banner
North Carolina

UNC's Ramsay: NCAA doesn't protect student-athletes

Posted July 9
Updated July 10

Devon Ramsay moves up field during the UNC vs. Florida State football game, Thursday, October 22, 2009 at Kenan Stadium in Chapel Hill.

Photo by Todd Melet

In a hearing Wednesday of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation, former University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill football player Devon Ramsay detailed the experience that saw him lose then regain eligibility under suspicion of academic fraud. 

Ramsay was one of 14 UNC players held out of games during the 2010 season as the NCAA investigated the football program. He was ruled ineligible in November 2010 before being reinstated in February 2011. In its ruling reinstating Ramsay, the NCAA said he did not violate any rules.

"The NCAA as an institution no longer protects the student athlete," Ramsay said after a detailed account of his navigation, with little support, of the NCAA violation procedure. 

Eventually, former North Carolina Supreme Court Justice Robert Orr took on Ramsay's case and helped him get reinstated. "It terrifies me," Ramsay said of student-athletes who lacked similar support.

In his introductory remarks, committee Chairman Sen. Jay Rockefeller, D-WV, questioned the NCAA's commitment to amateurism, saying, "There is a growing perception that college athletics, particularly Division 1 football and basketball, are not an avocation at all ... It's about capturing the billions of dollars that these sports generate."

Ramsay was one of two former student-athletes on the panel, and he told senators that a key regret of his college career had been the inability to do an internship which would help him prepare for a post-football career.

"At a competitive football school, completing an internship is almost impossible," he said.

Guests at the hearing were NCAA President Mark Emmert, Richard Southall, associate professor of the Department of Sport and Entertainment and director of the University of South Carolina's College Sport Research Institute, author and historian Taylor Branch, Myron Laurent Rolle, a student at Florida State University College of Medicine, Rhodes Scholar and former FSU football player and William Bradshaw, former director of athletics at Temple University.

Southall agreed with Ramsay's take on the time constraints on college athletes, noting that advisers often steer athletes to courses and majors that balance with the need for travel, workouts and practices. "Athletes are physically and socially isolated from the institution," he said.

After each man gave a brief statement about his athletic history and experience with the NCAA, Rockefeller and the others on the committee honed in on Emmert.  

"I am just very skeptical that the NCAA can ever live up to the lofty mission that you talk about," Rockefeller told Emmert. "My cynical self says universities like things the way they are because they are making a ton of money."

Emmert outlined changes he wants to see in how student-athletes are treated, but conceded that his role as president wields no real power.

"The NCAA is a democratically-governed, membership-led organization," he said before listing six key reforms that the NCAA board is pushing. They are:

  • Offering a "scholarship for life," so that student-athletes can complete a bachelor's degree even after their eligibility runs out.
  • Offering scholarships to cover what Emmert described as the "full and actual cost of attendance, not simply tuition, room and board, books and supplies."
  • Leadership in the realm of health and safety.
  • Closing gaps in health insurance and injury coverage for student-athletes.
  • Sex assault prevention and support for victims.
  • Provide time and resources for athletes to take advantage of all opportunities on college campuses

Emmert concluded, saying that any changes must not come at cost to female athletes supported by Title IX and student-athletes in non-revenue sports.

The harshest criticism of the status quo came from Branch, who likened the NCAA and big-time college programs to "a distorted cartel."

"The NCAA and schools strip rights from athletes uniquely as a class. No freedom should be abridged because of athletic status," he said.

Emmert expressed confidence that changes he proposed would be widely adopted. He noted a recent rule change that allows universities to offer multi-year scholarships.

"College sports should be appropriately self-governed," Emmert said. "We're going to see whether that system works. I have confidence. This hearing is a useful cattle prod."

Rockefeller emphasized that questions about big-time college sports are not going away. "We have jurisdiction over sports, all sports," he said. "We have ability to subpoena. We're very into this subject."

66 Comments

This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • JDT0827 Jul 11, 3:21 p.m.

    Not surprising that NCSU dolts focus on nothing this article illustrates, which we all know to be true, that the NCAA is more or less a worthless organization (unless revenue maximization really is supposed to be their primary focus) that certainly isn't there to protect student athletes. Wonder what the N&O will do when this investigation is over at UNC? Probably go back to trying to cover something positive about NCSU athletics from time to time, which is like picking peanuts out of poo historically.

