Adam Gold

Baseball balks on guidance for Hall voters

Posted January 9, 2013

The National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.

Officially, that is the name of the Baseball Hall of Fame and so many forget those last two words "and Museum."

On Wednesday afternoon, we'll learn the results from the last year of Hall of Fame balloting and find out how many, if any, of the former stars of the game will see their careers enshrined. Unfortunately, over the last decade we've come across a problem that has no easy answer and the museum has left it up to each individual voter to determine its meaning.

Steroids.

We have no idea when the steroid era began. Most people assume that players became acutely aware of anabolic steroids and other performance-enhancing agents in the early-to-mid 1990s. But, if the East German women's swimming team was all using steroids in the 1970s, why couldn't we also have seen some in baseball begin using around the same time? There's just no feasible way of telling when the steroid age began, especially when you consider that the league, the players, the players' union and the media who is charged with covering the game ignored what had grown obvious to most people for years.

Since the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum hasn't drawn up any criteria to deal with steroids and how to consider those implicated or detected, it's up to each voter to decide for himself what impact they may have had on each player's career.

Even within the issue of performance-enhancers there's a divide. Are they disqualified because they cheated or is it a case of simply not buying into the inflated statistics?

For five seasons, Sammy Sosa was one of the most feared hitters in the game – totaling 292 home runs between 1998-2002. That's an AVERAGE of 58.4 home runs per year.

But wait a minute, until 2005, steroids and other anabolic agents weren't against the rules. Well, that's not entirely true. Steroids have always been against the rules, there was even a 1993 letter from then-commissioner Fay Vincent to each individual team reminding them that steroids were against the law and thus against the rules of the game. However, since the league was unable to administer drug tests – random or otherwise – there was no way to detect users and there were no punishment guidelines on the off chance that a player would ultimately be caught.

As the great shortstop Phil Rizzuto, himself a member of the hall, might say, "HOLY COW!"

We've only begun to scratch the surface of the quandary facing the nearly 600 members of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA) who are eligible to fill out a ballot.

Some won't consider anyone from the steroid era – implicated or not. Some, either through what they saw or some advanced statistical formula, will try and make an educated guess as to the impact steroids had on each player's credentials. Others will ignore the steroid issue altogether. And, while it seems odd to essentially excuse cheating of that kind, you could make a logical case that every player is judged against every other player against whom they competed on a yearly basis. If the best of every era have found their way into the Hall why can't the best of the so-called "steroid age" as well.

It's now that we return to the "museum" portion of the story. Museums are supposed to tell the entire history of their subject matter. The good, the bad, the failures, the successes and even the embarrassing episodes in the timeline of its existence. To ignore the last two decades does the game a complete disservice. To single players out because we know, or we think we know, or we heard whispers from those who claim to know, and let others slide is arbitrary. On top of that, while most of us believe that performance-enhancing agents have a positive impact – why take them otherwise – there is simply no credible scientific study that tells us exactly what that impact is. I mean, did steroids make Barry Bonds 5 percent, 15 percent, or 50 percent better? Did Roger Clemens extend his career by 5 years, 8 years or did it have no impact at all? And, in the case of these two players, weren't they Hall of Fame-caliber players before it's widely believed that they started enhancing? 

Gray enough for you yet?

Finally, there's also the little matter of those players who might have used yet managed to escape detection. Jeff Bagwell and Mike Piazza are both on this year's ballot and both have never been mentioned in an official document accusing them of using anything to inflate their own performance. But, that doesn't mean they didn't. What if we find out five years from now, after both Bagwell and Piazza have delivered their acceptance speeches and had fans file past their plaques, that both did inject, swallow or rub-in something that kept them in the sport, at the top of the league leaders, for a few additional years? What happens then?

It's time. It's time for the game to own up to its entire history. It's time for the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum to charge its voting members with simply electing the best players historically with consideration given to the era in which they competed. Just using career statistical data is not only unfair but outdated as well. Ballparks are different today than they were 25 years ago. Baseballs are different today than they were 35 years ago. The rules of the game are different than they were 45 years ago (before then, pitching mounds were not limited to being 12 inches high, which gave pitchers a tremendous advantage – go look it up).

How we consider those good enough to be in the Hall of Fame needs to evolve with the times as well. Sure, we should pay close attention to baseball's history. Sure, it's fair to measure the career performance of today's stars against the likes of Henry Aaron or Willie Mays. And yes, we even need to adjust our thinking to include the age of specialization. Ace relievers and designated hitters have been in the game for four decades, it's time to stop excluding them based on their given role. Consider their total impact. Take "points" away for the things they didn't do. Use whatever intangibles you like. But, don't exclude because, as a DH, he wasn't a real "player."

