banner
Mike Maniscalco

MLB trying to get everything right

Posted August 1, 2013

— The notion that instant replay will ruin baseball is ridiculous.

I’m tired of hearing about how taking two minutes to make sure a call is correct takes away from the game. The argument is, ‘where does it stop? Are you going to review balls and strikes?’

“It will take too long and ruin the flow of the game,” scream the curmudgeons that hate change.

I love baseball - its history and nuances. But there is no distinct flow to a baseball game. Each half-inning is its own event, which is why it is a different game than ones measured by a clock. An inning can take seven minutes or 37. Those who are screaming that a replay would take too long and disrupt the game should think the same thing when a player and manager get ejected for arguing a missed call.

A few calls this season on the base paths have cost teams victories – or at the very least the chance to continue on and earn a win. Major League Baseball can get it right and do so in a hurry.

Safe or out is not an opinion, it is a black-and-white call and far more clear than what the NFL defines as a catch. As for reviewing balls and strikes, the NFL doesn’t review holding on every play - which is common sense.

There is now enough technology and camera angles to make replay easy to use for umpiring crews to get the calls right. Any resistance to making a change for the better is outdated thinking.

Baseball trying to make up for past sins
Baseball is looking to put a lifetime ban on Alex Rodriguez. The slugger, who just a decade ago was considered one of the best ever to play the game, has had his reputation ruined by being involved with Biogenesis, the company linked to giving PED’s to several high-profile athletes.

Baseball should suspend Rodriguez, but this seems like the MLB front office might be trying to hand out a punishment that it failed to assign to the group that really shamed the game. Baseball could not give Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Mark McGwire or other famous steroid users a ban like this because they were not looking hard enough for the abusers during their time of smashing records.

I should say accused so Roger Clemens does not get too upset.

Rodriguez should also do the game a favor and not fight a suspension that falls short of lifetime banishment. The evidence seems to be overwhelming that he had ties to this latest steroid outbreak in baseball and any contest to those facts would be an insult to the game he wants to stay in.

In case you wondered…
One of the biggest complaints I hear about baseball is that it is the same teams battling it out in the playoffs every year. Since 2008, baseball has had 21 different teams make the post season, the NFL has had 26. Before you think that disproves my point, remember baseball for the majority of that time only allowed eight teams in the post season while the NFL lets 12 teams enter the playoffs.

So maybe, just maybe, baseball has been doing something right.

3 Comments

This blogpost is closed for comments.

Newest First
View all
  • GunnyGoesBaaaarf Aug 1, 3:46 p.m.

    I agree that baseball should use replay; when the wrong team wins, which has happened, it justifies and makes replay worthwhile.

    Also agree about A-Rod. Fool me once,..... A-Rod has already lied about using PED's, so I don't think it's a stretch to believe he hasn't come clean this time either. At 38, baseball doesn't even have to give him a lifetime ban, and he certainly shouldn't be able to collect the $100-mil the Yankees may owe him should he be able to play again.

  • BattlingBishop 5 Aug 2, 5:02 a.m.

    Agreed, Mike. It doesn't matter how long it takes as long as they get it right.

    Does anybody associated with MLB like A-Rod? That would be a very short list.

  • Hokies94 Aug 2, 2:11 p.m.

    It's long overdue for MLB to get everything right as the title suggests. Think in terms of decades.

  • CBB: North Carolina vs. Ohio State

    Tomorrow at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CBB: UCLA vs Kentucky

    Tomorrow at 3:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: San Diego at San Francisco

    Tomorrow at 8:25 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Panthers vs. Cleveland

    Monday at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CBB: UCLA at Kentucky

    Tomorrow at 3:15 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • NFL: Philadelphia at Washington

    Tomorrow at 4:25 pm on 620am

  • NHL: Canes vs. NY Rangers

    Tomorrow at 7:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • CBB: NC State at West Virginia

    Tomorrow at 9:30 pm on WRAL-FM

Scoreboard
Local
3rd
PHI 53
CHA 74
 
3rd
PHI 53
CHA 74
 
3rd
ORL 57
UTA 70
 
2nd
CLE 45
BRK 45
 
Half
BOS 53
MIN 48
 
Half
DET 52
TOR 52
 
2nd
MIA 51
WAS 52
 
2nd
MEM 22
CHI 20
 
2nd
SAN 20
POR 17
 
9:00pm Tonight
DEN
LAC
10:30pm Tonight
LAL
OKC
Final
YOUNG 92
WILB 71
 
Final
TULA 56
JST 49
 
Final
RAD 76
SIENA 66
 
2nd
BUCK 76
CASEWEST 59
 
2nd
LIB 74
CPNC 55
 
2nd
SCAR 54
CLEM 37
 
2nd
CMICH 79
CONC 52
 
2nd
MIAMI 29
EKENT 43
 
2nd
GWEBB 84
HIWASSEE 58
 
2nd
ODU 46
MDES 35
 
2nd
BUF 54
NIAG 34
 
2nd
KSU 46
NCAT 38
 
2nd
FAM 43
UNF 62
 
2nd
NORST 61
NARZ 43
 
2nd
DART 42
NILL 36
 
2nd
MORE 48
NKENTUCKY 64
 
Final
UCSB 69
SDCHR 46
 
2nd
STJ 33
GAELS 39
 
2nd
ALA 47
STILL 29
 
2nd
HAMP 49
TENST 43
 
2nd
TENN 50
TENT 48
 
2nd
WMARY 77
WSHMD 39
 
Half
MERC 33
COOK 24
 
Half
FLGC 38
FUR 34
 
2nd
CALST 30
SDKST 30
 
1st
MTST 16
CHAT 14
 
1st
NDAK 15
DICKINSON 7
 
1st
LAMON 22
LSUALEX 19
 
1st
PRIN 40
LIP 25
 
1st
LAM 31
MLGN 19
 
1st
MINN 22
SEAT 15
 
1st
LOYC 22
SUTAH 9
 
1st
SELA 29
WINT 28
 
1st
SILL 17
NO 16
 
9:00pm Tonight
MARQ
ALAAM
 
9:00pm Tonight
TTU
ARKPB
 
9:00pm Tonight
DEN
COLST
9:00pm Tonight
CREI
TXPA
 
10:00pm Tonight
CAL
EWASH
10:05pm Tonight
UTST
IDST
 
11:00pm Tonight
UTEP
ARZ
11:59pm Tonight
CHAM
HAW
 
2nd
NJD 2
TAM 1
 
2nd
OTT 2
ANA 0
 
2nd
DET 1
NYI 1
 
1st
WIN 1
BOS 0
 
9:00pm Tonight
CAL
DAL