North Carolina

NCAA finds lack of institutional control at UNC

Posted June 4, 2015

— In its second investigation of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill athletes and academics in five years, the NCAA found the university lacked institutional control, especially within the College of Arts and Science and in the actions of a former ethics professor.

The NCAA accused UNC of five violations of NCAA bylaws, most importantly of providing benefits to student-athletes not available to the student body. UNC's recent history of impropriety served as an aggravating factor to the most recent round of allegations, the NCAA said.

In addition, the NCAA alleges that "persons of authority condoned, participated in or negligently disregarded the violation of relate wrongful conduct."

"What I think is most important for us is to take a look at what they alleged see what the facts we have on our campus, what we believe in, and present that back to the NCAA enforcement staff," said Director of Athletics Bubba Cunningham. "The allegations are very serious, extra benefits, failure to cooperate lack of institutional control all of those are very serious."

WRAL obtained a redacted copy of 59-page the Notice of Allegations and its hundreds of pages of exhibits after UNC leadership spent more than a week reviewing and redacting it in accordance with public records and student privacy laws.

Allegations cite AF-AM Department, Boxill

In the first allegation, the NCAA found that UNC directed student-athletes to certain courses within the Department of African and African-American Studies, arranged assignments fo those student-athletes and recommended grades for them. Browder: Wainstein report leads to dismissals at UNC FULL TEXT: Notice of Allegations

The second allegation centers on the women's basketball program and Jan Boxill, former faculty chairwoman, an ethics professor and the former athletic-academic counselor for that team. Boxill, according to the NCAA, knowingly provided athletes, including players outside the women's basketball team, with academic assistance, including recommending grades for them.

In making a case against Boxill, the NCAA interviewed current women's basketball coach Sylvia Hatchell, but Hatchell is not specifically implicated in any of the allegations.

“I’ve always run my program with integrity. That’s why reading some of the allegations are so disappointing," Hatchell said in a statement.

Head men's basketball coach Roy Williams was interviewed in December 2014, and he told investigators that he was concerned about the number of players from his team with AF-AM majors.

“Everyone who loves Carolina is truly saddened by these allegations," Williams said in a statement Thursday. "We aspire to and work toward meeting higher standards than the actions that warranted this notice." UNC Academics Investigation Archive: UNC investigation

The NCAA also interviewed football coaches Butch Davis, who was fired a year after allegations began to come to light, and Everett Withers, his interim replacement. Davis outlined for investigators the relationship between the football program and the student-athletic academic support program.

"I appreciate the work that the NCAA has put into this investigation, and am gratified that they have concluded -- for a second time -- that I was not involved in any of the alleged misconduct at the University of North Carolina," Davis told WRAL Thursday.

The third and fourth of the allegations focus on Julius Nyang'oro, former department chair of the AF-AM Department, and his long-time assistant, Deborah Crowder, from whom investigators reviewed hundreds of pages of emails.

The emails detail Crowder's help to student-athletes and her frustration when they did even less than she asked of them. In one message, she expressed disappointment that two student-athletes had turned in the same paper, provided them with a new assignment and pointed out that she wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt. In another, she notes that half the enrollment of a Swahili class is football players.

She exchanged numerous messages with Cynthia Reynolds, associate director of academic support of student athletes, arranging class assignments and discussing suggested grades for individual student athletes.

Nyang'oro, too, corresponded with Reynolds. The NCAA reviewed emails she sent him requesting a meeting to discuss paper topics for student athletes.

The NCAA alleges that Nyang'oro and Crowder refused to cooperate with both UNC and NCAA investigations despite multiple requests.

In conclusion, the NCAA found that "the scope and nature of the violations set forth ... demonstrate that the institution violated the NCAA principles of institutional control and rules compliance."

"I had a range of emotions as I read through the allegations," Cunningham said. "My emotions followed whether I agreed or disagreed with what I was reading. We are delighted we are taking that next step to get to the end of this process."

What is next?

UNC has until Aug. 20 to respond to the Notice of Allegations. Cunningham said Thursday that the university would take the full 90 days allotted to formulate a response.

"Some allegations we'll agree with, and some we won't," he said.

