sept 5
11
5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET12:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST
4
 
NFL Preseason
Wednesday, Aug. 31
Washington 5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET0:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST7:00 CT4:00 UAE (+1)20:00 ET23:00
Tampa Bay 
Thursday, Sep. 1
Jacksonville 4:00 PT5:00 MT6:00 CT7:00 ET23:00 GMT7:00 北京时间4:00 MST6:00 EST6:00 CT3:00 UAE (+1)19:00 ET22:00
Atlanta 
 
Tennessee 4:00 PT5:00 MT6:00 CT7:00 ET23:00 GMT7:00 北京时间4:00 MST6:00 EST6:00 CT3:00 UAE (+1)19:00 ET22:00
Miami 
 
New England 4:00 PT5:00 MT6:00 CT7:00 ET23:00 GMT7:00 北京时间4:00 MST6:00 EST6:00 CT3:00 UAE (+1)19:00 ET22:00
NY Giants 
 
NY Jets 4:00 PT5:00 MT6:00 CT7:00 ET23:00 GMT7:00 北京时间4:00 MST6:00 EST6:00 CT3:00 UAE (+1)19:00 ET22:00
Philadelphia 
 
Pittsburgh 4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET23:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST6:30 CT3:30 UAE (+1)19:30 ET22:30
Carolina 
 
Indianapolis 4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET23:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST6:30 CT3:30 UAE (+1)19:30 ET22:30
Cincinnati 
 
Buffalo 4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET23:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST6:30 CT3:30 UAE (+1)19:30 ET22:30
Detroit 
 
Chicago 5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET0:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST7:00 CT4:00 UAE (+1)20:00 ET23:00
Cleveland 
 
Houston 5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET0:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST7:00 CT4:00 UAE (+1)20:00 ET23:00
Dallas 
 
Green Bay 5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET0:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST7:00 CT4:00 UAE (+1)20:00 ET23:00
Kansas City 
 
Los Angeles 5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET0:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST7:00 CT4:00 UAE (+1)20:00 ET23:00
Minnesota 
 
Baltimore 5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET0:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST7:00 CT4:00 UAE (+1)20:00 ET23:00
New Orleans 
 
Denver 6:30 PT7:30 MT8:30 CT9:30 ET1:30 GMT9:30 北京时间6:30 MST8:30 EST8:30 CT5:30 UAE (+1)21:30 ET0:30
Arizona 
 
Seattle 7:00 PT8:00 MT9:00 CT10:00 ET2:00 GMT10:00 北京时间7:00 MST9:00 EST9:00 CT6:00 UAE (+1)22:00 ET1:00
Oakland 
 
San Francisco 7:00 PT8:00 MT9:00 CT10:00 ET2:00 GMT10:00 北京时间7:00 MST9:00 EST9:00 CT6:00 UAE (+1)22:00 ET1:00
San Diego 
 
MLB Scoreboard
Interleague
Cincinnati 7:05 PT8:05 MT9:05 CT10:05 ET22:05 ET2:05 GMT10:05 7:05 MST9:05 EST9:35 VEN6:05 UAE (+1)9:05 CT
Preview
LA Angels 
American League
Toronto04:05 PT5:05 MT6:05 CT7:05 ET19:05 ET23:05 GMT7:05 4:05 MST6:05 EST6:35 VEN3:05 UAE (+1)6:05 CT
Preview
Baltimore0
 
Tampa Bay04:10 PT5:10 MT6:10 CT7:10 ET19:10 ET23:10 GMT7:10 4:10 MST6:10 EST6:40 VEN3:10 UAE (+1)6:10 CT
Preview
Boston0
 
Minnesota 4:10 PT5:10 MT6:10 CT7:10 ET19:10 ET23:10 GMT7:10 4:10 MST6:10 EST6:40 VEN3:10 UAE (+1)6:10 CT
Preview
Cleveland 
 
