Adam Gold

NCAA athletes could receive cut of TV money

Posted January 30, 2013

Who are the most underpaid athletes in professional sports?

If you responded with anything other than college football and men's basketball players, you have answered this question incorrectly.  

I'm sorry for being misleading, but economically speaking, there is little, if any, difference between the college and pro games. The five – for the time being, at least – major football conferences currently are worth roughly $1 billion annually in television revenue alone.  

Then add NCAA men's basketball tournament monies, collegiate licensing dollars (you know, those numbered jerseys walking around college campuses on top of co-eds and intramural wannabes) and even the video games that use the likenesses of current and former players without any compensation, and you can see that no athletes on planet earth receive less compared to their overall value than those in college.

Well, there's a fairly good chance that the NCAA's mind-blowingly unfair business model is going to undergo a face lift. A California federal court judge has dealt a blow to the NCAA in an antitrust class action suit brought against it by former UCLA star Ed O'Bannon.

The suit began attacking video game manufacturers for using the images of current and former college players without compensation. The NCAA countered that college athletes voluntarily agreed to giving up any right to profit off their image, and that is true, until you understand that without doing so, they'd also forfeit their right to play, so I'm not entirely sure what's "voluntary" about that system.  

However, voluntary or not, the suit says that those rights were never intended to be forever. Players who were no longer saddled by their amateur status should have the right to profit from their likeness.

Obviously, the NCAA sees it differently. Imagine how much money would be owed to every player in every NCAA Tournament scene that has been used commercially? How much would the late Lorenzo Charles have received if he was eligible for royalties each time his game-winning dunk appeared in a commercial Even the University of Houston player weeping and slapping his hand on the floor would be eligible for compensation – every single time that footage was used commercially.  

Whoa! Now you see where this is headed.

Recently, the lawsuit was expanded to include the massive amount of live television money generated by the two revenue-producing sports and the NCAA went to court to prevent the addition on procedural grounds. Well, federal court judge Claudia Wilken sided with the plaintiffs in the case and a hearing is set for her courtroom on June 20 at which time the NCAA will have to argue on the merits of the law as opposed to procedure.

Merits? This doesn't bode well for the NCAA, and their corporate partner, Collegiate Licensing Company. It's got to be a tough sell to convince a judge that an industry that is worth billions of dollars annually is justified in giving back so little to the players we watch on fall Saturday afternoons and all throughout the madness of March. I can't wait to hear those arguments.

The Big Ten should be allowed to continue to distribute nearly $30 million per school in TV revenue alone, with much of that money finding it's way to the coaches and administrators while they try and placate the student-athletes with a stipend that amounts to a couple of dollars an hour.

But Adam, what about scholarships? Isn't that fair compensation?  And don't the jocks get the best dorms and the best dining hall food – if there is such a thing?

Yes, those things have value, but please don't insult your own intelligence by actually suggesting those to be an economically equitable exchange. Even if we're talking about $50,000 per year in value – which we're absolutely not – it still falls way short of being fair.

The truth of the matter is that the only reason for this situation is that college athletes have no players association like they have in the professional leagues, though that soon may change. We've recently discovered that former college athletes have banded together, and with the support of former college stars Bill Russell and Oscar Robertson, have laid the foundation for an organization, the Former College Athletes Association (FCAA) to negotiate licensing agreements with video game companies, member colleges and the NCAA. Of course, the former players still have to win their case, which is not a slam dunk.

My point is not that the NCAA should pay players, or that eligible players should receive a cut of the TV dollars, though licensing money should definitely be open for discussion. The reality is that there's no way, economically, that college athletes can become actual employees. If you think there's a gulf between the haves and the have-nots now…? It would be multiplied by a hundred in that case.

It's simply time to have an honest discussion about amateurism and the way the NCAA treats student athletes. That schools can make huge amounts of money off the images of current players and hide behind the facade of amateurism is borderline criminal. At the very least, former players should be allowed to benefit financially from video games and the sale of merchandise, but you could make the argument that even current players should get something more than laundry money in the process.