I will draw the line on specialization at situational left-handed relievers. I don't care if you haven't allowed a home run to a left-handed batter in your 18-year career. You get one out a game, maybe three a week, go collect your paycheck and let others bask in the fullness of their contributions.

Here are the questions I would ask myself were I privileged to be a BBWAA voter:

Was the player, at any point in his career, considered to be the best, or among the best, at his position? If so, for how long?

How did his performance stack up against his peers and those at his position, historically?

What was his impact in the postseason? Granted, not every player had the chance to perform in those situations, so this really is more of an extra credit part of the questionnaire, but there are some who deserve that extra consideration. I suppose that John Smoltz, when he shows up on the ballot in a few years, will be one who will benefit from his playoff success.

Now that we've asked and answered those questions about everyone on the ballot, lets make sure that we don't leave out any of the story. If you were found to have taken steroids, Alex Rodriguez, let's make sure it's mentioned on your plaque. Put up all the statistics. List the home runs, the Most Valuable Player awards, how your agent announced you were opting out of your contract while the rival Red Sox were wrapping up a World Series sweep – as in during the game. Then we can also read about how, during those loosey-goosey times, you and your cousin took to the streets of the Dominican Republic and you were introduced to steroids. Personally, I'd leave off the men's magazine photo shoot in which you appeared to be kissing yourself in the mirror, but if there's room on the wall I wouldn't be against inclusion. It's all part of your history.

If you wished to place all the players from the steroid era in the same part of the museum, that would be fine as well. Then we could do the same for the all-white era. Forgot about that, did you? Not allowing a collection of superb ballplayers to compete in Major League Baseball based on the color of their skin certainly could have been a performance-enhancer for some prior to 1947. Just sayin'.

So, before we're done, here's my ballot if I had one.

1-Barry Bonds. Hate him or despise him, he was the best player in the game before he ever got to San Francisco and he was still that before the time it is generally thought he started creaming and clearing – allegedly. A seven-time MVP, 14-time All Star and a winner of eight Gold Gloves, he ranks first all-time in home runs and walks, is third in runs scored and fourth in runs batted in.

2-Roger Clemens. Hate him or misremember him, he was the best pitcher in the game before former Boston, and current Baltimore General Manager Dan Duquette declared that he was "on the downside of his career."  354 wins, 4,672 strikeouts, seven Cy Young Awards and an MVP should be enough.

3-Mike Piazza. The greatest-hitting catcher of all time. He was obviously not a stellar defensive player, but 90 percent of the hitters in the Hall weren't either. 427 career home runs, 396 of which came as a catcher, plus a 12-time All Star and a rookie of the year.

4-Curt Schilling. Even if you don't believe the bloody sock story, Schilling is deserving of being in the Hall of Fame. 216 career wins in a 20-year career. He was a six-time All Star, three-time 20-game winner and three times he struck out more than 300 batters in a single season. Schilling is also one of the greatest postseason performers of all time – 11-2 with a 2.23 ERA in 19 postseason starts, 4-1 with a 2.03 in the World Series, and both the 1993 NLCS and 2001 World Series MVP.

5-Tim Raines. For a decade, the National League's version of Rickey Henderson. Simply the best lead-off hitter in the senior circuit while with Montreal. His 808 career stolen bases are the fifth highest total of all time. He played before the offensive explosion took place, yet still scored 100 or more runs six times and during an era which placed far more value on the stolen base, he swiped 453 in his first six full seasons in the big leagues – at least 70 each year.

6-Rafael Palmeiro. Don't wag your finger at me. He was as productive a hitter as the game had over a 15-year period. Four times an All Star, three times a Gold Glove winner and he ranks in the top 25 all-time in hits (3,020), home runs (569), RBIs (1,835) and doubles (585). He also had a stretch in which he drove in at least 100 runs in 10 consecutive (non-strike) seasons.

7-Sammy Sosa. In spite of his convenient inability to understand English when spoken by members of Congress, Sosa's 609 career home runs are the eighth best total of all time. He had nine straight seasons of at least 100 runs batted in and over a five year span of his career (1998-2002) he hit 292 home runs, an average of 59.4 per year. He won the MVP in 1998 and was named to seven All-Star teams.

That's my list. You may have yours. You might have fallen asleep while reading.

13 Comments

Please to add a comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • StunGunn Jan 12, 2:46 p.m.