Chi White Sox04:10 PT5:10 MT6:10 CT7:10 ET19:10 ET23:10 GMT7:10 4:10 MST6:10 EST6:40 VEN3:10 UAE (+1)6:10 CT
Preview
Detroit0
 
Seattle05:05 PT6:05 MT7:05 CT8:05 ET20:05 ET0:05 GMT8:05 5:05 MST7:05 EST7:35 VEN4:05 UAE (+1)7:05 CT
Preview
Texas0
 
Oakland05:10 PT6:10 MT7:10 CT8:10 ET20:10 ET0:10 GMT8:10 5:10 MST7:10 EST7:40 VEN4:10 UAE (+1)7:10 CT
Preview
Houston0
 
NY Yankees05:15 PT6:15 MT7:15 CT8:15 ET20:15 ET0:15 GMT8:15 5:15 MST7:15 EST7:45 VEN4:15 UAE (+1)7:15 CT
Preview
Kansas City0
National League
Washington04:05 PT5:05 MT6:05 CT7:05 ET19:05 ET23:05 GMT7:05 4:05 MST6:05 EST6:35 VEN3:05 UAE (+1)6:05 CT
Preview
Philadelphia0
 
San Diego04:10 PT5:10 MT6:10 CT7:10 ET19:10 ET23:10 GMT7:10 4:10 MST6:10 EST6:40 VEN3:10 UAE (+1)6:10 CT
Preview
Atlanta0
 
Miami04:10 PT5:10 MT6:10 CT7:10 ET19:10 ET23:10 GMT7:10 4:10 MST6:10 EST6:40 VEN3:10 UAE (+1)6:10 CT
Preview
NY Mets0
 
Pittsburgh 5:05 PT6:05 MT7:05 CT8:05 ET20:05 ET0:05 GMT8:05 5:05 MST7:05 EST7:35 VEN4:05 UAE (+1)7:05 CT
Preview
Chi Cubs 
 
St. Louis05:10 PT6:10 MT7:10 CT8:10 ET20:10 ET0:10 GMT8:10 5:10 MST7:10 EST7:40 VEN4:10 UAE (+1)7:10 CT
Preview
Milwaukee0
 
LA Dodgers05:40 PT6:40 MT7:40 CT8:40 ET20:40 ET0:40 GMT8:40 5:40 MST7:40 EST8:10 VEN4:40 UAE (+1)7:40 CT
Preview
Colorado0
 
Arizona07:15 PT8:15 MT9:15 CT10:15 ET22:15 ET2:15 GMT10:15 7:15 MST9:15 EST9:45 VEN6:15 UAE (+1)9:15 CT
Preview
San Francisco0
 
Canadian Pacific (LPGA)
PosNameScoreThru
1A. Jutanugarn-23F
2S. Kim-19F
3I. Chun-18F
4A. Sharp-16F
5tA. Nordqvist-15F
5tK. Webb-15F
7tC. Choi-13F
7tL. Ko-13F
7tA. Lee-13F
10tM. Martin-12F
View Full Leaderboard
 
Boeing Classic (CHMP)
PosNameScoreThru
1B. Langer - z-13F
2tK. Sutherland - y-13F
2tW. Austin - y-13F
4G. Sauers-12F
5K. Triplett-11F
6tB. Jobe-10F
6tF. Funk-10F
6tS. Ames-10F
6tT. Byrum-10F
6tJ. Durant-10F
View Full Leaderboard
z = Won in Playoff   y = Lost in Playoff
 
