banner
North Carolina

Defining 'Lack of Institutional Control'

Posted October 12, 2010

Institutional control, or lack thereof, has been a term thrown around by fans and media like, leading to many flawed conversations concerning the NCAA investigation into North Carolina’s football program. Inside Carolina attempts to set the record straight through NCAA legislation.

While the “lack of institutional control” phrase has been tossed around haphazardly in recent months, it’s important to first distinguish the difference between LOIC and a failure to monitor.

LOIC centers on if there were adequate policies and procedures in place for an institution to comply with NCAA rules, and if those steps were being monitored and enforced by designated individuals at the time of a violation. A failure to monitor occurs when those policies and procedures are in place to comply with NCAA rules, but the institution failed to fully monitor specific areas of the program for limited periods of time.

In August ’05, the NCAA certified UNC as operating in substantial compliance with the relevant operating principles.
NCAA Constitution 2.8.1 states that institutions are “responsible for monitoring compliance, identifying and reporting violations, cooperating with the NCAA and taking corrective action,” as well as being responsible for coaches, players and boosters. The NCAA utilizes four pillars in building institutional control – compliance systems, monitoring/enforcement, rules education and a commitment to compliance.

NCAA documents indicate that failure to monitor has been “cited at a greater rate” than lack of control at the D-I level in recent years, “suggesting that institutions may be doing a better job of putting systems for control in place but need to enhance monitoring.”

The NCAA Committee on Infractions provides the following list as a roadmap for institutions to avoid a finding of a lack of institutional control:

* The NCAA rules applicable to each operation are readily available to those persons involved in that operation.
* Appropriate forms are provided to persons involved in specific operations to ensure that they will properly follow NCAA rules.
* A procedure is established for timely communication among various university offices regarding determinations that affect compliance with NCAA rules.
* Meaningful compliance education programs are provided for personnel engaged in athletically related operations.
* Informational and educational programs are established to inform athletics boosters of the limitations on their activities under NCAA rules and of the penalties that can arise if they are responsible for rule violations.
* Informational and educational programs are established for student-athletes regarding the rules that they must follow
* An internal monitoring system is in place to ensure compliance with NCAA rules.
* An external audit of athletics compliance is undertaken at reasonable intervals.
* The chief executive officer and other senior administrators make clear that they demand compliance with NCAA rules and that they will not tolerate those who deliberately violate the rules or do so through gross negligence.
* The institution and its staff members have a long history of self-detecting, self-reporting and self-investigating all potential violations.

The NCAA Committee on Infractions then emphasizes “that the presence of such measures are not a guarantee against such a finding. The way in which the measures are carried out and the attitude toward compliance within the institution are vital factors.”

“I’m going to fight the institutional control issues because of what we had in place and because of the way we’re handling it.”
North Carolina athletics director Dick Baddour told reporters on Monday that North Carolina has “a strong compliance program in place.”

“I think anybody who looks at that program would say that we were doing more than significant things to protect our institution and to protect individuals,” Baddour said. “Obviously, we need to do more and that’s what this review process is going to do for us, is to establish things that we can do better. And we’re absolutely committed to that.”

The facts back up those claims. In August ’05, the NCAA certified the university as operating in substantial compliance with the relevant operating principles, marking the third consecutive time that UNC has earned that distinction, dating back to ‘94’-95.

In the NCAA Committee on Infractions release entitled, “Principles of Institutional Control,” section B indicates that the “deliberate or inadvertent violation of a rule by an individual who is not in charge of compliance with rules that are violated will not be considered to be due to a lack of institutional control” if the aforementioned four pillars of control are met.

That definition would appear to be the reason behind Baddour’s strong belief in North Carolina compliance program.

“I think we’re in good stead,” Baddour said. “I’m going to fight the institutional control issues because of what we had in place and because of the way we’re handling it.”

And if UNC’s NCAA troubles were limited in scope, it would appear to be an open-and-shut case. But legitimate questions remain when factoring in a two-pronged investigation (agents/academics), 16 student-athletes named by UNC, and a former assistant head coach with ties to agent Gary Wichard.

