banner
Adam Gold

Sorry Pete, the ban must stay

Posted August 26

This past Sunday marked the 25th anniversary of one of the darkest days in baseball history. Pete Rose, a player whose style was emulated by millions of boys on Little League fields all over the United States, was banished from Major League Baseball due to his involvement with gambling.

It was on Aug. 24, 1989, when then commissioner, A. Bartlett Giamatti, made the announcement to a packed New York City hotel ballroom.

"The banishment for life for Pete Rose from baseball is the sad end of a sorry episode. One of the game's greatest players has engaged in a variety of acts that have stained the game, and he must now live with the consequences of those acts….lifetime ineligibility."

Yet Monday night, at the culmination of an incredibly well-done, thoughtful, hour-long special on ESPN, Keith Olbermann declared, "…let him back in."

LET HIM BACK IN?

Into what? Into the Hall of Fame?

I've written about this before. In fact, it was only a week or so ago, in an open letter to new commissioner Rob Manfred, that I argued Rose, along with confirmed and suspected steroid users should have a bust at the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum in Cooperstown, NY, if their exploits on the field merit such enshrinement. The trade-off, in my opinion, is that on their plaque, all transgressions would be so noted for every man, woman and child to read. It is, in fact, just a museum. And museums that fail to tell the complete story do a disservice to those visiting.

On top of that, as I pointed out a couple of weeks ago, the game is not standing in the way of Rose, or any of the other greats who -- in the current climate -- have as much chance of election to the Hall as I have of qualifying for the PGA Tour this fall. That is the Hall of Fame's call. It was their decision and one that was reached AFTER Rose accepted his sentence from the commissioner.

The Hall, in order to avoid the embarrassment of having a player such as Rose, who committed the one cardinal sin against the sport, honored with induction. It was those in charge of the Musuem who changed the rules to exclude from consideration any player on the official banned list by Major League Baseball.

Obviously, this is to what Olbermann was referring Monday night, in the last line of his commentary regarding lifting Rose's lifetime ban. And, Keith did a marvelous job stating salient points in his favor. Twenty five years in a prison without walls is a difficult sentence, especially for one -- Rose -- who really has so much to offer about the game. That MLB has, in the past, utilized Rose when it was financially worthwhile for the league is not to be overlooked. In fact, it is likely to happen again next summer when the All Star Game comes to Cincinnati.

Then, there is the grand slam of comparisons, the performance enhancing drug cheats are treated less harshly than the all time hit king. How is that possible? How can Mark McGwire be a hitting coach for the Dodgers and Pete Rose can't work for the Reds in any capacity? McGwire and Sammy Sosa staged, what we now know to be, a tainted and fraudulent home run derby during the 1998 season.   Each flew past Roger Maris' single-season record of 62 home runs -- with the added insult of McGwire doing so in front of Maris' family in St. Louis.

Alex Rodriguez, a multiple steroid offender and a Hall of Fame liar, is eligible to return to PLAY for the Yankees next season, and while there is almost no chance of that ever actually coming to fruition, that it remains a possibility just doesn't seem fair in a logical sense.

But, therein lies the difference between steroids and gambling, as it relates to the business and competition of baseball. Performance enhancers cheat the game in several ways. It gives those that choose to use a physical and psychological advantage over those that don't. It distorts our ability to relate what we see today, or saw yesterday, to those that came before. And, while you may find it laughable that baseball is so beholden to statistical data of yesteryear that they would consider this is be such a high crime, I will simply say, that's the way it is. Not every sport can be like football where we simply don't know most, if any, of the significant NFL records beyond how many Super Bowl titles Joe Montana or Tom Brady have accumulated.

The reason why steroid cheats aren't as bad as having a sitting manager bet on major league baseball games, including those in which HIS OWN TEAM was playing, is that involving gambling invites the possibility that the competition has been compromised in some way. When you boil it all down, when you pare away the entertainment, the rules, the colors, the cheerleaders, the mascots in go carts and sausage races, the only thing that sports really has is the notion of fair, on-field competition. While the economic scales might be tilted in one way or another, when the ball is put in play, we must trust that the outcome has not been predetermined.

