Caulton Tudor

UNC-NCSU winner could reap in-state recruiting benefits

Posted November 1, 2013

The winner of Saturday’s UNC at N.C. State football (12:30 p.m. WRAL-TV) game could and certainly should get at least somewhat of an in-state recruiting spike.

But that said, is in-state recruiting as important as it was – say – during the days of Bill Dooley, Lou Holtz, Dick Crum, Dick Sheridan, Mack Brown and, of late, Tom O’Brien and Butch Davis?

Recruiting, like social media and perhaps because of it, in part, has changed a lot since the days when Dooley, in his first season as UNC’s coach in 1967, hired legendary Broughton High coach “Bulldog” Clyde Walker to piece together the first really sophisticated regional recruiting dragnet in ACC history.

That strategy worked so well for Dooley that the Tar Heels, in less than four years, became one of the can’t-miss weekly stops for NFL scouts.

Some 40 years later, Davis and assistant John Blake recruited a bevy of future pro picks. Davis also flunked the annual test against the Wolfpack and wound up throwing Carolina’s image out the window.

But that said, now let’s look at Oregon, No. 2 in the nation and one of the most incredible success stories college football has seen in ages.

The Ducks have only 24 players from Oregon, compared to 48 from California, eight from Texas, a few from British Columbia and others from map darting, including one or two from ACC territory.

The team’s best player, Heisman Trophy quarterback candidate Marcus Mariota, is from Honolulu (St. Louis High), as is center Mana Greig. The Ducks top ground gainer is Byron Marshall, from San Jose, Calif.

In fact, Oregon has only two current starters from in-state high schools – wide-out Keanon Lowe (Portland Jesuit) and defensive end Taylor Hart (Tualatin).

The top two Duck receivers – Josh Huff (5-11, 202) and Braion Addison (5-9, 180) – are both from Texas and hardly broke hearts from border to border when they didn’t pick Texas, Texas A&M, etc.

Keep in mind that these players are jumping over each other to get to Eugene, Ore., which is not exactly south Florida, Los Angeles or Baton Rouge.

And until Nike started designing Halloween costumes for the Ducks to wear during the games, there’s no program identity to match Notre Dame, Penn State, Ohio State or Alabama.

Which, of course, brings us to Alabama, No. 1 in the country and chasing a third straight national title.

The Tide has 31 in-state players, including quarterback A.J. McCarron (Mobile) and standout linebacker C.J. Mosley (Mobile). But 19 Bama players are from neighboring Georgia, one of whom is starting running back Ken Drake.

On the recruiting front, the Tide has depended as much on its reputation as a Dixie factory giant as whipping Auburn and it’s hardly as though Bama has a lucrative pipeline out of talent-rich Florida. Only nine players on the roster played prep ball in Florida, which is roughly the same number as Louisiana products on Bama’s roster.

Although rosters are constantly being updated and revised, both State and Carolina began the season with at least 55 in-state players listed – totals that are high in both cases for a state with five FBS (Division I-A) teams and a bevy of state-supported schools in the FCS (Division I-AA) pool.

The glaring conclusion is that neither State nor UNC is having much trouble bringing in homegrown players.
It’s just that too many of the most talented North Carolinians are still more interested in going outside the state than staying home.

Given the national recruiting trends, maybe the winner in Carter-Finley Stadium on Saturday afternoon should immediately dispatch an assistant to recruit the Island of O’ahu.


Please with your account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • ttaylor58 Nov 3, 2013

    View quoted thread

    Dook gets nothing but scraps.

  • StunGunn Nov 2, 2013

    View quoted thread

    Totally agree - I don't mind the ACC being a basketball conference either!

  • uncsuckz Nov 1, 2013

    View quoted thread

    Keep waiting for that trend to do a 180, but it's more of the aame this year except for Elijah Hood out of Charlotte. I suppose we'll always be a bball conference....and that's not too bad!

  • El Hans Nov 1, 2013

    They'll both continue to stink no matter who wins or loses.

  • Wheelman Nov 1, 2013

    View quoted thread

    However, only the SEC has more active players in the NFL than the ACC and both NCSU and UNC have contributed well to that number.

  • heelsforever Nov 1, 2013

    You mean of course except for the tp 5 or so players in the state who will no doubt go to one of the football powerhouses.

  • StunGunn Nov 1, 2013

    View quoted thread

    I agree. I think the four and five star recruits find the SEC more attractive - they have the facilities, coaches, fans, etc. all over the ACC.

  • jmcdow2792 Nov 1, 2013

    Every year it is said this game is big for in State recruiting. If that were the case, all the in State talent would be at NC State with only some freshmen at UNC. I think this idea is overblown.

  • 75Tarheel Nov 1, 2013

    View quoted thread

    Tudor isn't talking about NJ..

  • 75Tarheel Nov 1, 2013

    View quoted thread

    That's what makes them exceptionally intelligent and intuitive.

    See you Saturday....GO HEELS!!