"The head coach cannot be charged with the secretive activities of an assistant bent on violating NCAA rules.”
Baddour acknowledged on Monday that the NCAA would have to ask questions pertaining to the school’s institution control and that school officials needed to be prepared to answer those questions.

NCAA documents point to eight considerations when evaluating failure to monitor versus LOIC – duration/frequency of violations, visibility of violations, warning signs to institution, number of involved student-athletes/teams, number of involved staff members, significance of impermissible benefit, recruiting/competitive advantage gained and the distinction between self-reported or reported from outside source.

As for Butch Davis’s responsibility in determining LOIC, NCAA Bylaw 11.1.2.1 states that “head coaches have a responsibility to promote an atmosphere for compliance within the program and monitor the activities of assistants and staff who report directly or indirectly to the head coach.”

The document from the NCAA Committee on Infractions adds that not every violation by an assistant coach involves LOIC, stating: “If the head coach sets a proper tone of compliance and monitors the activities of all assistant coaches in the sport, the head coach cannot be charged with the secretive activities of an assistant bent on violating NCAA rules.”

Outside of the possibility that the UNC administration or coaching staff had prior knowledge of the violations, there would appear to be two areas that the institution could face intense scrutiny from the NCAA concerning LOIC.

First being that Robert Quinn and Marvin Austin were both projected as first-round draft picks in next April’s NFL Draft. Baddour admitted that the program should have done more to monitor its high-profile players.

“We should’ve been doing something else,” Baddour said. “We should’ve acknowledged the level that these guys are and that there were going to be people coming at them. … I wish we had done more. I’d like to relive that part.”

"High-profile players demand high-profile compliance."
Following the NCAA’s ruling on the USC football program in June, NCAA Committee on Infractions chairman Paul Dee told the L.A. Times: "The real issue here is, if you have high-profile players, your enforcement staff has to monitor those students at a higher level. High-profile players demand high-profile compliance."

Part of that ability falls into the second concern, which is that North Carolina’s official website lists four compliance officers for a 28-sport program. In contrast, Alabama’s official website lists eight compliance officers for its 18 athletic programs.

Florida International University was cited for lack of institutional control in 2008, and one of the four determinations in reaching that conclusion was “inadequate compliance staffing.”

In order to formulate a final ruling, the NCAA will continue to investigate all aspects of the UNC football program, from the student-athlete to the top administrators. That verdict could be as far as a year away, according to university officials, though Baddour noted on Monday that UNC is nearing the completion of the agent prong of the review.

11 Comments

This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • wolfbitesyourheels Oct 13, 8:34 p.m.

    Defining lack of institutional control is easy.
    It is spelled u n c f o o t b a l l.

  • TruthBKnown Banned Again02 Oct 13, 3:48 p.m.

    Systems in place huh? So who was watching the watchers?????

    — Posted by ncsu85

    Good question. I've heard that Butch set up his own compliance team for his football team, bypassing the school's compliance department. Has anyone else heard that? If this is true, then this is truly a case of the fox guarding the hen house.

  • GunnyGoesArrrgh Oct 13, 7:21 a.m.

    Although the rules of Institutional Control are clear, it does leave room for interpretation. Carolina may have had the rules in place, but they obviously weren't monitoring those rules. At the very least UNC will likely get slapped with the lack of monitoring, but considering the scope of infractions, LOIC may be the final verdict by the NCAA.

    What is really sad to me is that Baddour abnd Butch were trusted to do their jobs and neither man did. That level of trust will never be had again at Carolina.

  • mccpry2 Oct 12, 10:15 p.m.

    Even the guys on ESPN PTI show said on today's show that there is a lack of Institutional... View More

    — Posted by NCSU84

    Well shucks...since they said it, it must be true.

  • NCSU84 Oct 12, 8:57 p.m.

    Even the guys on ESPN PTI show said on today's show that there is a lack of Institutional Controls at Chapel Hill. Both also thought Davis is gone after the Duke game.

