Best Rookie QB In The NFL

Return to Forum

Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
  • Killing Time Jan 3, 2013
    All Star

    Johnny Unitas, hands down.

  • blueduke4 Jan 3, 2013
    Sports Legend

    Rw had to fight for his spot, the others were anointed.

  • BattlingBishop 5 Jan 3, 2013
    Sports Legend

    ^Seattle also has a very good D - #4 in the NFL, Colts are #26, the 'Skins are #28

    'Skins were #1 in rushing in the NFL, Seahawks #3...can see the argument for Luck.

  • RD n NC Jan 3, 2013
    All Star

    View quoted thread


    Seattle also has a running game (Lynch-1500+ yds)
    Washington (Morris - 1600+ yds)

    Luck didnt have that benefit to take the pressure off the QB.

  • BattlingBishop 5 Jan 3, 2013
    Sports Legend

    View quoted thread


    Yeah....I picked RG3 given the 'Skins history over the last 5 years. They finished last from 2008 through 2011, had a 3rd place finish in 2007. Agree with ya regarding RW - but he's over there. The Colts were 2 - 14 in 2011 but I wonder if a lot of that had to do with them mentally being out of it due to Manning missing the season. I don't follow them but they could have just thrown in the towel as a team. The Colts were 24 - 8 combined in 2009/2010.

    Thing about Luck that hurts him a little IMHGTNCWCCU opinion is the 54.1 comp % & the 18 picks. He's obviously on his way to being one of the NFL's elite players. As you pointed out, he gets a lot of credit for reversing their course, 11 - 5 & a playoff berth. I'm good with any of 'em as they all did some great things this season. Question is - can they sustain it?

  • Rameses Unchained Jan 3, 2013
    All Star

    View quoted thread


    If RW was on the East Coast I think he might have a better shot. RG3...I dunno, the Colts were sooooo bad and the Skins have a descent team. If RG3 had not gotten hurt but that affects the body of work to judge. It will be a tight race. I'm gonna side with Buffy and say Luck.

  • Hans Jan 3, 2013
    Sports Legend

    Regardless, the job these 3 have done is amazing.

  • blueduke4 Jan 3, 2013
    Sports Legend

    Rg3 has the advantage of playing on the number 1 rushing team, luck has Wayne, a class act vet. Wilson is the one for me.

  • VT1994Hokie Jan 3, 2013
    Sports Legend

    I would give a slight edge to RG3 over Wilson. Luck hasn't played as consistently as the other two players. Still these 3 have played better than a bunch of seasoned veterans.

  • Wolfpackindahizzy4shizzy Jan 3, 2013
    Sports Legend

    View quoted thread



    what did Seattle do last year??

    washington???

    neither were playoff teams, were they???

  • kmor2013 Jan 3, 2013
    Sports Legend

    Luck- look at what he did with this team from last year.....

  • believe Jan 3, 2013
    Veteran

    Don't forget little Dour Martin. He was a Godsend for Tampa.

  • Killing Time Jan 2, 2013
    All Star

    View quoted thread


    More like what a find for my fantasy team. Helped me win the league championship.

  • BattlingBishop 5 Jan 2, 2013
    Sports Legend

    View quoted thread


    +1....RG3 has had an incredible season. Luck will eventually get control of his Ints but as of now, I would have to go with RG3, RW, followed by Luck.

    A Morris - what a find that was for the 'Skins.

  • larrys080 .v1 Jan 2, 2013
    Sports Legend

    Wilson, RG3 and Luck are all studs and the future of the NFL! The rookie class overall has produced this year even 6th round pick Alfred Morris for the Redskins! I think all 3 have a case for ROY but since I'm a Redskins fan I will go with RG3! :)

  • blueduke4 Jan 2, 2013
    Sports Legend

    Hard to pick between those three

Oldest First
  • MLB: Pittsburgh at St. Louis

    Tonight at 7:00 on 99.9 The Fan

  • College World Series: Teams TBD

    Tomorrow at 7:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • College World Series: Teams TBD

    Tuesday at 7:45 pm on 99.9 The Fan

Minor League Baseball
International League
Pawtucket9Final
Scranton/Wilkes-Barre10
Buffalo7Final
Syracuse5
Norfolk 10:05 PT11:05 MT12:05 CT1:05 ET11:05 MT1:05 ET6:05 GMT2:05 北京时间
Gwinnett 
Lehigh Valley4Final
Rochester7
Toledo1Final
Columbus4
Charlotte 2:05 PT3:05 MT4:05 CT5:05 ET3:05 MT5:05 ET10:05 GMT6:05 北京时间
Durham 
Indianapolis 3:05 PT4:05 MT5:05 CT6:05 ET4:05 MT6:05 ET11:05 GMT7:05 北京时间
Louisville 
Travelers Champ (PGA)
PosNameScoreThru
1J. Spieth-1212
2tC. Hoffman-1016
2tD. Lee-1015
2tB. Weekley-1012
5tP. Reed-918
5tD. Berger-912
7tK. Streelman-818
7tT. Merritt-818
7tW. Simpson-816
7tK. Bradley-814
View Full Leaderboard
 
NW Ark Champ (LPGA)
PosNameScoreThru
1S. Ryu-178
2tA. Yang-139
2tM. Jutanugarn-139
4S. Lewis-128
5tM. Alex-1112
5tM. Wie-1112
5tM. Lee-119
8tM. Harigae-1018
8tC. Choi-1018
8tT. Joh-1018
View Full Leaderboard
 
American Family (CHMP)
PosNameScoreThru
1F. Couples-1517
2S. Verplank-1317
3J. Durant-1218
4tS. Stricker-1117
4tP. Broadhurst-1117
6tT. Byrum-1018
6tJ. Haas-1018
6tL. Janzen-1017
9tT. Armour III-918
9tS. Ames-918
View Full Leaderboard
 
ATP Scoreboard
Sunday, Jun. 25
AEGON Championships (ATP)
Final
(4) M. Cilic6 62 68   
F. Lopez4 77 710   
 
Gerry Weber Open (ATP)
Final
(1) R. Federer6 6    
(4) A. Zverev1 3    
 
AEGON International (ATP/WTA)
 
Antalya Open (ATP)
First Round
D. Istomin4 77 4   
S. Darcis6 65 6   
(7) B. Coric5 4    
A. Mannarino7 6    
 
WTA Scoreboard
Sunday, Jun. 25
AEGON Classic Birmingham (WTA)
Final
(7) P. Kvitova4 6 6   
A. Barty6 3 2   
 
Mallorca Open (WTA)
Final
(2) A. Sevastova6 3 6   
J. Goerges4 6 3   
 
AEGON International (ATP/WTA)
First Round
C. Suarez Nav6 6    
E. Makarova3 1    
A. Riske6 7    
A. Cornet4 5    
L. Tsurenko3 6 4   
H. Watson6 4 6   
T. Babos1 1    
E. Mertens6 6    
M. Lucic-Baro4 7 5   
M. Niculescu6 5 7   
Y. Putintseva4 77 1   
L. Arruabarre6 62 2   
A. Konjuh4 0    
M. Barthel6 1