I'm not worried that Pete Rose is going to manage a minor league team. I'm not worried that Rose will go to work for a big league club in some community outreach program. I'm not so bitter towards Rose that I want him to continue to be a baseball outcast. But, the commissioner has really one job to execute during his term in office, and that is to guarantee as best he can that the competition is legitimate. That's why Kennesaw Mountain Landis' decision to ban the eight Chicago White Sox players involved in throwing the 1919 World Series -- to the Cincinnati Reds, strangely enough -- was fair and just.

Do I detest the notion that steroid cheats are treated with less revulsion -- or at least finality -- than Rose? Yes. But, one is a crime against the record books while the other is a crime against the sport. The former is terrible, but we're adult enough to be able to reason through that wreckage and deal with distorted home run totals. The latter….well, we might as well just be professional wrestling.

10 Comments

This blogpost is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • tasfrog Aug 29, 3:32 p.m.

    actually his jersey and some other things are in the HOF. other than a not having a plaque on the first floor you wouldn't know he wasn't in it

  • doustoi Aug 29, 5:36 a.m.

    I so often disagree with Adam's opinions on sports matters ... but on this one, he's got it exactly right.

  • Steven Aug 28, 4:48 p.m.

    I think he should be in for his on the field accomplishments. At least he didn't use performance enhancing drugs.

  • Doc Holliday Aug 27, 8:26 p.m.

    At some point do we not have to stop, back off, look at the situation, and ask: What is the... View More

    — Posted by Objective Scientist

    If it's been proven that a player cheated, gambled, etc., & they clearly have the goods on him, it is what it is. Hate it for Rose...great player.

    Loved the way Pete Rose played the game. The gambling thing aside, he did play the game the right way & I can appreciate that. Rules are rules.

    Not sold on Joe Jackson being banned due to his WS numbers and the corruption in Chicago.

  • Objective Scientist Aug 27, 7:41 p.m.

    At some point do we not have to stop, back off, look at the situation, and ask: What is the right thing to do? In this case, what is best "for the game"... not individual players? Is it possible that players previously admitted to the HOF.... should not have been admitted, that if we throw one "bad apple" into the basket early in the process... then we must continue to throw every subsequent bad apple into the basket? I think not! At some point the basket will contain a sufficiently high number of bad apples that NO ONE will buy the basket! Not one of the current batch of "cheaters" should be allowed in the HOF. That would be the proverbial "slap in the face" to the players who have worked hard and "played the game right". I do agree that if some of the "cheaters" currently involved with the game are "allowed" to do that... it raises the question "Why not Rose?" I agree the question is legitimate... but I am NOT advocating that Rose be allowed "back in the game" or the HOF!

  • ACC EXPERT Aug 27, 8:50 a.m.

    Pete can be pompous a-- a jirk, just plain ole dum dip stick but he does belong in HOF- how many low lifes are already in- it is a honor for what you done on the field not man of the year

  • rush Aug 27, 8:38 a.m.

    The writing, the grammer, sentence construction in this piece is such that I can't follow what... View More

    — Posted by InTheNo

    Were you expecting something different from Adam?

  • Doc Holliday Aug 26, 7:35 p.m.

    "That's why Kennesaw Mountain Landis' decision to ban the eight Chicago White Sox players involved in throwing the 1919 World Series -- to the Cincinnati Reds, strangely enough -- was fair and just."

    Joe Jackson...
    Led both teams in hitting (.375) & hits (12), had 30 chances in the field & did not commit an error while throwing out a runner at the plate, threw out 5 runners total during the Series, hit the only HR in the Series in one of the games they lost, & half his RBIs came in games they lost.

    The other seven players admitted later that he was never involved in their meetings & they mentioned him to give themselves credibility with the gamblers. Lastly, it was Chicago, a city full of corruption.

    Jackson hit .286 in their losses, still 23 points higher than the league average. Put it this way, if the others played like Shoeless Joe did, they sweep the Series. He got hosed in that deal. IMO

  • InTheNo Aug 26, 3:44 p.m.