    Can't stand people who use the, "Just sayin" to attempt to make a point. Maybe, there... View More

    — Posted by lec02572

    I appreciate your statement. The 1st sentence especially. Worn out term. Elementary at best. ... View More

    — Posted by hokies94vt@gmail.com

    You forgot, "It is what it is". For some reason that one and, "At the end of the day" and "at the same time" have become so commonplace with regards to sports.

  • cjw6105 Jan 12, 11:49 a.m.

    I beg to differ on who's the greatest hitting catcher of all time. No disrespect for Mike Piazza, but I'll take Yogi Berra and Johnny Bench as the best.

    I believe that MLB did the only thing they COULD do by omitting Bonds and Clemens. They got that one right. What they HAVEN'T gotten right yet is to put Pete Rose in the HOF. Rose never used substances to enhance his performance, and although he's not well-liked, who said HOF credentials should include a "good citizenship" award? Rose may have bet on baseball, but only after he became a manager. Ban him from baseball for that, but if you're going to put his bats and such in the HOF, then the player should be included too.

    And one more- the greatest right-handed pitcher, at least in the modern era, is Nolan Ryan. Why would anyone else even think otherwise?

  • sburks1906 Jan 10, 9:51 a.m.

    The voters got this one wrong. Bonds and Clemens were among the best of all time at their positions before the alleged steroid use. And keep in mind that neither of them failed a drug test.
    http://wp.me/p1gCK6-z1

  • hpr641 Jan 10, 9:48 a.m.

    "if the East German women's swimming team was all using steroids in the 1970s, why couldn't we also have seen some in baseball begin using around the same time?"

    Simple: The East German's were getting the PED's from their Dr.'s ... who because of the number of athletes involved, could tweak and adjust the PED use as necessary based on the results they saw relative to the other PED-using swimmers (and non-PED swimmers from other countries). Whereas, basically until BALCO, MLB players really didn't have much help knowing exactly how to take PED's and maximize the benefits of them. Thus, I really don't believe PED's were used in MLB until the '90's because the players just didn't have much way to find out, not how to get PED's, but simply how to really use them.

    I suspect the majority the majority of non-pitchers that used PED's used them to help themselves get to as high a physical peak on Opening Day as possible ... and then didn't really use them much at all during the season. I suspect some pitchers may have also (or instead) taken them to a degree during the season to help their throwing shoulder and elbow recover more quickly by cuttin down on inflammation.

  • dukefanv12 Jan 9, 4:35 p.m.

    Brian mackay is the best you could do? Someone who has a legit opinion would have brought someone on the show who has a different (and the majority) opinion.

    Also, I think dbretzbetweentheears only wants the illegitimate's in the HOF, similar to his opinions....

  • dbretz Jan 9, 2:39 p.m.

    The baseball HOF is now officially illegitimate, as no one gets in this year. Adam is spot in with his #s 1-3 on his list. The baseball writers just left off arguably the second best offensive player of all time, the best right handed pitcher of all time, and the best offensive catcher of all time. I don't buy Adam's insinuation that because it is the Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum that that should change anything about who gets in the Hall. The Hall is simply part of the larger museum. It stands on its own. Having said that, what the writers are doing stands head and shoulders over anything I've seen in sports in a long time in terms of ego. The baseball HOF process is now on par with reality television.

  • They call me CATMAN Jan 9, 2:32 p.m.

    Just read a breaking story NO one was elected to the Hall of Fame with names like Barry Bonds, Sammy Sosa, Roger Clemens & Mike Piazza all suspected of using performance-enhancing drugs I am glad to see this. Baseball is a great sport but it is time to put baseball in the spotlight for a good reason not a bad one. When Pete Rose can't get in for what he did and when the 4 names listed above are even in Consideration then the game of Baseball will continue to be stained.

  • hokies94vt@gmail.com Jan 9, 2:04 p.m.

    Can't stand people who use the, "Just sayin" to attempt to make a point. Maybe, there... View More

    — Posted by lec02572

    I appreciate your statement. The 1st sentence especially. Worn out term. Elementary at best. And another one is: "with that being said." "At the end of the day."

  • wingate Jan 9, 1:55 p.m.

    Sorry Adam, but it is very easy to tell when someone has abused steroids AKA Bonds, Mac and Sosa. They all suddenly appeared to have altered bodies like they were stuffed into their uniforms. These three almost certainly benefited from from steroids. It is true that the effect of the steroids is impossible to quantitate. However, these guys knowing cheated and should be omitted from the hall. If nothing else out of respect for those that played fairly and either made it in or did not make in.

  • dukefanv12 Jan 9, 1:45 p.m.

