North Carolina

Judge: UNC must release more on NCAA probe

Posted September 26, 2012

— Information the University of North Carolina gathered for the NCAA about football players who got money, jewelry and other benefits is public record and should be released, according to an order from Superior Court Judge Howard E. Manning.

Wednesday's ruling is the latest in a series of back-and-forth as WRAL News and other media outlets seek detail in the investigation that led to 14 Tar Heel players sitting out some or all of the 2010 college football season. UNC Academics Investigation Archive: UNC investigations

The university mounted parallel investigations into academic and athletic violations within the football program in July 2010. Since that time, the director of athletics, head football coach and a key assistant have been replaced, and UNC has asked former governor Jim Martin to lead an investigation into academic improprieties university-wide. Just last week, Chancellor Holden Thorp announced his plan to resign in June.

At the heart of Wednesday's ruling are the "Statements of Fact" that UNC sent to the NCAA about each player. Manning ruled that, while information about a player's academic performance would remain sealed, facts about impermissible benefits that led to a player's being ruled ineligible should be released.

Manning wrote, "UNC is to produce in its original form each Statement of Facts related to any football player involved in the NCAA investigation at issue that is based on allegations of impermissible benefits (non-academic issues) received by the football player and which resulted in a decision by the NCAA to declare the student athlete ineligible to play intercollegiate football at UNC as a result." 

The media coalition had sued for access to all documents related to UNC's investigation into possible misconduct by football players, coaches, academic tutors, sports agents and/or boosters. In resisting release of those documents, UNC broke the request into subsets, and Manning's ruling addressed those issues individually.

His key ruling was that UNC release Statements of Facts and any Reinstatement Request the university made to the NCAA on behalf of players, if those players' violations were not academic-related and resulted in their being ineligible to play. A Reinstatement Request includes personal information of student-athletes and is not anonymized. Any request made by UNC on the basis of impermissible benefits, which would detail the type of illegal benefits particular players received, must be made public.

WRAL and its partners also asked for unredacted copies of UNC's entire response to the NCAA allegations, which the university prepared in September 2011. It was this response that UNC used to propose the Tar Heels vacate all wins in 2008 and 2009, pay a $50,000 fine, lose nine scholarships over three years and serve a two-year probation period. In March, the NCAA responded with a punishment that included the loss of 15 scholarships over three years, a one-year postseason ban and three years on probation.

"The issues surrounding this behemoth of a document present the Court with a Gordian knot," Manning wrote. "The Court will deal with this as Alexander did with the Gordian knot itself – slice it."

UNC will be allowed to redact information related to academic or personnel issues, but must release anything related to "student-athlete impermissible benefits violations resulting in
sanctions and ineligibility."

Manning allowed UNC to keep under wraps certain communication between the university and legal representatives, including bills and recordings. Furthermore, Manning ruled that former coach Butch Davis has released all records the court required of him.

The records must be released within 30 days. UNC has the right to appeal the ruling. 



142 Comments

Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • alyewy Oct 4, 2012

    I hope I didn't break any rules. Too tired to go to jail.
    Arnold.Rocky Mount NC.

  • alyewy Oct 4, 2012

    I think it's time to move on abount UNC problems.Let start talking about NCS.Duke& Wake Forest. I'm sure they ar not peaches and cream. Seems like the News and Observer and WRAL is getting a kick out of it.On&on&on. Wake up reporters, you know their is more out their. I'm eighty and these things have been going on for a long time. Get real. I guess these schools are clean. Move on please.
    Arnold from Rocky Mount N.C.

  • TsKaMF Sep 28, 2012

    It's STiiiiLL not over.

  • 1969inyourface Sep 27, 2012

    Old, tired, and dead news. Stale and uncovered by the National media. A big waste of taxpayer money (YOU AND ME). All to get ratings with the hidden agenda that no one sees. The KnowBama way. Thatnks WRAL!

    Funny how I couldnt submit NO bama! Typical censorship

  • Dr. Feelgood Sep 27, 2012

    View quoted thread


    I like the name. Now to your point, beating a dead horse is a distance learning masters degree at NCSU. They give quite a few of those degrees out. The PhDs that administer the program are also the same ones that start the insanely funny stuff on Crack Pride.

  • gsms69 Sep 27, 2012

    Release those records now.

  • tlesley4ncsu Sep 27, 2012

    Isn't this just good journalism and isn't that what they teach at UNC? Alot of folks wished Woodward and Bernstein would have given up on Watergate investigations too.

  • Coach Doherty Sep 27, 2012

    Ding Dang the witch is dead! The word is not allowed.

  • shakennotstirred Sep 27, 2012

    Lots of unc fans blaming their mess on state and the media. hmmmm, I dont think either of those started this mess, nor tried to cover it up for 2 years. How can you side with denying the public public records? I agree that this dead horse has been beaten, buried, dug up and beaten some more. Just as soon as unc releases this and all other public information concerning the scandals, the sooner this will be over. Should have been done with this a year ago. I am sure with the release of this information, there will be little nuggets of info that will keep these posts going for another year or more. It's ridiculous, turn over all these records and end this soap opera...

  • Native NC gal Sep 27, 2012

    View quoted thread


    Read this a while back. Just stopped laughing long enough to post this.

    GO HEELS! Love Roy Williams!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

More...