The biggest problem I see is that there isn't anyone truly looking out for the athletes' best interests. Even the most noble of coaches still does what's best for the program, first. If the two happen align, that's fantastic. But, if a choice needs to be made, they'll opt for program over individual – and that's not necessarily the wrong way for them to act. So allow players to have representation while they're in school. Allow a professional, someone approved by the university via a thorough screening process, to look out for the best interests of the player. And, if the marketplace sees a value in a financial arrangement between a company and given players – and we know that they will – allow it to happen. If those professionals see value in loaning players money, allow that to happen. But, let's stop pretending that the current system is even remotely equitable and can be remedied with the loose change in between the NCAA's couch cushions.

I have no idea how this story is going to end. In fact, while the hearing is scheduled for mid-June, the actual trial isn't going to start until the summer of 2014 – and that's assuming that there won't be typical pre-trial delays. Throw in the inevitable appeals, regardless of the victor, and we're unlikely to see a resolution to this case until 2015 or 2016 at the earliest. The important part of this story though, is that it seems certain that we're closing in on a sea change in the economics of intercollegiate athletics, and while that might not be the best thing for the NCAA and their member schools, it's exactly what needs to happen for the benefit of the athletes.

After all, while so many wallets are growing fat in this era of high dollar college sports, isn't it fair to at least give the athletes a little slice of that pie.

48 Comments

Please to add a comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Ken D. Jan 31, 3:49 p.m.

    And let's face it. If a few of those 26 sports were to dropped, the only people who would notice are the athletes and their families. I'm sure there are more athletes on UNC's women's rowing team on scholarship (20) than the number of spectators who have watched them perform.

  • Ken D. Jan 31, 3:15 p.m.

    Here's a question for you. If athletic scholarships were prohibited, how many of today's D-I... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    One of the big problems is that football and basketball must fund the entire athletic budget at... View More

    — Posted by uBnice

    UNC's athletic budget is large, I grant you. But at least $6 million a year of that is athletic scholarships in sports other than football. If only football were spun off from the university, and all athletic scholarships were eliminated, I believe the remaining costs would be manageable. And for schools with much smaller budgets than UNC's, that would be even more true.

  • uBnice Jan 31, 2:11 p.m.

    Here's a question for you. If athletic scholarships were prohibited, how many of today's D-I... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    One of the big problems is that football and basketball must fund the entire athletic budget at these Universities. For example, UNC-CH's athletic budget is $75-$80 million. That money is more than enough to have football and basketball entertainment businesses, but funding the other 26 sports makes it seems otherwise.

    So one solution is to make all non-revenue generating sports intramural and if we as a society want them bad enough, then let the taxpayer pay for it. Title IX should be paid for by the taxpayers, not the basketball and football players. And I support Title IX in principle.

  • Ken D. Jan 31, 10:27 a.m.

    Here's a question for you. If athletic scholarships were prohibited, how many of today's D-I schools would opt to sponsor a semi-pro football team, and how many would continue to field amateur teams the way the Ivy League does - with real students?

    I doubt if Duke or Wake Forest would. But what about schools like State and Carolina, which until now have never been truly competitive nationally? Would they invest the big bucks if they had to compete at a level where only the top 40-50 or so programs were their competition every week? Right now, by being able to play many of their games against other mediocre (and some awful) teams, they win a few more than they lose. If every opponent was a Southern Cal, Alabama, Oklahoma, etc. and they only won a few games a year, would their fans support that?

  • Ken D. Jan 31, 10:17 a.m.

    The simple solution for all this is to do away with all athletic scholarships, and make football... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Best idea here, Ken.

    — Posted by StunGunn

    And happy birthday, gunny. :)

  • Ken D. Jan 31, 10:14 a.m.

    They get full scholarships to get a FREE education. They are already getting paid! To give them... View More

    — Posted by natsfan1965

    It is a job because Div I football and basketball are entertainment businesses that have very... View More

    — Posted by uBnice

    I agree. They are getting paid. There is no more obvious quid pro quo than a contract in which a player receives something of value in direct exchange for performing a service for a specified period of time (one year). This is an employment contract, plain and simple. The only way you can argue otherwise is to argue that neither the education nor the stipend for room and board have any value. Try to picture Duke's president trying to make that argument in court.

    The problem in basketball is fixable if athletic scholarships are prohibited. The NBA would likely have to allow all high school graduates to enter the league immediately, and they would have to continue to have a viable D-league. The NBA might not like this so much, since they now enjoy the free publicity they get from the NCAA. But a lot of their current superstars never played college ball, so they can get past that.

