Caulton Tudor

Rule-breaking athletes need to be accountable

Posted November 4, 2013
Updated November 5, 2013

— While NC State fans are no doubt uneasy about news that a former football player Eric Leak continues to be a concern for the school, there seems to be little question that campus leaders are taking measures to maintain institutional control.

A report by WRAL Investigates makes it clear that while the Leak situation will continue to create anxiety on both the rules and image fronts, there’s no evidence that State has been inattentive to the potential lurking damage.

Barred booster shared townhouse, cars with former Pack players Browder: Barred booster shared townhouse, cars with former Pack players

As this story continues to unfold, Wolfpack fans and officials will ask themselves some of the same questions that have been posed at North Carolina, Ohio State, Southern Cal and any other school that has had to deal with agent/player contacts.

That question: How do you stop it?

The answer, unfortunately, is you probably can’t.

Shift Accountability to Athletes?

There are some radical cures being floated, the most popular of which is finding a way to put more of the onus on rules-breaking players.

One possibility in that regard is to completely revamp the scholarship agreement model, which essentially is a year-to-year casual contract between the school and the player (or player’s guardian in some cases).

If the scholarship agreement included a clause that made a player financially responsible for monetary and/or image damage that he or she knowingly brought upon the school, there’s little doubt that the extent of such rules violations would be decreased many times over.

But is it possible to incorporate such a clause into scholarship contracts? There’s much disagreement in the legal community. For one thing, the athlete would need to hire a lawyer before signing. Otherwise, such a contract almost certainly would be spiked by judges.

That said, the vast majority of the players who break the rules with agents understand what they’re doing when they’re doing it. In some cases, the athlete even initiates contact.

If UNC’s Marvin Austin or Southern Cal’s Reggie Bush knew they could have been sued for damages by their schools when they deliberately accepted illegal goods and money, there’s good reason to think they would have abided by the rules.

A more feasible solution might be to allow any college athlete to turn pro at any time regardless of the situation.

Here’s an example: After a great performance, let’s say an agent offered the athlete a $1 million signing bonus on the spot if he would quit the team immediately to avoid any injury risk during the remainder of the season.

Fans would be outraged, of course, but having the option to cash in on his accomplishments immediately might eliminate temptation for the athlete to break rules that would endanger the reputation of the rest of his team and the school.

Agents give college basketball and football players money and gifts for only one reason  - to land future clients. But that business model doesn’t work well in most other sports. In tennis, golf, baseball, soccer, etc., the athlete can go pro straight out of high school. College golfers and tennis players can turn pro when they chose, even in the middle of a college season.

A third route is the one the state of North Carolina is pursuing by aggressively going after rules-breaking agents and agent intermediaries. If the legal consequences are severe enough, there’s reason to assume at least some agents will abide by the statues.

But under-the-table payments are almost impossible to stop, whether the donor is an agent or overzealous fan. That practice has been going for decades and no doubt will continue to some extent regardless of state or even federal laws. And paying athletes a salary will not stop illicit money from changing hands.

For now, NCSU seems to be doing its best to protect both its borders and reputation. But ultimately, the first and last lines of defense are the athletes. That aspect of the equation may never change.


This blogpost is closed for comments.

Newest First
View all
  • moveythemez Nov 4, 9:06 p.m.

    I wholeheartedly agree, a college athlete gets his institiution in hot water and it the university that loses revenue, and the left behind players that get punished. Make them sit out for the number of years, from the pro league they are goling to, for the number of years their school is on probation.

  • uncsuckz Nov 4, 10:58 p.m.

    Meanwhile, the coach just walks away with his pockets chock full of gold. He is the adult in all of this and should not be allowed to skirt free. Wherever he lands, he should carry any sanctions he has allowed to incur, with him. No more wiping his slate clean simply because he has a change of address.

    Kids are kids, even if they're 6-6 and 325 lbs. Dangle something shiny in front of them and they'll bite. Is it wrong? Yes, and they ought to held accountable. But first and foremost, just what kind of example are the adults setting? ...I yield to the prosecution....

  • Objective Scientist Nov 4, 11:31 p.m.

    What Tudor proposes is what I've been saying for YEARS! The athletes themselves MUST be held accountable!!! The athletes - and often coaches who "break rules" - have done "damage" to the University, the athletic program, etc. - they should be held ACCOUNTABLE!

  • rduguyhere Nov 4, 11:33 p.m.

    Mooers never win!

  • jeff727 Nov 5, 2:00 a.m.

    Mooers never win!

    — Posted by rduguyhere

    and only use words like "mooers"...

  • acc_blood Nov 5, 2:23 a.m.

    To predict that Marvin Austin would have thought twice about breaking the rules if he's financially liable for the actions is wrong on several fronts. First of all, the thought that Marvin Austin would actually THINK is laughable. He had no business being a student at UNC. Second, someone that lacks the respect for himself or his school to get busted by tweeting pictures of his illegal activities really wouldn't care about any kind of liability. Finally, even IF he would be required to pay UNC some sort of restitution, that just means the money from agents would include the pay-off promise.

  • dooksucks_1 Nov 5, 5:38 a.m.

    How about Lance Thomas Carlton with nearly 100K in jewelry bought while a senior at Dook?

    The terms themselves should have brought down Dook, but K skated yet again.

  • Gunnstigator Nov 5, 6:14 a.m.

    Allowing a player to go pro at any point in the season is neither fair nor feasible to a coach and team IMHO. One and done players have already made it difficult for coaches to maintain continuity in their teams, I can't imagine what would happen if players could bolt at any point in the season.

    Prosecuting agents/runners seems like the most effective way of discouraging impermissible benefits. Unscrupulous agents/runners will find a way, but I'd think the threat of jail time would significantly cut down on impermissible benefits.

  • QC Nov 5, 8:45 a.m.

    Let's have NC State open their doors wide to investigation as UNC did. There will of course be infractions. Dig deeper. Tip of the iceberg, as Woofies like to say.

  • early exit Roy Nov 5, 8:53 a.m.

    State fans shouldn't worry. This is minor compared to unc scandals and we will probably get an award for having such minor problems. When we have bogus classes, bogus professors given out grades, tutors that are doing work for athletes and giving them other fringe" benefits, agents on staff, runners for agents that are unc athletes, then you can say something. Otherwise keep your mouth shut.




  • NASL: RailHawks vs. Ft. Lauderdale

    Tomorrow at 7:30 am on WRAL-2

  • PGA: RBC Heritage

    Tomorrow at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • PGA: RBC Heritage

    Sunday at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • PGA: Zurich Classic of New Orleans

    Saturday at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • MLB: Atlanta Braves at NY Mets

    Tomorrow at 7:05 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • MLB: Baltimore Orioles at Boston Red Sox

    Sunday at 7:05 pm on 99.9 The Fan

7:05pm Tonight
7:05pm Tonight
7:05pm Tonight
7:05pm Tonight
7:08pm Tonight
7:10pm Tonight
7:10pm Tonight
7:10pm Tonight
7:10pm Tonight
8:05pm Tonight
8:10pm Tonight
8:40pm Tonight
10:05pm Tonight
10:10pm Tonight
10:10pm Tonight
7:00pm Tonight
7:30pm Tonight
10:00pm Tonight
7:05pm Tonight