 

 

  • NHL Playoffs: NY Islanders at Tampa Bay

    Today at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • 1st Look: Race to the Triple Crown

    Tonight at 7:30 on WRAL-TV

  • NHL Playoffs: Pittsburgh at Washington

    Tonight at 8:00 on WRAL-TV

  • NHL Playoffs: St. Louis at Dallas

    Tomorrow at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • MLB: San Francisco at NY Mets

    Today at 4:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • MiLB: Bulls at Louisville

    Tonight at 6:05 on Buzz Sports Radio

  • NASCAR at Talladega

    Tomorrow at 1:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • MLB: San Francisco at NY Mets

    Tomorrow at 8:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

NBA Scoreboard
Oklahoma City 5:30 PT6:30 MT7:30 CT8:30 ET0:30 GMT8:30 5:30 MST7:30 EST4:30 UAE (+1)02:3020:30 ET7:30 CT23:30
Preview
San Antonio 
 
NHL Scoreboard
NY Islanders 12:00 PT1:00 MT2:00 CT3:00 ET19:00 GMT3:00 北京时间12:00 MST2:00 EST23:00 UAE15:00 ET4:00 BRT
Preview
Tampa Bay 
 
Pittsburgh 5:00 PT6:00 MT7:00 CT8:00 ET0:00 GMT8:00 北京时间5:00 MST7:00 EST4:00 UAE (+1)20:00 ET9:00 BRT
Preview
Washington 
 
MLB Scoreboard
Interleague
Cleveland 4:05 PT5:05 MT6:05 CT7:05 ET19:05 ET23:05 GMT7:05 4:05 MST6:05 EST6:35 VEN3:05 UAE (+1)6:05 CT
Preview
Philadelphia 
American League
Detroit3Top
3rd
Minnesota0
 
Houston01:05 PT2:05 MT3:05 CT4:05 ET16:05 ET20:05 GMT4:05 1:05 MST3:05 EST3:35 VEN0:05 UAE (+1)3:05 CT
Preview
Oakland0
 
Toronto 3:10 PT4:10 MT5:10 CT6:10 ET18:10 ET22:10 GMT6:10 3:10 MST5:10 EST5:40 VEN2:10 UAE (+1)5:10 CT
Preview
Tampa Bay 
 
Chi White Sox 4:05 PT5:05 MT6:05 CT7:05 ET19:05 ET23:05 GMT7:05 4:05 MST6:05 EST6:35 VEN3:05 UAE (+1)6:05 CT
Preview
Baltimore 
 
NY Yankees 4:10 PT5:10 MT6:10 CT7:10 ET19:10 ET23:10 GMT7:10 4:10 MST6:10 EST6:40 VEN3:10 UAE (+1)6:10 CT
Preview
Boston 
 
LA Angels 5:05 PT6:05 MT7:05 CT8:05 ET20:05 ET0:05 GMT8:05 5:05 MST7:05 EST7:35 VEN4:05 UAE (+1)7:05 CT
Preview
Texas 
 
Kansas City 7:10 PT8:10 MT9:10 CT10:10 ET22:10 ET2:10 GMT10:10 7:10 MST9:10 EST9:40 VEN6:10 UAE (+1)9:10 CT
Preview
Seattle 
National League
Washington4Bot
2nd
St. Louis0
 
Atlanta Postponed
Chi Cubs 
 
San Francisco01:05 PT2:05 MT3:05 CT4:05 ET16:05 ET20:05 GMT4:05 1:05 MST3:05 EST3:35 VEN0:05 UAE (+1)3:05 CT
Preview
NY Mets0
 
Cincinnati 4:05 PT5:05 MT6:05 CT7:05 ET19:05 ET23:05 GMT7:05 4:05 MST6:05 EST6:35 VEN3:05 UAE (+1)6:05 CT
Preview
Pittsburgh 
 
Miami 4:10 PT5:10 MT6:10 CT7:10 ET19:10 ET23:10 GMT7:10 4:10 MST6:10 EST6:40 VEN3:10 UAE (+1)6:10 CT
Preview
Milwaukee 
 
Colorado 5:10 PT6:10 MT7:10 CT8:10 ET20:10 ET0:10 GMT8:10 5:10 MST7:10 EST7:40 VEN4:10 UAE (+1)7:10 CT
Preview
Arizona 
 
San Diego 6:10 PT7:10 MT8:10 CT9:10 ET21:10 ET1:10 GMT9:10 6:10 MST8:10 EST8:40 VEN5:10 UAE (+1)8:10 CT
Preview
LA Dodgers 
 
ATP Scoreboard
Saturday, Apr. 30
Istanbul Open (ATP)
Semifinals
(2) G. Dimitrov77 77    
(3) I. Karlovic60 62    
(4) F. Delbonis77 3 2   
D. Schwartzma65 6 6   
 
(ATP)
Semifinals
(3) D. Thiem4 6 6   
(8) A. Zverev6 2 3   
(4) P. Kohlschrei6 6    
(5) F. Fognini1 4    
 
Estoril Open (ATP)
Semifinals
(3) B. Paire3 3    
(8) P. Carreno Bu6 6    
(2) N. Kyrgios3 5    
N. Almagro6 7    
 
WTA Scoreboard
Saturday, Apr. 30
Grand Prix de SAR (WTA)
Final
(1) T. Bacsinszky6 6    
M. Erakovic2 1    
 
(WTA)
Final
(2) L. Safarova3 6 6   
(4) S. Stosur6 1 4   
 
(ATP/WTA)
First Round
A. Beck3 4    
E. Makarova6 6    
(12) E. Svitolina4 6 6   
Y. Wickmayer6 3 4   
(15) S. Errani5 5    
C. Giorgi7 7    
A. Friedsam0 4    
C. McHale6 6    
A. Cornet2 5    
P. Badosa Gib6 2    
(16) S. Stephens 
T. Pereira