ATP Scoreboard
Tuesday, Aug. 30
US Open (ATP/WTA)
First Round
(14) N. Kyrgios     
A. Bedene     
R. Berankis     
M. Jaziri     
I. Dodig     
I. Marchenko     
(6) K. Nishikori6 6 3 6  
B. Becker1 1 6 3  
(27) A. Zverev3 6 6 77  
D. Brands6 1 4 64  
(22) G. Dimitrov6 6 79   
I. Cervantes2 4 67   
K. Khachanov6 6 4 6  
T. Fabbiano3 3 6 3  
P. Carreno Bu6 7 6   
I. Ivashka0 5 2   
J. Chardy6 6 6   
M. Mmoh4 4 1   
D. Evans6 4 7 6  
R. Ram2 6 5 1  
V. Troicki5 3 6 6 77 
R. Albot7 6 4 4 65 
(11) D. Ferrer6     
A. Dolgopolov5     
(12) D. Goffin6 5 4 0  
J. Donaldson4 7 6 6  
D. Kudla6 4 1 6 0 
A. Giannessi0 6 6 1 6 
(25) P. Kohlschrei3 5 0   
N. Mahut6 7 1   
(29) S. Querrey64 77 3 3  
J. Tipsarevic77 60 6 6  
(3) S. Wawrinka77 6 6   
F. Verdasco64 4 4   
(16) F. Lopez3     
B. Coric4     
(17) B. Tomic4 3 6 60  
D. Dzumhur6 6 4 77  
P. Mathieu6 6 6   
C. Harrison0 2 1   
H. Zeballos6 6 79   
F. Mayer3 4 67   
V. Estrella B0 1 1   
J. Sousa6 6 6   
D. Schwartzma4 4 3   
J. Del Potro6 6 3   
T. Gabashvili711 6 65 5  
F. Fognini69 3 77 5  
(21) I. Karlovic4 77 64 3  
Y. Lu6 64 77 3  
D. Young6 7 4 0  
J. Struff3 5 6 0  
C. Berlocq0     
P. Lorenzi1     
(8) D. Thiem6 0    
J. Millman3 0    
M. Granollers2     
J. Monaco2     
(30) G. Simon1     
R. Stepanek1     
(19) S. Johnson3     
E. Donskoy5     
(2) A. Murray 
L. Rosol 
 
WTA Scoreboard
Tuesday, Aug. 30
US Open (ATP/WTA)
First Round
(10) K. Pliskova     
S. Kenin     
(4) A. Radwanska     
J. Pegula     
(29) A. Ivanovic64 1    
D. Allertova77 6    
(5) S. Halep6 6    
K. Flipkens0 2    
L. Safarova6 6    
D. Gavrilova4 4    
(31) T. Babos5 6 7   
B. Haas7 3 5   
H. Watson2 5    
R. Hogenkamp6 7    
(20) K. Bertens3 6 4   
A. Konjuh6 2 6   
(25) C. Garcia4 6 6   
P. Parmentier6 3 4   
L. Arruabarre2 3    
Y. Shvedova6 6    
(23) D. Kasatkina4 6 2   
Q. Wang6 2 6   
K. Siniakova6 3 6   
E. Bouchard3 6 2   
(15) T. Bacsinszky6 6    
V. Diatchenko1 1    
(16) S. Stosur7 64 6   
C. Giorgi5 77 1   
(19) E. Vesnina77 4 6   
A. Kontaveit64 6 3   
N. Gibbs6 6    
A. Krunic1 0    
K. Knapp4 2    
J. Larsson6 6    
S. Zhang6 6    
E. Perez1 1    
A. Beck78 6    
N. Podoroska66 3    
K. Nara6 7    
S. Voegele0 5    
(17) A. Pavlyuchen6 6    
L. Chirico1 4    
M. Duque-Mari4 1    
J. Jankovic6 6    
(11) C. Suarez Nav6 6    
T. Pereira0 0    
N. Broady64 6 6   
L. Robson77 3 4   
D. Kovinic5 2    
M. Gonzalez7 6    
V. King77 6    
A. Lottner62 3    
J. Goerges6 6    
Y. Wickmayer3 2    
(6) V. Williams6 5 5   
K. Kozlova2 7 3   
S. Peng6 69 0   
V. Lepchenko4 711 0   
(26) L. Siegemund3 1    
P. Tig6 0    
N. Hibino4 3    
K. Mladenovic6 4    
(1) S. Williams 
E. Makarova