Erin Summers

NCAA continues to take hits in light of O'Bannon case

Posted August 7, 2013

NCAA generic logo

It was just last week that a Court of Appeals upheld a ruling that Electronic Arts, Inc. has to stop producing their popular NCAA College Football game. The NCAA had already decided to part ways with EA and 2014 is the last version of their game that will include the NCAA logo.

It's a part of the Keller/O'Bannon case. The Keller case, which began in 2009, was specifically about the gaming company profiting from the use of former Arizona State quarterback Samuel Keller's physical likeness without pay. And the court ruled in his favor, saying that EA sports cannot use the physical likeness of collegiate athletes without compensating them for it.

A thread of 2005 emails released earlier this year showed the NCAA realized EA Sports was specifically designing their game after current players and several NCAA members voiced their concerns.

"The biggest concern I have is that such a position really does allow for the maximum commercial exploitation of the (student-athlete), and if that occurs, will it be long before we can defend not giving them a piece of the profits?," wrote NCAA membership services official Steve Mallonee.

But that concern hasn't seemed to stop the NCAA from doing the same thing. I mean, we are talking about a lot of money here, right?

Tuesday, ESPN analyst Jay Bilas went on a Twitter tirade unveiling that although the NCAA does not sell player specific football jerseys, if one were to search a specific player on ShopNCAASports.com, they would be steered to a jersey that looked almost identical to his. Fans could purchase this jersey with the players team and number on it, and the only thing missing would be the players' name.

In essence, the NCAA would be profiting from using the physical likeness of college athletes without compensating them for it – exactly what EA Sports got popped for and what the NCAA tried to walk away from. Not surprisingly, the search engine on the website that allowed people to search for gear was disabled before the day was done. 

The Bilas findings and EA ruling are just the latest developments in the overall picture of the Ed O'Bannon's lawsuit. The O'Bannon suit combines Keller's suit among others against the NCAA. Let's break it down.

The plaintiffs are suing the NCAA for profiting off the likenesses of college athletes, including the conferences and the networks that televise the games.

Prior to playing, NCAA athletes have to sign a waiver that relinquishes their right to make money off of their likeness as an NCAA athlete. So why did the courts rule in Keller's favor? He has the Sherman Antitrust Act to thank for that. The act specifically bans artificially fixing prices, which O'Bannon is alleging the NCAA did by fixing his worth at $0. 

The major problem now is that current players have jumped on board. Vanderbilt linebacker Chase Garnham, Clemson cornerback Darius Robinson, linebacker Jake Fischer and kicker Jake Smith from Arizona, tight end Moses Alipate and wide receiver Victor Keise of Minnesota are all part of the suit. The additions satisfied Judge Claudia Wilken's request to have a current player join as a plaintiff before she will rule on certifying the suit.

So while the EA side seems to be over, we now shift to television rights and the hundreds of millions of dollars that the NCAA and conferences earn from TV deals.

The trial isn't set until July 9, 2014 but the outcome could change college sports entirely. Worst case, the plaintiffs win and get everything they ask for. The NCAA would go bankrupt and colleges would have to create a new governing body.

Athletes would get paid, coaches would get paid less and non-revenue sports would be cut. Or the NCAA and schools decide to settle, most likely securing a portion of revenue for athletes.

Either way, Bilas didn't make the NCAA look very good Tuesday.

15 Comments

This blogpost is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • Ken D. Aug 7, 4:02 p.m.

    How much do these athletes get? How about the backup long snapper? How about the field hockey... View More

    — Posted by scorekeep

    D1 men's basketball and football are entertainment businesses that have little or nothing to do... View More

    — Posted by uBnice

    That sounds good, bit I doubt the courts would allow schools to do an end run around Title IX just by "professionalizing" football and men's basketball.

  • Sauras69 Aug 7, 3:39 p.m.

    Jay Bilas is right. I am a lifelong Carolina fan. UNC has enough problems without an alumna... View More

    — Posted by jhdaniels54

    You made some solid points.

  • rush Aug 7, 2:37 p.m.

    "Instead of colleges paying their players, why not allow the player to profit off their name?"

