banner
Caulton Tudor

Rule-breaking athletes need to be accountable

Posted November 4, 2013
Updated November 5, 2013

— While NC State fans are no doubt uneasy about news that a former football player Eric Leak continues to be a concern for the school, there seems to be little question that campus leaders are taking measures to maintain institutional control.

A report by WRAL Investigates makes it clear that while the Leak situation will continue to create anxiety on both the rules and image fronts, there’s no evidence that State has been inattentive to the potential lurking damage.

Barred booster shared townhouse, cars with former Pack players Browder: Barred booster shared townhouse, cars with former Pack players

As this story continues to unfold, Wolfpack fans and officials will ask themselves some of the same questions that have been posed at North Carolina, Ohio State, Southern Cal and any other school that has had to deal with agent/player contacts.

That question: How do you stop it?

The answer, unfortunately, is you probably can’t.

Shift Accountability to Athletes?

There are some radical cures being floated, the most popular of which is finding a way to put more of the onus on rules-breaking players.

One possibility in that regard is to completely revamp the scholarship agreement model, which essentially is a year-to-year casual contract between the school and the player (or player’s guardian in some cases).

If the scholarship agreement included a clause that made a player financially responsible for monetary and/or image damage that he or she knowingly brought upon the school, there’s little doubt that the extent of such rules violations would be decreased many times over.

But is it possible to incorporate such a clause into scholarship contracts? There’s much disagreement in the legal community. For one thing, the athlete would need to hire a lawyer before signing. Otherwise, such a contract almost certainly would be spiked by judges.

That said, the vast majority of the players who break the rules with agents understand what they’re doing when they’re doing it. In some cases, the athlete even initiates contact.

If UNC’s Marvin Austin or Southern Cal’s Reggie Bush knew they could have been sued for damages by their schools when they deliberately accepted illegal goods and money, there’s good reason to think they would have abided by the rules.

A more feasible solution might be to allow any college athlete to turn pro at any time regardless of the situation.

Here’s an example: After a great performance, let’s say an agent offered the athlete a $1 million signing bonus on the spot if he would quit the team immediately to avoid any injury risk during the remainder of the season.

Fans would be outraged, of course, but having the option to cash in on his accomplishments immediately might eliminate temptation for the athlete to break rules that would endanger the reputation of the rest of his team and the school.

Agents give college basketball and football players money and gifts for only one reason  - to land future clients. But that business model doesn’t work well in most other sports. In tennis, golf, baseball, soccer, etc., the athlete can go pro straight out of high school. College golfers and tennis players can turn pro when they chose, even in the middle of a college season.

A third route is the one the state of North Carolina is pursuing by aggressively going after rules-breaking agents and agent intermediaries. If the legal consequences are severe enough, there’s reason to assume at least some agents will abide by the statues.

But under-the-table payments are almost impossible to stop, whether the donor is an agent or overzealous fan. That practice has been going for decades and no doubt will continue to some extent regardless of state or even federal laws. And paying athletes a salary will not stop illicit money from changing hands.

For now, NCSU seems to be doing its best to protect both its borders and reputation. But ultimately, the first and last lines of defense are the athletes. That aspect of the equation may never change.

26 Comments

This blogpost is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • Objective Scientist Nov 8, 1:46 p.m.

    Read this article, made a comment, then failed to look at it for several days. Just "scanned" through all of them... and there are some good comments. I'll add some additional thoughts;

    Whoever "writes the rules' - be it the NCAA or the Conference or the University - the rules should be simply and unequivocally stated - clear and 'to the point' - with no more rules than are absolutely necessary. All - ALL - to whom the rules apply - the Universities if the rule is from the NCAA or Conference, the athletic program administrators and every member of a coaching staff, and the PLAYERS/ATHLETES are all held responsible for KNOWING THE RULES and are accountable when they are broken! ESPECIALLY including the players/athletes. For the players/athletes... there MUST be clear consequences of a rule violation... including LOSS of SCHOLARSHIP, and REPAYMENT of scholarship costs and services/materials/equipment, etc. supplied to the athlete, etc., etc., etc. I could go on and on with examples. Bottom line - those INDIVIDUALS who violate rules should suffer significant consequences.

  • GunnyGoesBaaaarf Nov 7, 2:28 p.m.

    Allowing a player to go pro at any point in the season is neither fair nor feasible to a coach... View More

    — Posted by GunnyGoesBaaaarf

    Another option in dealing with impermissible benefits is to make them permissible. I would much... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Ken, like you said in another post, if the NCAA closes a loophole, somebody will develop another, and that is probably true as far as academics go as well. Look at what happened at Carolina. I'm OK with easy classes like "Rocks for Jocks", but I don't condone grades being changed, no-show classes, and things like that. There are young people who are very gifted athletically, but not academically. Where would these people go? The NCAA has dictated players be one year removed from HS to play in the NBA and (I think) three years removed from HS to play in the NFL. Other than playing in Europe, college provides the avenue for these kids to satisfy NCAA requirements.

