banner
Adam Gold

Never too early to talk college football

Posted June 13, 2013

Is it college football season yet?

No? Man, it's too hot already outside, and I'm jonesing for the start of the season so we can finally see how this new playoff is going to work.

What? Oh, we're still a year away from that. That's right, we've got one more year under the old Bowl Championship Series. Next year is when everything changes for the better.

Yeah, not so much, I'm afraid.

The four-team College Football Playoff goes into effect after the 2014 season and will NOT dramatically alter the college football landscape. In fact, it will be very hard to notice a tangible difference at all, unless you're the third and fourth teams in the final standings. In theory, the two teams that will be the next-best in this year's final BCS rankings would slot into a semifinal matchup were the system already in place. So, it's not really a playoff at all, it's just an extra game.

I can't think of a playoff that starts in the semifinals.

However, it IS better than the system that we have because we've yet to figure out a way to honor more than two major conference undefeated teams.

Auburn was denied a national championship shot in 2004 in spite of an undefeated season and an SEC title. No way on this, or any other, planet that would happen today, but it did nine years ago. The best part of the four-team system is that it is highly unlikely that this will ever happen again.

The next best part of the "playoff" is that there will be a human selection committee, much like we see in basketball, baseball and the other sports that have larger tournaments. However, the NCAA has yet to define the makeup of that group or the criteria they will be asked to consider. And, to me, this is going to be a major problem.

If the committee is made up of conference commissioners and directors of athletics, like all of the other NCAA selection committees, we're going to have a constant battle over the fairness of the system. We all know that the SEC is, by miles, the dominant conference in college football. Four SEC schools have won the last seven national championships, and four more that didn't have recently finished in the top ten of the final polls.

That is across-the-board butt kicking.

But, you know that ADs and officials from the B1G and the ACC and the Pac-12 and the Big XII don't want to see two or three teams from the SEC in the playoff, no matter how deserving they may be, so we're going to have a heated debate over favoring conference champions. This is going to create a very real problem for the playoff. Especially at the outset, the one element that the new system needs is credibility, and if we arrive in January of 2015 with anything less than the four best teams duking it out for the championship – the FIRST college football championship of this era – then the sport will be looked at as the loser.

The whole reason for a playoff, even this four-team version, is to eliminate the controversy. And, as we've seen in both basketball and baseball selections in recent years, in those committee rooms – or in limousines on the ride to committee rooms – deals get made. We can't allow that to happen if we want this to be a trusted system, unless they want to scrap the model already and just open it up to eight teams which will allow cover for the league officials to favor some conference champs and still not deny those truly deserving of a shot at the title.

Since we've been told that expanding the field is not on the table – though I promise you it's coming in the next contract – getting correct both the committee and the criteria to be considered is paramount. Whom do we trust to make the right call on the teams?

Conference commissioners and athletic directors? Aren't they busy doing other things, like commissioning and directing athletics?

Current coaches? You know, the coaches' poll has always been an integral part of the BCS formula? (Sticks finger down throat)

What about national media members whose job it is to cover the entirety of the sport? People like national college football writer/commentator Tony Barnhardt, or CBSSports.com's Dennis Dodd, or ESPN's Chris Fowler and Kirk Herbstreit, though that would probably eliminate the Mid-American Conference champion.

If we're just choosing four teams, there's no way to remove doubt unless you utilize people without allegiances. Everyone has biases, we all went to school somewhere, but coaches, athletic directors and conference commissioners have at least an indirect financial stake in who gets into the final four, and that element must be removed.

In a recent conversation with Kevin White, Duke's very candid director of athletics, I asked him if he wanted to be on the committee and should conference champions be given strong consideration.

His two answers: "Absolutely not" and "absolutely not.'" He had no interest in devoting that amount of time to that process, and we agreed that the only way this system works is if the four best teams are thrown into the ring to see who climbs out with the belt. If the best four teams all hail from the same conference, then that's who should play. Anything short of that is a hit at the veracity of the system.

And, in year one, even though we're a year away, the most vital piece of the equation is that we truly believe they got it right.

34 Comments

Please to add a comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • StunGunn Jun 14, 2013

    View quoted thread



    I'm a fan of one of the "blue" schools, but I agree with you completely. At the very lease the Big Four should play each other every year; for State to play Duke once and then not until 2020 is ridiculous. It's one thing to expand and realign the ACC, but to eliminate local rival games is a terrible decision IMHO.

  • rherring23 Jun 13, 2013

    View quoted thread

    Hum, App St is not a mid-major, they are a division 2 school. But saying that they would not belong, questionable. During their back to back championships and undefeated season they beat Michigan at Michigan, something a lot of those teams you say belong couldn't do. So that means Michigan doesn't belong? During those years App St could have beaten most of the teams you say belong in the championship.

  • VT1994Hokie Jun 13, 2013

    ^^^ You maybe outlined a decent deal. It was difficult to read though.