    Because then you would lose the parity in college athletics. There would be nothing to stop a situation where a school with millionaire/billionaire donors could pay the players absurd amounts of money for their autograph.

  • pause to consider Aug 7, 1:52 p.m.

    "... the outcome could change college sports entirely. Worst case, the plaintiffs win and get everything they ask for. The NCAA would go bankrupt and colleges would have to create a new governing body." - story

    I think this is what needs to happen anyway. The 'concept' of the NCAA is valid but they've lost their way with compromises created by the ridiculous amount of money in an 'Amateur' business.

    The schools are equally to blame - they've pursued maximum profits on the backs of scholarship and non-scholarship Students. Either take the money out of college sports or bank some of the money for the students when they leave school.

  • Me again Aug 7, 1:41 p.m.

    Instead of colleges paying their players, why not allow the player to profit off their name? for example...let Manziel get paid for his autograph.

  • uBnice Aug 7, 12:02 p.m.

    How much do these athletes get? How about the backup long snapper? How about the field hockey... View More

    — Posted by scorekeep

    D1 men's basketball and football are entertainment businesses that have little or nothing to do with a University's mission.

    If they moved the men's basketball and football to separate, minor-league, semi-pro leagues, there would be no reason to consider any non-revenue sports, including all of Title IX, in the make-up. Then let the pro market determine how much one gets paid. Presently, the long-snappers in the pros make a lot less than the QB's.

    All non-revenue sports would be under D3 specifications, including all of Title IX. Everyone in the non-revenue sports would be on an equal footing.

  • scorekeep Aug 7, 11:46 a.m.

    How much do these athletes get? How about the backup long snapper? How about the field hockey goalie?

  • cherokee43v6 Aug 7, 11:42 a.m.

    Saw this on another discussion board.

    N ever

    C ared

    A bout

    A thletes

  • jhdaniels54 Aug 7, 11:17 a.m.

    Jay Bilas is right. I am a lifelong Carolina fan. UNC has enough problems without an alumna writing a column that ignores the truth about the NCAA and implying its because he's a DOOKIE. BS. The NCAA has been pimping out athletes for years. Bill Friday had it right. Either rein in the profit making and make student more important than athlete or pay the athletes a stipend for their services. Then, prosecute these agents/runners and ban them from the campuses for life. The proposal to place the royalties in an escrow account that can only be received after graduation solves both problems. Lets get real!!!!

  • issymayake Aug 7, 11:14 a.m.

    If they are going to set up a fund for the athletes, graduating should not be a requirement; unless the NCAA dismantles the year-to-year renewal aspect of their scholarships.

More...

 

 

  • PGA: RBC Heritage

    Tomorrow at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • PGA: Zurich Classic of New Orleans

    Saturday at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • MiLB: Bulls at Norfolk

    Tonight at 7:00 on 620am

  • MLB: Atlanta Braves at NY Mets

    Tonight at 7:05 on 99.9 The Fan

  • MLB: Baltimore Orioles at Boston Red Sox

    Tomorrow at 7:05 pm on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
Local
7:05pm Tonight
NOR
DUR
 
Final
WAS 3
STL 4
Final
CLE 0
TOR 5
9th
DET 5
ANA 2
 
9th
BOS 4
BAL 2
 
6th
KAN 5
MIN 4
 
6th
CHC 3
CIN 0
 
1st
OAK 0
HOU 0
 
7:05pm Tonight
PIT
MIL
7:10pm Tonight
NYM
ATL
7:10pm Tonight
TAM
NYY
7:10pm Tonight
MIA
SEA
8:05pm Tonight
TEX
CWS
8:10pm Tonight
LOS
ARI
8:10pm Tonight
COL
PHI
8:40pm Tonight
SDP
SFG
Final
TOR 87
BRK 94
2nd
LAC 31
GSW 29
 
7:00pm Tonight
IND
ATL
9:30pm Tonight
OKC
MEM
2nd
STL 2
CHI 0
 
7:00pm Tonight
PIT
CLB
9:30pm Tonight
COL
MIN
7:05pm Tonight
NOR
DUR