    Tough situation, with no obvious answer. I agree with you: I'd rather see things done over the table instead of under it.

  • BISHOP5 Nov 6, 6:32 p.m.

    Allowing a player to go pro at any point in the season is neither fair nor feasible to a coach... View More

    — Posted by GunnyGoesBaaaarf

    Another option in dealing with impermissible benefits is to make them permissible. I would much... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Translation - it's not the athlete's fault for breaking the rules. Now then, anybody here willing to man up & take responsibility for the actions of others?
    Anybody will do. lol

  • Jewelry-EricLeak Nov 5, 9:18 p.m.

    Let's have NC State open their doors wide to investigation as UNC did. There will of course be... View More

    — Posted by QC

    ...exactly WHEN did unc "open their doors?" LMFAO They stone-walled with every fiber... View More

    — Posted by uncsuckz

    LMFAO at a fanbase that worships the NCAA's KING of cheaters, Jim Valvano

  • jmcdow2792 Nov 5, 5:15 p.m.

    Allowing a player to go pro at any point in the season is neither fair nor feasible to a coach... View More

    — Posted by GunnyGoesBaaaarf

    Another option in dealing with impermissible benefits is to make them permissible. I would much... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    I think you have hit the nail on the head. The rules are way to complicated and way to extensive. For example; if I as a minimal contributor (defined as booster) to State happen to meet a high school player, say working at the local McDonald's, and I casually say to him that he should think about attending State, then I have broken the NCAA rules. A lot of these rules are ridiculous. I don't pretend to know what the rules should be. However, I would think that a small committee of in the know people could come up with a complete rewrite given the guidance that the rules need to be simplified and made less restrictive on many fronts.

  • uncsuckz Nov 5, 4:42 p.m.

    Let's have NC State open their doors wide to investigation as UNC did. There will of course be... View More

    — Posted by QC

    ...exactly WHEN did unc "open their doors?" LMFAO They stone-walled with every fiber in their bank account....and still are.

  • Ken D. Nov 5, 3:32 p.m.

    Allowing a player to go pro at any point in the season is neither fair nor feasible to a coach... View More

    — Posted by GunnyGoesBaaaarf

    Another option in dealing with impermissible benefits is to make them permissible. I would much... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Hey that's right up there with making drugs legal to eliminate the drug problem, or giving... View More

    — Posted by jdpridg

    The Olympics had this exact problem. They solved it by letting the athletes receive... View More

    — Posted by uBnice

    And it wouldn't make the agents and runners any less sleazy. It would just allow them to slither out from underneath their rocks and operate in the open.

    My point is that there isn't anything inherently unethical or tawdry about players being rewarded for being good at what they do. The only thing that makes them (the players) "guilty" is that there are unreasonable rules in the first place.

  • uBnice Nov 5, 2:16 p.m.

    Allowing a player to go pro at any point in the season is neither fair nor feasible to a coach... View More

    — Posted by GunnyGoesBaaaarf

    Another option in dealing with impermissible benefits is to make them permissible. I would much... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Hey that's right up there with making drugs legal to eliminate the drug problem, or giving... View More

    — Posted by jdpridg

    The Olympics had this exact problem. They solved it by letting the athletes receive compensation. Ending prohibition did not solve the alcohol addiction problem but it sure took the violent culture surrounding illegal alcohol away.

  • jdpridg Nov 5, 1:27 p.m.

    Allowing a player to go pro at any point in the season is neither fair nor feasible to a coach... View More

    — Posted by GunnyGoesBaaaarf

    Another option in dealing with impermissible benefits is to make them permissible. I would much... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Hey that's right up there with making drugs legal to eliminate the drug problem, or giving amnesty to illegals who sneak into our country so they are no longer law breakers. That's the best idea I've heard yet. While we are at it, let's make sure we create as many rules as possible to penalize the players who follow the rules. Then we can change the name from NCAA to department of collegiate sports oversight. The government doesn't have control of that yet.

  • Ken D. Nov 5, 11:31 a.m.

    Allowing a player to go pro at any point in the season is neither fair nor feasible to a coach... View More

    — Posted by GunnyGoesBaaaarf

    Another option in dealing with impermissible benefits is to make them permissible. I would much rather have NCAA enforcement efforts directed to making sure athletes are legitimate students making satisfactory progress toward a degree.

    I don't care all that much if the star athlete is getting rewarded for his performance. So are star lawyers, and musicians, and doctors, etc.

    As fast as the NCAA finds a way to close one loophole, somebody will develop another. This is a war the NCAA can't win.

