North Carolina

Report reiterates clash between UNC athletics, academics

Posted September 3, 2013

UNC-Chapel Hill seal on sidewalk

A panel of leaders in higher education released a report on Tuesday highlighting ways the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill can improve how it handles the "complex maze of athletics," particularly in regard to how athletics impact academic goals and campus life.

Headed by Hunter Rawlings, the president of the Association of American Universities, the Rawlings Panel on Intercollegiate Athletics at UNC-Chapel Hill issued 28 recommendations to new Chancellor Carol Folt and also provided ideas for other universities facing similar challenges. 

The panel recommended that academic support services for student-athletes should operate without "any undue influence by athletics officials and staff, including coaching staff" and that the unit in charge of enforcing compliance with NCAA rules have "sufficient independence from athletics staff" in order to meet its responsibilities. 

The university made changes to that effect after the scandal that cost several football players their eligibility, led to the firing of then-coach Butch Davis and saw UNC miss out on a bowl last season.

Reviews by the UNC Board of Governors and former Gov. Jim Martin led to changes in academic advising for athletes and in how students are supervised in independent study classes.

"We make our recommendations primarily to the administration and faculty of UNC-CH, but we are fully cognizant of the national context for this report, and we make several suggestions we hope other universities will note and consider," Rawlings said. 

"I think everyone is cognizant that something needs to be done."

The cost of big-time college sports – both to a university’s budget and to the purported education of student-athletes -- has increasingly been under a microscope after high-profile investigations at Chapel Hill, Auburn, Penn State and Texas A&M. The NCAA’s ability to police abuses of its amateur system, and even whether college athletes should be considered students or mere employees of the universities where they perform are questions swirling in the national zeitgeist.

"The balance between academics and athletics is now perilously close to going over the tipping point where I think the trend is simply not sustainable," Hunter Rawlings said Tuesday.

With academic outcomes in mind, the panel said that UNC-Chapel Hill should consider reducing the number of hours student-athletes devote to sports activities both locally and on the conference or national level. 

Financially, the panel said UNC-Chapel Hill should revise its budget to clearly delineate the spending that supports student athletes' "educational, professional or career development" as opposed to other operating costs such staff salaries, recruiting or team travel. They also said UNC should make financial data more transparent to the public by publishing NCAA financial reports, the athletics department budget and additional financial data about long-term athletics debt and rates of change in athletics and academic spending. 

To make sure the university continues to promote an atmosphere of compliance, the panel said the school should establish an internal and external audit every four years to test its adherence to new procedures.

"Institutions of higher learning exist primarily to discover and to disseminate knowledge; winning sporting events is peripheral to those basic missions," the panel said. "As a result, a university’s athletics program must fit within the context of its core missions, and in no way violate them. Herein lies the principal challenge of intercollegiate athletics, since an institution’s desire to win must always be balanced against the core interests of the institution as a whole."

The investigation last fall by Martin and a more recent one by the UNC Board of Governors singled out the Department of African and Afro-American Studies as a trouble spot for academic integrity but concluded that athletes weren't the driving force behind the irregularities. 

In all, 216 courses in a nine-year span showed “anomalies,” and there were no fewer than 454 unauthorized grade changes over an 18-year period.

The Rawlings Panel included Jim Delaney, commissioner of the Big Ten Conference, Amy Perko, executive director of the Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics, Bob Malekoff, associate professor and sports studies chair at Guilford College, and Patricia Timmons-Goodson, former associate justice of the N.C. Supreme Court.


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • packfan07 Sep 5, 7:14 a.m.

    Yawn!! Tired of hearing about UNC, and their athletics, and academics. It happens everywhere!!

    — Posted by Toddler10-21

    That is always Cryolina fans excuse. But it doesn't happen everywhere and Cryolina fans can't come to terms with it.

  • joeBob Sep 4, 2:15 p.m.

    18 years of cheating is not a unfortunate page in UNC-CH sports's a tradition at that point.

  • GunnyGoesArrrgh Sep 4, 9:14 a.m.

    "The panel recommended that academic support services for student-athletes should operate... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    Yeah, it's about time Dracula wasn't in change of the blood bank.

  • GunnyGoesArrrgh Sep 4, 9:12 a.m.

    This story refuses to go away. The athletics dept. has cheapened the degrees of all UNC alumni.... View More

    — Posted by Luv2Camp

    Disagree. This may have cheapened the degrees that athletes get, but not the general student population - those students go to class and do their own work and EARN their degree.

  • GunnyGoesArrrgh Sep 4, 9:05 a.m.

    454 unauthorized grade changes over an 18 year period. That one sticks out. Just saying.

    — Posted by TB from WF

    Yeah - that one does jump out at you. For the grade changes to have gone on as long as 18 years shows this is not a situation that started with Butch/Wiley/Blake/Dr J, et al.


    Yawn!! Tired of hearing about UNC, and their athletics, and academics. It happens everywhere!!

    — Posted by Toddler10-21

    YEP! Even at NC State (gasp!)

    As I've said all along "Those who live in glass houses should... View More

    — Posted by Native NC gal

    being a carowhina fan I would worry about unc instead trying to implicate everyone else-- clean up your own house

  • grh90 Sep 4, 1:41 a.m.

    Well, it's about time for Markie to get another fried motherboard....or have his mother die... View More

    — Posted by uncsuckz

    Wrong. That's Dook. UNC doesn't pay players like they do over at blood diamond U a.k.a duke.

  • uncsuckz Sep 3, 10:52 p.m.

    Well, it's about time for Markie to get another fried motherboard....or have his mother die again, whichever is convenient. A direct reflection of what's gone on at unc for 20+ years....look the other way and don't question what we're doing, then deny and deflect when caught. unc=the Auburn of the ACC.

  • Deacons Sep 3, 9:25 p.m.

    What a shame, UNC had a great academic reputation. If I went to school there I would be upset because this tarnishes the schools academic reputation.

  • johnnyaudit Sep 3, 8:17 p.m.

    "The panel recommended that academic support services for student-athletes should operate... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    Sad that your institution has to be told that...........




  • ACC: North Carolina vs. Miami

    Tomorrow at 12:25 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: San Diego vs. Miami

    Tomorrow at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • SEC: Florida vs. Georgia

    Tomorrow at 3:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CFB: Notre Dame vs. Navy

    Tomorrow at 8:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • ACC: Duke at Pittsburgh

    Tomorrow at 12:00 pm on 620am

  • ACC: NC State at Syracuse

    Tomorrow at 3:00 pm on WRAL-FM

  • NHL: Carolina Hurricanes vs Arizona Coyotes

    Tomorrow at 7:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • Football Friday with Tom Suiter

    Tonight at 11:35

7:00pm Tonight
8:00pm Tonight
8:30pm Tonight
10:00pm Tonight
10:00pm Tonight
10:30pm Tonight
8:00pm Tonight
8:02pm Tonight
7:00pm Tonight
7:30pm Tonight
8:30pm Tonight
9:00pm Tonight