    The writing, the grammer, sentence construction in this piece is such that I can't follow what Adam is trying to say. Instead of becoming the Joan Rivers of sports, writers should have learned how to write.

  • Knightwolf Aug 26, 3:40 p.m.

    Just ask Ray Fosse what he thinks of Pete......The ban must stay.

  • The Logan Zone

    Tomorrow at 11:30 am on WRAL-TV

  • NHL: Hurricanes at Colorado

    Tonight at 9:00 on 99.9 The Fan

  • CBB: Duke vs. Stanford

    Tonight at 9:30 on 620am

Scoreboard
Local
Final
NCCU 21
NCA 14
 
Final
DAVID 72
UNC 90
Final
ECU 34
TULA 6
 
9:00pm Tonight
COL
CAR
9:30pm Tonight
DUKE
STAN
2nd
ORL 39
MIA 42
 
2nd
IND 43
PHO 48
 
1st
NYK 21
PHI 8
 
1st
CLE 24
TOR 6
 
8:00pm Tonight
HOU
DAL
8:00pm Tonight
MIN
SAC
8:30pm Tonight
SAN
BRK
8:30pm Tonight
MIL
WAS
9:00pm Tonight
UTA
NOP
Final
UGA 55
CHSO 9
 
Final
UF 52
EKU 3
Final
OSU 42
IND 27
Final
OKLA 44
KU 7
 
Final
UAB 18
MARS 23
Final
NEB 24
MINN 28
 
Final
PURD 14
NW 38
 
Final
ILL 16
PSU 14
Final
MSU 45
RUTG 3
 
Final
UCF 53
SMU 7
 
Final
SCAR 37
SALABAMA 12
Final
WKENT 45
TXSANANTO 7
 
Final
WAKE 6
VT 3
 
Final
ODU 30
LATU 27
 
Final
ARST 52
WASU 31
 
Final
CMICH 20
WMICH 32
 
Final
COLST 58
NMU 20
Final
LALAF 16
APPST 35
 
Final
BST 45
EMICH 30
 
Final
HOU 38
TULSA 28
Final
UTAH 10
ARZ 42
 
Final
FSU 20
BC 17
 
Final
UNT 17
FIU 14
 
Final
CLEM 28
GASTATE 0
 
Final
ND 28
LOU 31
 
Final
MICH 16
MD 23
 
Final
ARK 30
MISS 0
 
Final
PITT 30
SYR 7
 
Final
ISU 31
TTU 34
 
Final
ECU 34
TULA 6
 
Final
IOWA 24
WISC 26
 
Final
MEM 31
SFLA 20
 
Final
CAL 17
STAN 38
 
Final
NMST 17
LAMON 30
 
Final
ALA 48
WCAR 14
 
Final
OREG 44
COL 10
 
2nd
MTST 7
FATL 17
 
2nd
UVA 3
MIAMI 7
 
2nd
AUB 0
SAMF 0
 
1st
TENN 0
MIZZ 7
 
1st
BAY 14
OKST 0
 
1st
MSST 6
VANDY 0
 
8:00pm Tonight
UCONN
CIN
8:00pm Tonight
UCLA
USC
10:15pm Tonight
WYO
BSU
10:30pm Tonight
NEV
FRES
10:30pm Tonight
WASH
ORST
11:00pm Tonight
HAW
UNLV
Final
PRIN 68
INCWORD 79
 