More...

 

 

  • CBB: North Carolina vs. Ohio State

    Today at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CBB: UCLA vs Kentucky

    Today at 3:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: San Diego at San Francisco

    Tonight at 8:25 on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Panthers vs. Cleveland

    Monday at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CBB: UCLA at Kentucky

    Today at 3:15 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • NFL: Philadelphia at Washington

    Today at 4:25 pm on 620am

  • NHL: Canes vs. NY Rangers

    Tonight at 7:00 on 99.9 The Fan

  • CBB: NC State at West Virginia

    Tonight at 9:30 on WRAL-FM

Scoreboard
Local
Final
PHI 91
CHA 109
1:00pm Today
UNC
OSU
 
4:00pm Today
MVSU
NCCU
 
7:00pm Tonight
UNCW
ECU
 
7:00pm Tonight
CAR
NYR
 
7:00pm Tonight
CHA
UTA
 
9:30pm Tonight
WVU
NCSU
 
Final
PHI 91
CHA 109
Final
ORL 94
UTA 101
Final
CLE 95
BRK 91
Final
BOS 114
MIN 98
Final
DET 100
TOR 110
Final
MIA 103
WAS 105
Final
MEM 97
CHI 103
Final
SAN 119
POR 129
Final
DEN 109
LAC 106
Final
LAL 103
OKC 104
1:00pm Today
NYK
PHO
 
7:00pm Tonight
NOP
POR
 
7:00pm Tonight
CHA
UTA
 
8:00pm Tonight
HOU
ATL
 
8:30pm Tonight
DAL
SAN
 
9:00pm Tonight
DEN
IND
 
10:30pm Tonight
LAC
MIL
 
11:00am Today
LALAF
NEV
2:20pm Today
UTEP
UTST
3:30pm Today
COLST
UTAH
5:45pm Tonight
AFA
WMICH
9:15pm Tonight
BGU
SALABAMA
Final
YOUNG 92
WILB 71
 