  • ACC Basketball: Miami at Wake Forest

    Wednesday at 8:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CBB: UNC at Boston College

    Saturday at 12:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CBB: NC State vs. Wake Forest

    Saturday at 2:00 pm on WRAL-TV

NFL Scoreboard
Sunday, Jan. 22
Green Bay 12:05 PT1:05 MT2:05 CT3:05 ET20:05 GMT4:05 北京时间1:05 MST3:05 EST2:05 CT0:05 UAE (+1)15:05 ETNaN:�
Pittsburgh 3:40 PT4:40 MT5:40 CT6:40 ET23:40 GMT7:40 北京时间4:40 MST6:40 EST5:40 CT3:40 UAE (+1)18:40 ETNaN:�
New England 
CME Tour Champ (LPGA)
1C. Hull-19F
2S. Ryu-17F
3J. Song-15F
4tM. Martin-14F
4tB. Recari-14F
4tA. Jutanugarn-14F
7I. Chun-13F
8tS. Feng-12F
8tA. Yang-12F
10tL. Ko-11F
View Full Leaderboard
SA Open (EURO)
1G. Storm - z-18F
2R. McIlroy - y-18F
3J. Smith-17F
4D. Burmester-15F
5tT. Aiken-14F
5tT. Fisher, Jr.-14F
7tA. Bjork-13F
7tD. Drysdale-13F
7tM. Korhonen-13F
7tE. Molinari-13F
View Full Leaderboard
z = Won in Playoff   y = Lost in Playoff
ATP Scoreboard
Sunday, Jan. 15
Australian Open (ATP/WTA)
First Round
V. Estrella B79 7 0 6  
A. Bedene67 5 6 3  
N. Almagro0     
J. Chardy4     
(29) V. Troicki6 6 2 2 6 
D. Dzumhur4 4 6 6 3 
(5) K. Nishikori5 6 6 66 6 
A. Kuznetsov7 1 4 78 2 
R. Harrison6 6 6   
N. Mahut3 4 2   
A. De Minaur5 6 2 77 6 
G. Melzer7 3 6 62 1 
(27) B. Tomic6 6 6   
T. Bellucci2 1 4   
(31) S. Querrey610 77 6 6  
Q. Halys712 64 3 4  
(19) J. Isner6 6 65 6  
K. Kravchuk3 4 77 1  
A. Rublev4 6 77 6  
Y. Lu6 3 60 3  
(10) T. Berdych6 0    
L. Vanni1 0    
G. Garcia-Lop3 65 4   
M. Zverev6 77 6   
(7) M. Cilic4 4 6 6 6 
J. Janowicz6 6 2 2 3 
(26) A. Ramos-Vino6 5 6 4 3 
L. Lacko4 7 1 6 6 
J. Duckworth4 64 77 4  
P. Lorenzi6 77 64 6  
(1) A. Murray7 77 6   
I. Marchenko5 65 2   
(22) P. Cuevas3 3 0   
D. Schwartzma6 6 6   
M. Jaziri6 6 6   
G. Soeda3 4 3   
K. Khachanov6 3 711 6  
A. Mannarino4 6 69 3  
D. Lajovic6 6 6   
S. Robert3 3 3   
P. Mathieu4 64 77 5  
A. Seppi6 77 63 7  
WTA Scoreboard
Sunday, Jan. 15
Australian Open (ATP/WTA)
First Round
M. Barthel6 77    
D. Aiava3 64    
S. Crawford4 6 6   
L. Davis6 3 0   
(7) G. Muguruza7 6    
M. Erakovic5 4    
K. Siniakova6 3 4   
J. Goerges3 6 6   
(26) L. Siegemund1 6 4   
J. Jankovic6 1 6   
(19) K. Bertens5 65    
V. Lepchenko7 77    
(4) S. Halep3 1    
S. Rogers6 6    
(27) I. Begu5 6 6   
Y. Shvedova7 3 4   
Y. Duan6 6    
R. Sramkova3 4    
(29) M. Puig6 6    
P. Tig0 1    
A. Barty6 7    
A. Beck4 5    
A. Riske7 6    
M. Brengle5 3    
P. Parmentier7 7    
M. Doi5 5    
A. Tatishvili4 3    
J. Fourlis6 6    
K. Pliskova6 2 6   
V. Golubic3 6 4   
(32) A. Sevastova6 0    
N. Hibino4 0    
(13) V. Williams77 7    
K. Kozlova65 5    
K. Kucova6 6    
C. McHale4 0    
V. King3 2    
N. Vikhlyants6 6    
(20) S. Zhang6 6    
A. Sasnovich0 3    
F. Schiavone2 4    
J. Boserup6 6    
I. Khromachev2 1    
S. Cirstea6 6    
(8) S. Kuznetsova6 6    
M. Duque-Mari0 1    
(24) A. Pavlyuchen6 77    
E. Rodina1 62    
(15) R. Vinci1 63    
C. Vandeweghe6 77    
K. Nara6 2 3   
S. Voegele2 6 6   
(11) E. Svitolina6 6    
G. Voskoboeva0 2