Final
UMASS 68
ND 81
Final
GEOR 80
RMU 66
 
Final
LAS 59
PETE 50
 
Final
VT 63
APP 65
 
Final
IUPUI 71
BST 69
 
Final
WMICH 91
DRAK 75
 
Final
RICH 80
HIGH 56
 
Final
MSST 71
UTST 63
 
Final
CAMP 48
COL 53
 
Final
DAVID 72
UNC 90
Final
NIOWA 66
UNF 49
 
Final
CSNO 79
SAMF 72
 
Final
YALE 61
MLOWELL 63
 
Final
NEV 50
CLEM 59
 
Final
PROV 80
FSU 54
 
Final
MARQ 89
NEOM 97
 
Final
DET 66
SALA 53
 
Final
TXSA 80
TXST 67
 
Final
CHIST 75
TRINCHRIS 52
 
Final
UMO 63
LIB 52
 
Final
BONA 59
CAN 53
 
Final
SAV 87
CLST 83
 
Final
NW 68
ELON 67
 
Final
RFLSH 57
MDES 53
 
Final
CARK 68
SEMIZ 74
 
Final
AFA 90
WSCO 60
 
Final
YOUNG 82
LONG 72
 
Final
MTST 66
SOUTH 48
 
Final
ARKLR 73
UMKC 68
 
Final
ABCHRIST 81
DUQ 102
 
Final
WEBER 58
LSU 72
 
Final
BUT 80
GHND 39
 
Final
CSFU 70
SJST 66
 
Final
WOFF 72
SD 68
 
Final
NORST 76
TXSOU 66
 
Final
COOK 42
TOWS 63
 
Final
SILL 46
YALE 53
 
Final
KNST 83
ALCOR 80
 
Final
MAN 78
BING 63
 
Final
JVST 88
MILES 71
 
Final
CSOU 79
WRST 86
 
Final
CITA 81
BOBJONES 50
 
2nd
INDST 73
BRO 63
 
Final
WYO 56
COL 33
 
Final
GSOUT 97
FCCOL 41
 
Final
CCAR 76
PIED 33
 
Half
LATU 34
AMER 23
 
1st
MAR 41
ARMY 41
 
Half
TENT 26
CHAT 43
 
Half
EKENT 58
CLERMONT 24
 
Half
SMU 43
EWASH 35
 
1st
NIAG 27
HART 25
 
Half
PENN 30
LAF 45
 
Half
UCSB 47
MASTERS 22
 
1st
BUCK 40
MNTER 36
 
Half
VMI 45
UNCW 46
 
Half
RIU 19
NEB 23
 
Half
NKENTUCKY 57
OHMWSTRN 17
 
Half
GTDNS 35
QUIN 26
 
Half
EMICH 30
UNCG 19
 
1st
ETST 53
UNCA 42
 
Half
TEMPL 27
UNLV 24
 
1st
STJOE 19
VERM 24
 
1st
MON 17
CCST 17
 
1st
KSU 24
ILLCH 15
 
1st
FAIR 28
SHSU 20
 
1st
LIP 13
TRANSYLVAN 16
 
1st
FUR 13
UCD 15
 
8:00pm Tonight
WKENT
BEL
8:00pm Tonight
NDST
HAMP
 
8:00pm Tonight
IND
LAM
 
8:00pm Tonight
TTU
MIZST
8:00pm Tonight
HOU
MRGST
 
8:00pm Tonight
NAVY
NE
8:00pm Tonight
ALAAM
OAKW
 
8:00pm Tonight
WILL
SELA
 
8:00pm Tonight
TULA
SONO
 
8:00pm Tonight
TXPA
A
 
8:00pm Tonight
RICE
WMARY
8:30pm Tonight
TXARL
HOUB
 
8:30pm Tonight
MINN
UMBC
 
9:00pm Tonight
UTEP
NMST
 
9:00pm Tonight
GONZ
STTHOM
9:00pm Tonight
SUTAH
WLVRN
 
9:30pm Tonight
PBY
MORE
9:30pm Tonight
DUKE
STAN
10:00pm Tonight
WISC
BSU
10:00pm Tonight
PORT
SIUE
Final
OTT 2
STL 3
 
1st Intermission
WAS 0
BUF 0
 
1st Intermission
PHI 2
CLB 1
 
1st Intermission
TOR 1
DET 0
 
1st Intermission
TAM 0
MIN 0
 
1st Intermission
BOS 0
MON 1
 
1st Intermission
NYI 0
PIT 1
 
8:00pm Tonight
NAS
FLA
8:00pm Tonight
DAL
LOS
9:00pm Tonight
COL
CAR
10:00pm Tonight
EDM
CHI
10:00pm Tonight
CAL
NJD
10:30pm Tonight
SJS
ARI
Final
NCCU 21
NCA 14