  • modukev5saysbyebye Jul 10, 11:07 p.m.

    The NCAA is an embarrassment to all of humanity.

    — Posted by Winchester-.308

    It wasn't the NCAA that was promulgating those embarrassing no-show classes. Unc did it all by it's lonesome.

  • Winchester-.308 Jul 10, 11:00 p.m.

    The NCAA is an embarrassment to all of humanity.

  • vply2000 Jul 10, 10:04 p.m.

    Read Tarnished Heels and Weep.

  • vply2000 Jul 10, 8:42 p.m.

    "Of course WRalunc fails to mention this comment by Ramsay," UNC was more concerned in avoiding ncaa penalties and fines than helping me." greg barnes also says McCants didn't back up his accusations but in fact he did. He provided his transcript. Why would he want to talk to UNC after all they've done to run his name through the mud?
    Read more at http://www.wralsportsfan.com/unc-encouraging-everybody-to-talk/13801394/#MXmjXlibGDXFfuT0.99"

  • NothingButNet Jul 10, 7:30 p.m.

    Anyone that can read on an elementary school level can surely see that UNC-CH allows poor... View More

    — Posted by vt94hokies

    Hokie, not everyone comes here to brag about their education, nor do they care if others know... View More

    — Posted by Hammerhead

    Hammer, I haven't seen anyone here brag - or lie - about their education. The irony of all this... View More

    — Posted by NothingButNet

    Have you listened to any of ol' Roy's press conferences? Just askin'

    — Posted by modukev5saysbyebye

    Mo - I know you enjoy "sticking it" to Carolina - and Roy - but c'mon. Roy's worst goofs are more intelligent than anything that comes out of McCants' mouth. Roy may have hoof and mouth disease from time to time, but McCants doesn't have much of a brain.

  • ALLIN Jul 10, 5:24 p.m.

    NCAA doesn't protect student-athletes. You are over 18 and therefore an adult. If you need an apron string to hang on to stay with your momma. You poor kids and this pathetic generation of IT IS SOMEONE ELSES FAULT. This world will never survive or at least my way of life is doomed if I have to depend on the youth of today to sustain a free America.

  • modukev5saysbyebye Jul 10, 5:24 p.m.

    Hokie, not everyone comes here to brag about their education, nor do they care if others know... View More

    — Posted by Hammerhead

    Hammer, I haven't seen anyone here brag - or lie - about their education. The irony of all this... View More

    — Posted by NothingButNet

    Have you listened to any of ol' Roy's press conferences? Just askin'

    — Posted by modukev5saysbyebye

    Are we also going to hold it against Special Kay for saying "you know" over and over in his... View More

    — Posted by heelsforever

    I don't think you want to get into an IQ comparison contest between coach K and ol' huck.

    Might better stick with the McCants comparison. At least there huck has a fighting chance, anyway.

  • heelsforever Jul 10, 5:09 p.m.

    Anyone that can read on an elementary school level can surely see that UNC-CH allows poor... View More

    — Posted by vt94hokies

    Hokie, not everyone comes here to brag about their education, nor do they care if others know... View More

    — Posted by Hammerhead

    Hammer, I haven't seen anyone here brag - or lie - about their education. The irony of all this... View More

    — Posted by NothingButNet

    Have you listened to any of ol' Roy's press conferences? Just askin'

    — Posted by modukev5saysbyebye

    Are we also going to hold it against Special Kay for saying "you know" over and over in his press conferences?

  • Hammerhead Jul 10, 2:45 p.m.

    The biggest crock of all is the idea that the NCAA (or universities) aren't protecting... View More

    — Posted by cjw6105

    But the University is making money off of them. Just like the employer of every other working stiff.

More...