    Thank goodness ag has no vote. I'm calling on the b1g ten to take ag with maryland, and it will be a good riddance to both.

More...

 

 

  • PGA: Waste Management Phoenix Open

    Today at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • Big 10: Michigan at Michigan State

    Tomorrow at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • ACC: Duke at Virginia

    Tonight at 7:00 on 620am

  • NHL: Hurricanes at NY Rangers

    Tonight at 7:00 on 99.9 The Fan

  • Super Bowl: Seattle vs. New England

    Tomorrow at 6:30 pm on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
Local
1st OT
GT 69
NCSU 68
 
4:00pm Today
LOU
UNC
7:00pm Tonight
NYR
CAR
7:00pm Tonight
UVA
DUKE
7:00pm Tonight
ETST
NCCU
 
9:00pm Tonight
DEN
CHA
7:00pm Tonight
ORL
DAL
7:00pm Tonight
IND
SAC
 
7:00pm Tonight
WAS
TOR
7:30pm Tonight
DET
HOU
7:30pm Tonight
ATL
PHI
8:00pm Tonight
MIN
CLE
8:00pm Tonight
MEM
OKC
8:30pm Tonight
MIL
POR
9:00pm Tonight
DEN
CHA
9:00pm Tonight
SAN
LAC
10:30pm Tonight
GSW
PHO
2nd
TENN 67
AUB 63
 