  • ncaa2014playoff Jun 13, 2013

    ND doesn't play and never has played an FCS Patsy like everybody else but TX. So they belonged in a playoff for the National Championship. So did Alabama even though they lost to A&M. The super sized conferences with the divisions and Conference Championship game are not built to really separate out the best for a playoff. Divide them up. Like the SEC should be 3 football only 10 team conferences fleshed out with 4 mid major teams.
    East: FL, GA, KY, So Car, TN, Vandy, LA T, Mid TN, UL Lafayette, UL Monroe;
    South: AL, Auburn, LSU, MS, MS St., TAMU, Houston, Rice, So MS, Tulane;
    Border: Arkansas, Missouri, ND, Cincinnati, Louisville, Arkansas St., Ball State, Kent St., Memphis, W. KY.;
    Divide ACC, B1G, B12 & PAC into 2 conferences of 10 teams. Then remake the American (old Big East) into BC, Conn, MD, Rutgers, Temple, W VA, Army, Navy, Akron & Marshall.
    The season should be only 11 games, 9 conference & 2 non-conference major teams.
    You now have 12 Conferences of 10 teams (120 total) with the Mid Majors (weaker schools) now in conferences that mean something so they can share the money and recruits because they play in a Power Conference. All 12 Champs go to the 16 Team Playoff along with the 4 second place teams with the most wins. Done all the problems are cured. No more Patsy Games with FCS teams no more expansion with FCS teams, sorry S. Alabama, Mass, GA St., TX St., UTSA, ODU, App St., So GA & Charlotte but you don't belong, wait till some of the weaker schools don't keep up and you can replace them when they are dropped down to FCS. Go check it out at ncaa2012.com/theperfectplan.pdf

  • BattlingBishop 5 Jun 13, 2013

    Ready for some football as well.

  • JPack Jun 13, 2013

    View quoted thread

    no ND did not beat them. ND did not play them. Don't know what you were watching but it wasn't football.

  • sburks1906 Jun 13, 2013

    Long live college football! I am looking forward to seeing the new ACC this fall.
    http://www.theklowntimes.net

  • cjw6105 Jun 13, 2013

    I couldn't care less about how many teams are in a college football playoff that most ACC schools will never be a part of. All I want is for my team (Pack) to play Duke, Georgia Tech, Virginia and Virginia Tech each season or at least every other season, not just once every 10 or 12 years.

    The ACC we are mutating into is one which I don't want to be a part of anymore. I honestly believe that teams like the Wolfpack would be better off being an independent. At least we could schedule teams that our fans wanted to play, and not be controlled by an arrogant bunch whose main interests bleed blue.

  • VT1994Hokie Jun 13, 2013

    A good many well written statements. I'm looking forward to a new football season. Hoping Logan Thomas can have a solid season. Go Hokies.

  • DUKE4EVER Jun 13, 2013

    GO DUKE!!

More...

 

 

TV
  • NCAAT: Louisville v. Michigan State

    Today at 2:20 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NCAAT: Duke v. Gonzaga

    Tonight at 5:05 on WRAL-TV

Scoreboard
Local
Final
CHA 115
ATL 100
Final
CAR 3
NJD 1
5:00pm Tonight
CAR
BOS
 
5:05pm Tonight
DUKE
GONZ
 
Final
NYY 2
BAL 10
Final
TAM 6
BOS 9
Final
MIA 1
HOU 1
Final
MIN 7
PHI 1
Final
DET 4
STL 3
Final
PIT 8
TOR 3
Final
TOR 3
ATL 5
Final
NYM 10
WAS 2
Final
CIN 9
CHC 5
Final
MIL 2
CLE 3
Final
CHC 18
COL 4
Final
CWS 4
OAK 10
Final
TEX 2
SDP 3
Final
SEA 8
SFG 9
Final
ARI 5
KAN 10
Final
ANA 4
LOS 5
1:05pm Today
PHI
DET
 
1:05pm Today
WAS
MIA
 
1:05pm Today
BAL
MIN
 
1:05pm Today
STL
NYM
 
1:05pm Today
HOU
NYY
 
1:05pm Today
ATL
PIT
 
1:05pm Today
BOS
TAM
 
1:07pm Today
TOR
BAL
 
3:10pm Today
ANA
CIN
 
4:05pm Today
KAN
CHC
 
4:05pm Today
CLE
CWS
 
4:05pm Today
SFG
LOS
 
4:05pm Today
OAK
MIL
 
4:05pm Today
SDP
SEA
 
4:05pm Today
LOS
TEX
 
4:10pm Today
COL
ARI
 
4:10pm Today
ARI
COL
 
Final
CHA 115
ATL 100
Final
CHI 111
NYK 80
Final
MIL 95
GSW 108
Final
UTA 94
OKC 89
4th
POR 118
DEN 108
 
12:30pm Today
WAS
HOU
 
3:30pm Today
BRK
LAL
 
4:00pm Today
NOP
MIN
 
4:30pm Today
CLE
PHI
 
6:00pm Tonight
MIA
DET
 
6:00pm Tonight
BOS
LAC
 
7:00pm Tonight
IND
DAL
 
7:00pm Tonight
SAN
MEM
 
9:00pm Tonight
PHO
OKC
 
Final
WISC 85
ARZ 78
Final
YALE 78
CAN 73
Final
KENT 68
ND 66
2:20pm Today
LOU
MSU
 
5:05pm Tonight
DUKE
GONZ
 
Final
WAS 3
NAS 4
Final
NYI 2
ANA 3
Final
PIT 3
ARI 2
Final
BOS 4
NYR 2
Final
PHI 2
SJS 3
Final
DET 4
TAM 0
Final
MON 3
FLA 2
Final
CAR 3
NJD 1
Final
TOR 4
OTT 3
Final
STL 2
CLB 4
Final
MIN 4
LOS 1
Final
COL 5
BUF 3
3rd
VAN 2
DAL 2
 
3:00pm Today
NYR
WAS
5:00pm Tonight
CAR
BOS
 
5:00pm Tonight
NAS
CAL
 
5:00pm Tonight
NYI
DET
 
5:00pm Tonight
OTT
FLA
 
7:00pm Tonight
NJD
ANA
 
7:30pm Tonight
WIN
CHI
 
7:30pm Tonight
PIT
SJS