UNC then faces a hearing with the NCAA Committee on Infractions, which includes representatives of other universities and select experts outside academia, then votes on any penalties to impose.

If the process follows the same pattern, it could be February or later before UNC learns the penalty for this round of violations. That uncertainty, according to some reports, has chilled recruits' interest in committing to play at UNC.

Based on the NCAA's published matrix of violations and punishments, which defines the allegations against UNC as "level 1 violations," any penalty could include a postseason ban and loss of scholarships for teams implicated, fines of up to 5 percent of the athletic department budget, suspensions of active coaches and limits on contact with recruits.

"The range and scope of potential penalties is beyond anything I want to speculate on today," Cunnginham said. "We have had multiple conversations with the NCAA, I’ve read an awful lot of cases, each and every case is unique. The amount of time we have spent as a University, number of reviews and investigations, the media coverage is something that is unparalleled."

In the hours before the report was released, UNC outlined the members of two new campus groups charged with preventing future academic irregularities. One group will "identify any redundancies, gaps and inconsistencies," the other "has been charged with reinforcing ethical high-integrity behavior."

Five years of scandal

It was the football program that first caught the eye of the NCAA in 2010 when a series of Tweets led to an investigation that found academic improprieties, student-agent dealings and players accepting cash, gifts and trips. For those violations, the NCAA banned the UNC football program from the 2012 postseason. The team forfeited 15 scholarships over a three-year period and erased 16 wins from the record books.

The university, prompted by revelations during that investigation about student-athletes who got help with papers and classes that never met, conducted several reviews of the then-Department of African and Afro-American Studies, eventually hiring Kenneth Wainstein, who worked in the U.S. Attorney General's Office, with a mandate to report on academic improprieties dating back to the early 1990s.

Wainstein found 169 student-athletes at UNC-CH over the course of 18 years who benefited from classes that never met or had grades manipulated to keep them eligible.

Of the 169, 123 were football players, 15 were men's basketball players, eight were women's basketball players and 26 played in one of the Olympic sports.

Whistleblower Mary Willingham, who worked as an advisor at UNC before coming forward with the allegaitions of academic wrongdoing, released a statement on her website paperclassinc.com Thursday that read in part, "In its Notice of Allegations against UNC, the NCAA has stated the obvious: there was no real institutional control over the athletics program in Chapel Hill for a very long time...We find it especially revealing, and discouraging, that Jan Boxill was singled out for one of the five named allegations. Boxill worked in a system where all who had regular contact with athletes were complicit in a charade. These people included admissions officials, athletic directors, academic counselors, coaches, and compliance staff for football, men’s basketball, and many other sports."

Cunningham noted that the Notice of Allegations are just another step on a long path to closure for UNC.

"This may be the longest game in the history of the world, we are at half time," Cunningham said. "Everyone wants to bring closure to this. It’s not a pleasant time in the history of the university."

17 Comments

Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Kristin Byrne Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread


    As a taxpayer, there is no return on your "investment" if you cheat to get it. Save that for politics.

  • Jason McAllister Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread


    Thanks for the insight which I never presumed to dispute.

  • Burke Evans Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread


    Had they not cheated to begin with, none of this would have been necessary.

  • Sean Creasy Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    For them to be "highly educated" individuals, they sure are slow on the uptake aren't they? The average person knew this several months ago...

  • Jason McAllister Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread


    Except for, you know, initiating and funding the investigation that ultimately handed these allegations to the NCAA.

    You do realize that UNC could have very easily swept this under the rug after the NCAA initially didn't get involved stating it was academic, not athletic?

  • Tom Boswell Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    The University of Notorious Cheaters scandal reminds me of speak no evil, hear no evil and see no evil. Smith, Williams, Holt, Cunningham, Thorp, Baddour to claim they knew nothing is hilarious.

  • Eugene Irene Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    As a former UNC Prof it is clear that the people responsible at the highest level are the Provost who is the chief academic officer and the dean of Arts and Sciences both of whom are the leaders who should know about the courses being offered. This is a long festering problem attributed to coaches who have nothing to do with academics but rather administrators who choose to look the other way. There is big money involved.

  • Sam Adams Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    Knowing UNC I am sure they will rename their building after Julius Nyang'oro.