    Football is a much tougher nut to crack. Now, nobody can tell me that the NFL can't afford to finance a development league large enough to produce 250 rookie candidates a year. But how do you identify which players to bring into this D-league straight out of high school? You'd probably guess wrong as often as you'd guess right. So you would still have to rely on truly amateur college teams to provide some of your talent. And that pool would be limited to those students affluent enough to pay for their education, or bright enough to get an academic scholarship.

    There are no easy answers to this problem. But that doesn't mean schools shouldn't stop looking for one.

  • StunGunn Jan 31, 9:55 a.m.

    The simple solution for all this is to do away with all athletic scholarships, and make football... View More

    — Posted by Ken D.

    Best idea here, Ken.

  • uBnice Jan 30, 7:22 p.m.

    They get full scholarships to get a FREE education. They are already getting paid! To give them... View More

    — Posted by natsfan1965

    It is a job because Div I football and basketball are entertainment businesses that have very little to do with academia. Those college athletes and others are semi-professionals who spend, on average, 30-40 hours per week engaged in a very physical job that makes the Universities and the NCAA billions of dollars.

    The education is not free. If they don't play ball, they can't attend. They are not protected under workman's compensation and they do sustain injuries. Just like in the professional leagues. Universities have no obligation to a debilitated former player.

    It really is time to remove basketball and football businesses out of the schools. The economic model is unsustainable. The United States is the only country that does this with their college students. Everywhere else, those players would be playing on a club team in a semi-professional league. And then we won't have to pretend that a player who shouldn't even be in college will actually do college work like a regular student and work a physical, demanding job 30 to 40 hours a week.

  • Constitutional-Defender Jan 30, 7:16 p.m.

    These guys are getting free ride scholarships to attend colleges of their choice, get over it... View More

    — Posted by Mustange

    Free scholly is nothing compared to a billion dollar annual revenue take. It's actually wrong to not share more with the ones who generate it. "A free ride scholarship". LMA OFFFF!!!!!

  • MoDuke v2 is gone Jan 30, 7:07 p.m.

    That means everyone else would get to do what Dook has done for years, pay players.

    — Posted by DooksucksV3

    Are you really that stupid?!

    — Posted by lanecc

    If I may be allowed to answer that for you, the answer is a resounding YES!

More...

 

 

  • ACC: NC State at Georgia Tech

    Today at 12:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • SEC: Arkansas at Florida

    Today at 2:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • PGA: Waste Management Phoenix Open

    Today at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • Big 10: Michigan at Michigan State

    Tomorrow at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • ACC: NC State at Georgia Tech

    Today at 12:00 pm on WRAL-FM

  • ACC: Duke at Virginia

    Tonight at 7:00 on 620am

  • NHL: Hurricanes at NY Rangers

    Tonight at 7:00 on 99.9 The Fan

  • Super Bowl: Seattle vs. New England

    Tomorrow at 6:30 pm on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
Local
Final
CAR 2
STL 3
12:00pm Today
GT
NCSU
 
4:00pm Today
LOU
UNC
 
7:00pm Tonight
NYR
CAR
 
7:00pm Tonight
UVA
DUKE
 
7:00pm Tonight
ETST
NCCU
 
9:00pm Tonight
DEN
CHA
 
Final
PHI 103
MIN 94
Final
BOS 87
HOU 93
Final
ATL 105
POR 99
Final
CLE 101
SAC 90
Final
BRK 122
TOR 127
Final
MIA 72
DAL 93
Final
NOP 108
LAC 103
Final
UTA 110
GSW 100
4th
PHO 70
CHI 69
 