Final
CLEM 64
BC 49
 
2nd
STJOE 74
DAVID 70
 
1st OT
GT 69
NCSU 68
 
Final
PITT 76
ND 72
 
2nd
STJ 73
PROV 62
 
Final
UNH 63
USB 48
 
Final
WVU 77
TTU 58
 
Final
TEMPL 55
TULA 37
 
Final
EMICH 69
WMICH 63
 
Final
IOWA 63
WISC 74
2nd
SHU 87
XAV 82
 
2nd
UF 35
ARK 30
 
2nd
STET 30
LIP 40
 
Half
ILL 30
PSU 26
 
2nd
TULSA 32
SFLA 36
 
2nd
INDST 23
BRAD 26
 
1st
MAINE 5
GTDNS 8
 
2:00pm Today
UGST
ARKST
 
1st
LEH 6
BU 4
 
1st
MARQ 5
BUT 7
 
1st
DEL 2
COC 4
 
1st
CREI 0
GEOR 7
 
1st
CLST 9
UWGB 8
 
1st
NEOM 4
MAST 2
 
1st
LOYC 2
ILLST 2
 
1st
KU 10
KYST 4
 
1st
JVU 0
KNST 0
 
1st
MSST 5
LSU 3
 
1st
SHU 2
MNTER 8
 
1st
VCU 2
RICH 2
 
1st
ISU 9
TCU 9
 
1st
BING 2
MLOWELL 3
 
1st
HART 7
VERM 10
 
2:00pm Today
DEP
VILL
1st
WAKE 2
VT 0
 
3:00pm Today
FAM
COOK
 
3:00pm Today
NDAK
IDST
 
3:00pm Today
ARMY
GHND
 
3:00pm Today
BEL
TENT
 
3:00pm Today
TXSA
UAB
3:00pm Today
ILLCH
VALPO
 
3:05pm Today
DRAK
EVAN
 
3:15pm Today
IND
RUTG
3:30pm Today
UMO
BST
 
4:00pm Today
RMU
BRY
 
4:00pm Today
WAGN
CCST
 
4:00pm Today
GWEBB
CCAR
 
4:00pm Today
MDES
COPST
 
4:00pm Today
RFLSH
FD
 
4:00pm Today
RIU
GWU
4:00pm Today
SCAR
UGA
4:00pm Today
Terriers
LIU
 
4:00pm Today
PAC
LMU
 
4:00pm Today
STLU
UMASS
4:00pm Today
HOW
MRGST
 
4:00pm Today
DREX
UNCW
 
4:00pm Today
LOU
UNC
4:00pm Today
MIZZ
MISS
4:00pm Today
ALCOR
SOUTH
 
4:00pm Today
NIOWA
WICHS
4:00pm Today
JMU
WMARY
 
4:00pm Today
RAD
WINT
 
4:15pm Today
EILL
SIUE
 
4:30pm Today
UNCA
CAMP
 
4:30pm Today
MORE
EKENT
 
4:30pm Today
NICST
INCWORD
 
4:30pm Today
CMICH
OHIO
 
4:30pm Today
TEXAM
VANDY
5:00pm Tonight
UWMIL
DET
 
5:00pm Tonight
LAMON
SALA
 
5:00pm Tonight
UNCG
WCU
 
5:05pm Tonight
EWASH
IDAHO
 
5:30pm Tonight
SDKST
DEN
 
5:30pm Tonight
SHSU
HOUB
 
5:30pm Tonight
MVSU
JST
 
5:30pm Tonight
TXST
LALAF
 
5:30pm Tonight
LATU
MARS
5:30pm Tonight
SD
ORU
 
6:00pm Tonight
PVU
ALAAM
 
6:00pm Tonight
GRAM
ARKPB
 
6:00pm Tonight
PRIN
DART
 
6:00pm Tonight
SCST
DELST
 
6:00pm Tonight
COLST
FRES
6:00pm Tonight
NORST
HAMP
 
6:00pm Tonight
MINN
NEB
6:00pm Tonight
WYO
NEV
6:00pm Tonight
SAV
NCAT
 
6:00pm Tonight
GAELS
PEPP
 
6:00pm Tonight
NW
PURD
6:00pm Tonight
BAY
TEX
6:00pm Tonight
CHAT
CITA
 
6:00pm Tonight
SMISS
WKENT
6:00pm Tonight
CORN
YALE
 
7:00pm Tonight
LAM
ABCHRIST
 
7:00pm Tonight
BGU
AKR
 
7:00pm Tonight
KENT
ALA
7:00pm Tonight
CLMB
BRO
 
7:00pm Tonight
LIB
CSOU
 
7:00pm Tonight
BUCK
COL
 
7:00pm Tonight
UVA
DUKE
7:00pm Tonight
NE
ELON
 
7:00pm Tonight
CHAR
FIU
7:00pm Tonight
ODU
FATL
7:00pm Tonight
SAMF
FUR
 
7:00pm Tonight
DUQ
GMAS
7:00pm Tonight
PENN
HARV
 
7:00pm Tonight
LBSU
HAW
 
7:00pm Tonight
BONA
LAS
7:00pm Tonight
NAVY
LAF
 
7:00pm Tonight
PBY
LONG
 
7:00pm Tonight
WOFF
MERC
 
7:00pm Tonight
ETST
NCCU
 
7:00pm Tonight
MCNST
NO
 
7:00pm Tonight
FLGC
NKENTUCKY
 
7:00pm Tonight
IONA
PETE
 
7:00pm Tonight
STEPH
TAMCC
 
7:00pm Tonight
UNF
USCU
 
7:30pm Tonight
GSOUT
ARKLR
 
8:00pm Tonight
UCR
CSNO
 
8:00pm Tonight
SELA
NWST
 
8:00pm Tonight
OKST
OKLA
8:00pm Tonight
UNT
RICE
8:00pm Tonight
SDU
USF
 
8:00pm Tonight
NMU
SJST
8:00pm Tonight
PEAY
SEMIZ
 
8:00pm Tonight
NILL
TOL
 
8:00pm Tonight
HOF
TOWS
 
8:00pm Tonight
SMU
UCF
8:00pm Tonight
MURST
TENNM
 
8:00pm Tonight
SDST
UTST
8:05pm Tonight
MIZST
SILL
 
8:15pm Tonight
TXARL
TROY
 
8:30pm Tonight
TXSOU
ALAST
 
8:30pm Tonight
TENST
JVST
 
8:30pm Tonight
WASU
STAN
9:00pm Tonight
GRCN
CHIST
 
9:00pm Tonight
UTEP
MTST
9:00pm Tonight
SUTAH
NARZ
 
9:00pm Tonight
BYU
SCU
 
9:00pm Tonight
NMST
TXPA
 
9:00pm Tonight
NCOL
WEBER
 
10:00pm Tonight
UNLV
AFA
10:00pm Tonight
UCD
CPSL
 
10:00pm Tonight
GONZ
MEM
10:00pm Tonight
CALST
SEAT
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCI
UCSB
 
10:05pm Tonight
SACST
MONT
 
10:05pm Tonight
PORST
MNTST
 
10:30pm Tonight
UCLA
COL
10:30pm Tonight
WLVRN
UMKC
 
1st
DET 0
NYI 0
 
3:00pm Today
OTT
ARI
7:00pm Tonight
NYR
CAR
7:00pm Tonight
WIN
DAL
7:00pm Tonight
NJD
FLA
7:00pm Tonight
BOS
LOS
7:00pm Tonight
PHI
TOR
7:30pm Tonight
TAM
CLB
10:00pm Tonight
CAL
EDM
10:30pm Tonight
SJS
CHI