My ballot and the voting process for ACC postseason awards
Posted March 10, 2014
It has been an interesting race for the ACC Player of the Year award and my three finalists call the Triangle home. TJ Warren, Jabari Parker and Marcus Paige have put together a season to remember and performances that will long live in the archives of ACC basketball.
For the record, my vote went to NC State's TJ Warren by a whisker over Duke's Jabari Parker.
Night in and night out Warren faced the opponents top defender and help defense. He still led the league in scoring including season ending point totals of 41 and 42 points. Looking at the ACC game stats only, Warren with a 25.5 scoring average, scored 100 more points than the 2nd leading scorer, Olivier Hanlan of Boston College. He also was tops in field goal percentage at 53% and led the league in steals with 32. Oh, TJ missed the Maryland game due to an injury. Using only conference game stats, Parker was fourth in scoring (17.6 PPG) and he led the ACC in rebounding (9.8). Paige seventh in scoring (16.2) and third in assists (4.8).
My selection process mixture includes looking at conference only stats. Are you in multiple statistical columns? I also consider the importance to your team and how successful your team is. There is also the eye test.
Different people use different criteria when it comes to voting for post season accolades and that's the beauty of the vote. It's also a reason why the panel needs to be diverse in their selection process and where they are located in the ACC's geographic footprint.
To vote for the ACC awards and recognition, media members have to pay 10 dollars to join the Atlantic Coast Sports Media Association. Currently there are 113 members and the strongest contingent of voters reside in North Carolina. There are 52 members of ACSMA in our state. Virginia is next with 20 with Florida the only other state reaching double digits in membership with 10. What about the newcomers? A combined 9 ACSMA members are in the home states of Syracuse, Pittsburgh and Notre Dame.
Now I certainly know media members vote for players outside of the school or schools they cover but the membership numbers for ACSMA don't reflect a geographically balanced group.
Should we continue to use the current format? Should the ACC form a panel of voters like the AP poll and Heisman Trophy? This year 77 of the 113 eligible ACSMA members voted.
The coaches vote is an entirely different beast. I know we in the media make some bonehead choices but which coach in the ACC didn't vote TJ Warren 1st team all-conference this year?
Here is how my vote went.
All-ACC First Team: TJ Warren, Jabari Parker, Marcus Paige, KJ McDaniels, CJ Fair
All-ACC Second Team: Rodney Hood, Lamar Patterson, Malcolm Brogdon, Tyler Ennis, James Michael McAdoo
All-ACC Third Team: Eric Atkins, Olivier Hanlan, Rion Brown, Joe Harris, Talib Zanna
Player of the Year: TJ Warren
Coach of the Year: Tony Bennett
Rookie of the Year: Jabari Parker
Defensive Player of the Year: KJ McDaniels
Sixth Man: Ian Miller
Most Improved: Marcus Paige