7:00pm Tonight
ORL
DAL
 
7:00pm Tonight
IND
SAC
 
7:00pm Tonight
WAS
TOR
 
7:30pm Tonight
DET
HOU
 
7:30pm Tonight
ATL
PHI
 
8:00pm Tonight
MIN
CLE
 
8:00pm Tonight
MEM
OKC
 
8:30pm Tonight
MIL
POR
 
9:00pm Tonight
DEN
CHA
 
9:00pm Tonight
SAN
LAC
 
10:30pm Tonight
GSW
PHO
 
Final
PRIN 72
HARV 75
 
Final
CORN 57
BRO 49
 
Final
PENN 58
DART 51
 
Final
NIAG 61
MAR 65
 
Final
CAN 63
QUIN 57
 
Final
MAN 87
SIENA 79
 
Final
WILL 63
IUPUI 59
 
Final
FAIR 59
MON 60
 
Final
ARST 67
OREG 68
Final
CLMB 59
YALE 63
 
Final
BUF 80
KSU 55
 
Final
ARZ 57
ORST 34
 
12:00pm Today
TENN
AUB
 
12:00pm Today
CLEM
BC
 
12:00pm Today
STJOE
DAVID
 
12:00pm Today
GT
NCSU
 
12:00pm Today
PITT
ND
 
12:00pm Today
STJ
PROV
 
12:00pm Today
UNH
USB
 
12:00pm Today
WVU
TTU
 
12:00pm Today
TEMPL
TULA
 
12:00pm Today
EMICH
WMICH
 
12:00pm Today
IOWA
WISC
 
12:00pm Today
SHU
XAV
 
1:00pm Today
UF
ARK
 
1:00pm Today
STET
LIP
 
1:00pm Today
ILL
PSU
 
1:00pm Today
TULSA
SFLA
 
1:05pm Today
INDST
BRAD
 
2:00pm Today
MAINE
GTDNS
 
2:00pm Today
UGST
ARKST
 
2:00pm Today
LEH
BU
 
2:00pm Today
MARQ
BUT
 
2:00pm Today
DEL
COC
 
2:00pm Today
CREI
GEOR
 
2:00pm Today
CLST
UWGB
 
2:00pm Today
NEOM
MAST
 
2:00pm Today
LOYC
ILLST
 
2:00pm Today
KU
KYST
 
2:00pm Today
JVU
KNST
 
2:00pm Today
MSST
LSU
 
2:00pm Today
SHU
MNTER
 
2:00pm Today
VCU
RICH
 
2:00pm Today
ISU
TCU
 
2:00pm Today
BING
MLOWELL
 
2:00pm Today
HART
VERM
 
2:00pm Today
DEP
VILL
 
2:00pm Today
WAKE
VT
 
3:00pm Today
FAM
COOK
 
3:00pm Today
NDAK
IDST
 
3:00pm Today
ARMY
GHND
 
3:00pm Today
BEL
TENT
 
3:00pm Today
TXSA
UAB
 
3:00pm Today
ILLCH
VALPO
 
3:05pm Today
DRAK
EVAN
 
3:15pm Today
IND
RUTG
 
3:30pm Today
UMO
BST
 
4:00pm Today
RMU
BRY
 
4:00pm Today
WAGN
CCST
 
4:00pm Today
GWEBB
CCAR
 
4:00pm Today
MDES
COPST
 
4:00pm Today
RFLSH
FD
 
4:00pm Today
RIU
GWU
 
4:00pm Today
SCAR
UGA
 
4:00pm Today
Terriers
LIU
 
4:00pm Today
PAC
LMU
 
4:00pm Today
STLU
UMASS
 
4:00pm Today
HOW
MRGST
 
4:00pm Today
DREX
UNCW
 
4:00pm Today
LOU
UNC
 
4:00pm Today
MIZZ
MISS
 
4:00pm Today
ALCOR
SOUTH
 
4:00pm Today
NIOWA
WICHS
 
4:00pm Today
JMU
WMARY
 
4:00pm Today
RAD
WINT
 
4:15pm Today
EILL
SIUE
 
4:30pm Today
UNCA
CAMP
 
4:30pm Today
MORE
EKENT
 
4:30pm Today
NICST
INCWORD
 
4:30pm Today
CMICH
OHIO
 
4:30pm Today
TEXAM
VANDY
 
5:00pm Tonight
UWMIL
DET
 
5:00pm Tonight
LAMON
SALA
 
5:00pm Tonight
UNCG
WCU
 
5:05pm Tonight
EWASH
IDAHO
 
5:30pm Tonight
SDKST
DEN
 
5:30pm Tonight
SHSU
HOUB
 
5:30pm Tonight