 

 

  • The Logan Zone

    Today at 11:30 am on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Washington at Philadelphia

    Today at 1:00 pm on FOX50

  • NFL: Oakland at New England

    Today at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Denver at Seattle

    Today at 4:25 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: Green Bay at Detroit

    Today at 1:00 pm on 620am

  • NHL: Hurricanes vs. Columbus

    Today at 1:30 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • NFL: Kansas City at Baltimore

    Today at 4:30 pm on 620am

  • NFL: Panthers vs. Pittsburgh

    Tonight at 8:30 on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
Local
Final
DUKE 47
TULA 13
Final
ECU 70
UNC 41
Final
TOWSN 31
NCCU 20
 
Final
NCSU 42
PRES 0
 
1:30pm Today
CAR
CLB
 
8:30pm Tonight
CAR
PIT
Final
KAN 2
DET 3
Final
CHC 8
LOS 7
Final
OAK 0
PHI 3
Final
NYY 3
TOR 6
Final
COL 5
ARI 1
Final
BAL 7
BOS 2
Final
PIT 0
MIL 1
Final
TAM 3
CWS 1
Final
MIN 3
CLE 7
Final
ATL 2
NYM 4
Final
HOU 10
SEA 1
Final
MIA 2
WAS 3
Final
STL 8
CIN 4
Final
SDP 3
SFG 2
Final
ANA 8
TEX 5
1:05pm Today
NYY
TOR
 
1:10pm Today
MIA
WAS
 
1:35pm Today
BAL
BOS
 
1:35pm Today
PIT
MIL
 
1:35pm Today
ATL
NYM
 
1:40pm Today
TAM
CWS
 
2:10pm Today
MIN
CLE
 
2:10pm Today
KAN
DET
 
2:10pm Today
HOU
SEA
 
2:20pm Today
CHC
LOS
 
3:35pm Today
ANA
TEX
 
4:05pm Today
OAK
PHI
 
4:10pm Today
COL
ARI
 
4:10pm Today
SDP
SFG
 
8:05pm Tonight
STL
CIN
 
Final
WISC 68
BGU 17
Final
MSU 73
EMICH 14
Final
VT 24
GT 27
Final
PITT 20
IOWA 24
Final
RICE 42
ODU 45
Final
UGA 66
TROY 0
Final
SYR 20
MD 34
Final
DUKE 47
TULA 13
Final
COL 21
HAW 12
Final
AKR 17
MARS 48
Final
WAKE 24
ARMY 21
Final
KU 24
CMICH 10
Final
ALA 42
UF 21
Final
FIU 3
LOU 34
Final
ECU 70
UNC 41
Final
NAVY 24
RUTG 31
Final
SMU 6
TEXAM 58
Final
MICH 10
UTAH 26
Final
BYU 41
UVA 33
Final
WYO 20
FATL 19
Final
MIZZ 27
IND 31
Final
PSU 48
UMASS 7
Final
MINN 24
SJST 7
Final
ILL 42
TXST 35
Final
WASH 45
GASTATE 14
Final
SMISS 21
APPST 20
Final
TOL 34
BST 23
Final
OHIO 36
IDAHO 24
Final
CIN 31
UMO 24
Final
MEM 36
MTST 17
Final
LSU 29
MSST 34
Final
ARK 52
NILL 14
Final
ARKST 21
UTST 14
Final
SALABAMA 6
GASO 28
Final
WVU 33
OKLA 45
Final
VANDY 34
SCAR 48
Final
NEB 41
MIAMI 31
Final
NMST 35
NMU 38
Final
HOU 47
UNLV 14
Final
FSU 23
CLEM 17
Final
ARZ 49
CAL 45
Final
ORST 28
SDST 7
Final
WASU 31
OREG 38
Final
BSU 34
LALAF 9
1:30pm Today
CAR
CLB
 
5:00pm Tonight
WAS
BUF
 
6:30pm Tonight
CLB
STL
 
8:00pm Tonight
EDM
CAL
 
8:00pm Tonight
CAL
EDM
 
1:00pm Today
CLE
BAL
1:00pm Today
STL
DAL
1:00pm Today
DET
GBP
1:00pm Today
NYG
HOU
1:00pm Today
JAC
IND
1:00pm Today
NOS
MIN
1:00pm Today
NEP
OAK
1:00pm Today
BUF
SDC
1:00pm Today
CIN
TEN
1:00pm Today
PHI
WAS
4:05pm Today
ARI
SFX
4:25pm Today
SEA
DEN
4:25pm Today
MIA
KAN
8:30pm Tonight
CAR
PIT
Final
TOWSN 31
NCCU 20
 
Final
NCSU 42
PRES 0