  • Scott Boykin Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread


    Wow! I thought the main purpose of the universities was to EDUCATE! not to be a minor league for the NBA & NFL...

  • Sam Ashworth Jun 5, 2015
    user avatar

    This is not important, it helped win games. What is important is renaming a building that was named after some guy who was in the klan over a hundred years ago.

More...

 

 

Listen & Watch
  • HighSchoolOT Live

    Tomorrow at 7:00 pm on WRAL-2

  • Football Friday

    Tomorrow at 11:35 pm on WRAL-TV

  • ACC Football: Pittsburgh @ Duke

    Saturday at 12:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • College Football: Southern Cal @ Notre Dame

    Saturday at 7:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NASL Soccer: San Francisco @ North Carolina FC

    Saturday at 7:30 pm on WRAL-2

  • The Logan Zone

    Sunday at 11:00 am on WRAL-TV

  • Motor Sports: Formula 1 Racing - Austin

    Sunday at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Atlanta @ New England

    Sunday at 8:20 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL Football Carolina Panthers at Chicago Bears

    Sunday at 12:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • NFL Football Dallas Cowboys at San Francisco 49ers

    Sunday at 5:30 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • MLB Playoffs Chicago Cubs at Los Angeles Dodgers Game 7 (if necessary)

    Sunday at 6:30 pm on 95.7 The Ticket

  • NFL Football Atlanta Falcons at New England Patriots

    Sunday at 7:30 pm on 99.9 The Fan

AP Top 25
Thu, Oct 19
25
5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET12:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST
Preview
Sat, Oct 21
10
9:00 PT10:00 MT11:00 CT12:00 ET4:00 GMT12:00 北京时间9:00 MST11:00 EST
Preview
9:00 PT10:00 MT11:00 CT12:00 ET4:00 GMT12:00 北京时间9:00 MST11:00 EST
Preview
5
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
Preview
1
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
Preview
8
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
Preview
18
20
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
Preview
12:30 PT1:30 MT2:30 CT3:30 ET7:30 GMT3:30 北京时间12:30 MST2:30 EST
Preview
14
9
1:00 PT2:00 MT3:00 CT4:00 ET8:00 GMT4:00 北京时间1:00 MST3:00 EST
Preview
16
4:00 PT5:00 MT6:00 CT7:00 ET11:00 GMT7:00 北京时间4:00 MST6:00 EST
Preview
24
4:15 PT5:15 MT6:15 CT7:15 ET11:15 GMT7:15 北京时间4:15 MST6:15 EST
Preview
21
4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET11:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST
Preview
11
4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET11:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST
Preview
13
19
4:30 PT5:30 MT6:30 CT7:30 ET11:30 GMT7:30 北京时间4:30 MST6:30 EST
Preview
2
23
5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET12:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST
Preview
5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET12:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST
Preview