MVSU
JST
 
5:30pm Tonight
TXST
LALAF
 
5:30pm Tonight
LATU
MARS
 
5:30pm Tonight
SD
ORU
 
6:00pm Tonight
PVU
ALAAM
 
6:00pm Tonight
GRAM
ARKPB
 
6:00pm Tonight
PRIN
DART
 
6:00pm Tonight
SCST
DELST
 
6:00pm Tonight
COLST
FRES
 
6:00pm Tonight
NORST
HAMP
 
6:00pm Tonight
MINN
NEB
 
6:00pm Tonight
WYO
NEV
 
6:00pm Tonight
SAV
NCAT
 
6:00pm Tonight
GAELS
PEPP
 
6:00pm Tonight
NW
PURD
 
6:00pm Tonight
BAY
TEX
 
6:00pm Tonight
CHAT
CITA
 
6:00pm Tonight
SMISS
WKENT
 
6:00pm Tonight
CORN
YALE
 
7:00pm Tonight
LAM
ABCHRIST
 
7:00pm Tonight
BGU
AKR
 
7:00pm Tonight
KENT
ALA
 
7:00pm Tonight
CLMB
BRO
 
7:00pm Tonight
LIB
CSOU
 
7:00pm Tonight
BUCK
COL
 
7:00pm Tonight
UVA
DUKE
 
7:00pm Tonight
NE
ELON
 
7:00pm Tonight
CHAR
FIU
 
7:00pm Tonight
ODU
FATL
 
7:00pm Tonight
SAMF
FUR
 
7:00pm Tonight
DUQ
GMAS
 
7:00pm Tonight
PENN
HARV
 
7:00pm Tonight
LBSU
HAW
 
7:00pm Tonight
BONA
LAS
 
7:00pm Tonight
NAVY
LAF
 
7:00pm Tonight
PBY
LONG
 
7:00pm Tonight
WOFF
MERC
 
7:00pm Tonight
ETST
NCCU
 
7:00pm Tonight
MCNST
NO
 
7:00pm Tonight
FLGC
NKENTUCKY
 
7:00pm Tonight
IONA
PETE
 
7:00pm Tonight
STEPH
TAMCC
 
7:00pm Tonight
UNF
USCU
 
7:30pm Tonight
GSOUT
ARKLR
 
8:00pm Tonight
UCR
CSNO
 
8:00pm Tonight
SELA
NWST
 
8:00pm Tonight
OKST
OKLA
 
8:00pm Tonight
UNT
RICE
 
8:00pm Tonight
SDU
USF
 
8:00pm Tonight
NMU
SJST
 
8:00pm Tonight
PEAY
SEMIZ
 
8:00pm Tonight
NILL
TOL
 
8:00pm Tonight
HOF
TOWS
 
8:00pm Tonight
SMU
UCF
 
8:00pm Tonight
MURST
TENNM
 
8:00pm Tonight
SDST
UTST
 
8:05pm Tonight
MIZST
SILL
 
8:15pm Tonight
TXARL
TROY
 
8:30pm Tonight
TXSOU
ALAST
 
8:30pm Tonight
TENST
JVST
 
8:30pm Tonight
WASU
STAN
 
9:00pm Tonight
GRCN
CHIST
 
9:00pm Tonight
UTEP
MTST
 
9:00pm Tonight
SUTAH
NARZ
 
9:00pm Tonight
BYU
SCU
 
9:00pm Tonight
NMST
TXPA
 
9:00pm Tonight
NCOL
WEBER
 
10:00pm Tonight
UNLV
AFA
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCD
CPSL
 
10:00pm Tonight
GONZ
MEM
 
10:00pm Tonight
CALST
SEAT
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCI
UCSB
 
10:05pm Tonight
SACST
MONT
 
10:05pm Tonight
PORST
MNTST
 
10:30pm Tonight
UCLA
COL
 
10:30pm Tonight
WLVRN
UMKC
 
Final
NJD 1
PIT 2
Final
CAR 2
STL 3
Final
COL 3
NAS 0
3rd
ANA 1
CHI 4
 
1:00pm Today
MON
WAS
 
2:00pm Today
DET
NYI
 
3:00pm Today
OTT
ARI
 
7:00pm Tonight
NYR
CAR
 
7:00pm Tonight
WIN
DAL
 
7:00pm Tonight
NJD
FLA
 
7:00pm Tonight
BOS
LOS
 
7:00pm Tonight
PHI
TOR
 
7:30pm Tonight
TAM
CLB
 
10:00pm Tonight
CAL
EDM
 
10:30pm Tonight
SJS
CHI