Final
TULA 56
JST 49
 
Final
RAD 76
SIENA 66
 
Final
BUCK 88
CASEWEST 65
 
Final
LIB 94
CPNC 65
 
Final
SCAR 68
CLEM 45
Final
CMICH 97
CONC 60
 
Final
MIAMI 44
EKENT 72
Final
GWEBB 91
HIWASSEE 71
 
Final
ODU 60
MDES 43
 
Final
BUF 88
NIAG 62
 
Final
KSU 71
NCAT 57
 
Final
FAM 65
UNF 83
 
Final
NORST 81
NARZ 62
 
Final
DART 58
NILL 55
 
Final
MORE 60
NKENTUCKY 83
 
Final
UCSB 69
SDCHR 46
 
Final
STJ 53
GAELS 47
Final
ALA 69
STILL 49
 
Final
HAMP 66
TENST 54
 
Final
TENN 61
TENT 58
Final
WMARY 86
WSHMD 46
 
Final
MERC 67
COOK 46
 
Final
FLGC 83
FUR 78
 
Final
CALST 49
SDKST 53
 
Final
MTST 68
CHAT 58
Final
NDAK 78
DICKINSON 48
 
Final
LAMON 76
LSUALEX 71
 
Final
PRIN 77
LIP 55
 
Final
LAM 80
MLGN 53
 
Final
MINN 92
SEAT 57
 
Final
LOYC 73
SUTAH 57
 
Final
SELA 81
WINT 71
 
Final
SILL 52
NO 56
 
Final
MARQ 83
ALAAM 49
 
Final
TTU 72
ARKPB 51
 
Final
DEN 84
COLST 85
Final
CREI 75
TXPA 60
 
Final
CAL 78
EWASH 67
Final
UTST 69
IDST 56
 
Final
UTEP 55
ARZ 60
Final
CHAM 63
HAW 94
 
12:00pm Today
GEOR
CHAR
 
12:00pm Today
WKENT
LOU
 
12:00pm Today
MICH
SMU
 
12:00pm Today
CIN
VCU
 
1:00pm Today
BSU
ABCHRIST
 
1:00pm Today
PROV
UMASS
 
1:00pm Today
AMER
MNTER
 
1:00pm Today
UNC
OSU
 
1:00pm Today
IUPUI
SALA
 
1:00pm Today
VILL
SYR
 
1:00pm Today
VT
CITA
 
1:00pm Today
DUQ
MLOWELL
 
1:30pm Today
FAIR
BEL
 
2:00pm Today
YALE
GTDNS
 
2:00pm Today
FD
DEL
 
2:00pm Today
PSU
DREX
 
2:00pm Today
UNCG
ELON
 
2:00pm Today
ILL
MIZZ
 
2:00pm Today
CAMP
MONT
 
2:00pm Today
LONG
PSUBEAVER
 
2:00pm Today
HOU
SCST
 
2:00pm Today
FSU
SFLA
 
2:00pm Today
BING
BONA
 
2:00pm Today
RUTG
RFLSH
 
2:00pm Today
MCNST
TOL
 
2:00pm Today
JVU
TRUETT
 
2:00pm Today
GT
VANDY
 
2:05pm Today
INDST
EILL
 
2:30pm Today
BUT
IND
 
3:00pm Today
STEPH
ARTCH
 
3:00pm Today
OREG
DELST
 
3:00pm Today
Terriers
FATL
 
3:00pm Today
TXARL
HPYN
 
3:00pm Today
KU
LAF
 
3:00pm Today
ARKST
MARS
 
3:00pm Today
MEM
ORU
 
3:00pm Today
KNST
UMBC
 
3:00pm Today
NW
WMICH
 
3:05pm Today
MIZST
EMICH
 
3:05pm Today
CHIST
STJOE
 
3:30pm Today
KENT
UCLA
 
4:00pm Today
COC
DAVID
 
4:00pm Today
RIU
DET
 
4:00pm Today
UCR
HOUB
 
4:00pm Today
MURST
ILLST
 
4:00pm Today
NWST
LALAF
 
4:00pm Today
WAGN
MON
 
4:00pm Today
MVSU
NCCU
 
4:00pm Today
PITT
OU
 
4:00pm Today
TENNM
PBY
 
4:00pm Today
WYO
SOUTH
 
4:00pm Today
AFA
UCD
 
4:00pm Today
MSST
USCU
 
5:00pm Tonight
JMU
HIGH
 
5:00pm Tonight
TXST
HTILL
 
5:00pm Tonight
DRAK
ISU
 
5:00pm Tonight
SHU
UNH
 
5:00pm Tonight
SCU
NE
 
5:00pm Tonight
MSU
TXSOU
 
5:00pm Tonight
UF
WAKE
 
5:15pm Tonight
ND
PURD
 
5:30pm Tonight
SHSU
PVU
 
6:00pm Tonight
AUB
XAV
 
7:00pm Tonight
AKR
BLUFFTON
 
7:00pm Tonight
DAY
BU
 
7:00pm Tonight
UNCW
ECU
 
7:00pm Tonight
CLMB
HOF
 
7:00pm Tonight
GMAS
IONA
 
7:00pm Tonight
TOWS
LAS
 
7:00pm Tonight
MAN
MRGST
 
7:00pm Tonight
CCST
YALE
 
7:00pm Tonight
PEPP
RICH
 
7:00pm Tonight
MAR
STJOE
 
7:00pm Tonight
KYST
TEXAM
 
7:00pm Tonight
MAST
VALPO
 
7:05pm Tonight
UMKC
INCWORD
 
7:30pm Tonight
IDST
CALST
 
7:30pm Tonight
NIOWA
IOWA
 
7:30pm Tonight
SIUE
UWMIL
 
8:00pm Tonight
TEX
LBSU
 
8:00pm Tonight
TCU
TXSA
 
8:30pm Tonight
ARK
SEMIZ
 
9:00pm Tonight
NCOL
JVST
 
9:00pm Tonight
ARST
LEH
 
9:00pm Tonight
NMST
NMU
 
9:00pm Tonight
WASH
OKLA
 
9:00pm Tonight
GRCN
STED
 
9:00pm Tonight
WEBER
WLVRN
 
9:30pm Tonight
WVU
NCSU
 
10:00pm Tonight
SDST
BST
 
10:00pm Tonight
GONZ
CPSL
 
10:00pm Tonight
PAC
FRES
 
10:00pm Tonight
PORT
MNTST
 
10:00pm Tonight
CSNO
TAMCC
 
10:05pm Tonight
UTST
SDKST
 
11:00pm Tonight
BYU
STAN
 
11:30pm Tonight
UNLV
UTAH
 
Final
NJD 3
TAM 2
Final
OTT 6
ANA 2
Final
DET 1
NYI 2
Final
WIN 2
BOS 1
Final
CAL 1
DAL 2
4:00pm Today
LOS
ARI
 
7:00pm Tonight
CLB
CHI
 
7:00pm Tonight
BUF
COL
 
7:00pm Tonight
PIT
FLA
 
7:00pm Tonight
CAR
NYR
 
7:00pm Tonight
MON
OTT
 
7:00pm Tonight
TOR
PHI
 
7:00pm Tonight
NYI
TAM
 
7:00pm Tonight
NJD
WAS
 
8:00pm Tonight
MIN
NAS
 
10:00pm Tonight
VAN
CAL
 
10:30pm Tonight
SJS
STL
 
4:30pm Today
WAS
PHI
8:25pm Tonight
SFX
SDC