4
7:45 PT8:45 MT9:45 CT10:45 ET2:45 GMT10:45 北京时间7:45 MST9:45 EST
Preview
15
NFL Scoreboard
Thursday, Oct. 19
Kansas City 5:25 PT6:25 MT7:25 CT8:25 ET0:25 GMT8:25 5:25 MST7:25 EST7:25 CT4:25 UAE (+1)20:25 ETNaN:�
Preview
Oakland 
Sunday, Oct. 22
Tampa Bay 10:00 PT11:00 MT12:00 CT1:00 ET17:00 GMT1:00 10:00 MST12:00 EST12:00 CT21:00 UAE13:00 ETNaN:�
Preview
Buffalo 
Carolina 10:00 PT11:00 MT12:00 CT1:00 ET17:00 GMT1:00 10:00 MST12:00 EST12:00 CT21:00 UAE13:00 ETNaN:�
Preview
Chicago 
Tennessee 10:00 PT11:00 MT12:00 CT1:00 ET17:00 GMT1:00 10:00 MST12:00 EST12:00 CT21:00 UAE13:00 ETNaN:�
Preview
Cleveland 
New Orleans 10:00 PT11:00 MT12:00 CT1:00 ET17:00 GMT1:00 10:00 MST12:00 EST12:00 CT21:00 UAE13:00 ETNaN:�
Preview
Green Bay 
Jacksonville 10:00 PT11:00 MT12:00 CT1:00 ET17:00 GMT1:00 10:00 MST12:00 EST12:00 CT21:00 UAE13:00 ETNaN:�
Preview
Indianapolis 
Arizona 10:00 PT11:00 MT12:00 CT1:00 ET17:00 GMT1:00 10:00 MST12:00 EST12:00 CT21:00 UAE13:00 ETNaN:�
Preview
LA Rams 
NY Jets 10:00 PT11:00 MT12:00 CT1:00 ET17:00 GMT1:00 10:00 MST12:00 EST12:00 CT21:00 UAE13:00 ETNaN:�
Preview
Miami 
Baltimore 10:00 PT11:00 MT12:00 CT1:00 ET17:00 GMT1:00 10:00 MST12:00 EST12:00 CT21:00 UAE13:00 ETNaN:�
Preview
Minnesota 
Dallas 1:05 PT2:05 MT3:05 CT4:05 ET20:05 GMT4:05 1:05 MST3:05 EST3:05 CT0:05 UAE (+1)16:05 ETNaN:�
Preview
San Francisco 
Denver 1:25 PT2:25 MT3:25 CT4:25 ET20:25 GMT4:25 1:25 MST3:25 EST3:25 CT0:25 UAE (+1)16:25 ETNaN:�
Preview
LA Chargers 
Seattle 1:25 PT2:25 MT3:25 CT4:25 ET20:25 GMT4:25 1:25 MST3:25 EST3:25 CT0:25 UAE (+1)16:25 ETNaN:�
Preview
NY Giants 
Cincinnati 1:25 PT2:25 MT3:25 CT4:25 ET20:25 GMT4:25 1:25 MST3:25 EST3:25 CT0:25 UAE (+1)16:25 ETNaN:�
Preview
Pittsburgh 
Atlanta 5:30 PT6:30 MT7:30 CT8:30 ET0:30 GMT8:30 5:30 MST7:30 EST7:30 CT4:30 UAE (+1)20:30 ETNaN:�
Preview
New England 
Monday, Oct. 23
Washington 5:30 PT6:30 MT7:30 CT8:30 ET0:30 GMT8:30 5:30 MST7:30 EST7:30 CT4:30 UAE (+1)20:30 ETNaN:�
Preview
Philadelphia 
Minor League Baseball
International League
Memphis 4:07 PT5:07 MT6:07 CT7:07 ET12:07 GMT
Durham 
ATP Scoreboard
Thursday, Oct. 19
Intrum Stockholm Open (ATP)
Second Round
(7) Y. Sugita6 3 6   
M. Baghdatis3 6 2   
(2) K. Anderson4     
H. Chung3     
(5) M. Zverev 
V. Troicki 
(1) G. Dimitrov 
J. Janowicz 
(4) J. Del Potro 
J. Struff 
 
European Open (ATP)
Second Round
I. Karlovic64 6    
S. Tsitsipas77 5    
(4) D. Schwartzma6 0    
E. Escobedo3 0    
(2) J. Tsonga 
K. De Scheppe 
(1) D. Goffin 
F. Tiafoe 
(5) D. Ferrer 
S. Darcis 
 
Kremlin Cup (ATP/WTA)
Second Round
M. Basic6 6    
L. Djere1 1    
(1) P. Carreno Bu 
D. Medvedev 
F. Krajinovic 
R. Berankis 
(2) A. Ramos-Vino 
A. Bublik 
 
WTA Scoreboard
Thursday, Oct. 19
BGL Luxembourg Open (WTA)
Quarterfinals
J. Larsson1 2    
P. Parmentier6 6    
(2) K. Bertens0     
C. Witthoeft1     
M. Puig 
N. Broady 
(5) E. Mertens 
H. Watson 
 
Kremlin Cup (ATP/WTA)
Quarterfinals
A. Sasnovich4 3    
D. Kasatkina6 6    
I. Begu6 4 4   
V. Lapko3 6 4   
(7) J. Goerges 
L. Tsurenko 
A. Cornet 
N. Vikhlyants