  • Hokies94 Oct 12, 8:34 p.m.

    The word institution means. A place of higher learning.. It is an established organization .....(as a college or university)...esp. of public character.

    Well. I guess Dick Baddour, Davis, Blake, Austin, Little, Quinn, and many others need to understand this one word. And simply; adhere to the word.

    In the end it will mean this one word. Intregrity.

  • ncsu85 Oct 12, 8:20 p.m.

    Systems in place huh? So who was watching the watchers?????

  • southraleigh Oct 12, 6:37 p.m.

    So we're to understand that UNC was in compliance with Institutional Control standards until they hired Butch Davis as the Football coach?

    How about defining 'Denial of Reality'?

  • redistrumps Oct 12, 6:36 p.m.

    I looked up "LACK OF INSTITUTIONAL CONTROL". I read the definition. At the end, it... View More

    — Posted by TruthBKnown Banned Again02

    Now that's funny TBK and I don't care who you are LOL

  • TruthBKnown Banned Again02 Oct 12, 6:35 p.m.

    I looked up "LACK OF INSTITUTIONAL CONTROL". I read the definition. At the end, it said, "See also North Carolina, University of".

    But seriously, here's a good article on the subject:

    http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2010/10/12/1757426/unc-must-find-way-to-regain-control.html

More...

 

 

  • ACC: NC State at UNC

    Today at 12:58 pm on WRAL-TV

  • SEC: Mississippi State at Ole Miss

    Today at 3:30 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NFL: San Diego at Baltimore

    Tomorrow at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • CFB: Michigan at Ohio State

    Today at 12:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • CFB: NC State at UNC

    Today at 12:30 pm on WRAL-FM

  • NHL: Hurricanes vs. Pittsburgh

    Tonight at 7:00 on 99.9 The Fan

  • CBB: NC State at Purdue

    Tuesday at 9:00 pm on WRAL-FM

Scoreboard
Local
Final
NCCU 65
EILL 40
Final
NCSU 60
BSU 54
Final
PIT 2
CAR 4
Final
CHA 101
GSW 106
Final
UF 64
UNC 75
Final
TULSA 32
ECU 49
 
12:30pm Today
UNC
NCSU
2:30pm Today
NARZ
NCCU
 
7:00pm Tonight
CAR
PIT
 
7:00pm Tonight
DUKE
WAKE
7:30pm Tonight
ATL
CHA
 
Final
BOS 102
CHI 109
Final
CHA 101
GSW 106
Final
TOR 102
DAL 106
Final
DET 88
MIL 104
 
Final
ATL 100
NOP 91
Final
HOU 85
LAC 102
Final
OKC 105
NYK 78
Final
IND 98
ORL 83
Final
SAN 112
SAC 104
Final
DEN 122
PHO 97
Final
POR 99
MEM 112
Final
LAL 119
MIN 120
 
7:00pm Tonight
PHI
DAL
 
7:00pm Tonight
WAS
NOP
 
7:30pm Tonight
ATL
CHA
 
7:30pm Tonight
CLE
IND
 
9:00pm Tonight
MIL
HOU
 
9:00pm Tonight
UTA
LAC
 
Final
WMICH 21
NILL 31
Final
SMU 9
HOU 35
Final
IOWA 34
NEB 37
Final
SFLA 0
UCF 16
Final
MARS 66
WKENT 67
Final
KSU 27
AKR 24
Final
BGU 24
BST 41
Final
UMASS 21
BUF 41
Final
EMICH 16
TOL 52
Final
MIZZ 21
ARK 14
Final
SALABAMA 40
NAVY 42
Final
ARZ 42
ARST 35
Final
AFA 27
COLST 24
Final
UCLA 10
STAN 31
Final
VT 24
UVA 20
 
Final
TULSA 32
ECU 49
 
12:00pm Today
TEMPL
CIN
12:00pm Today
UGA
GT
12:00pm Today
NW
ILL
12:00pm Today
LOU
KENT
12:00pm Today
OSU
MICH
12:00pm Today
TXSANANTO
UNT
12:00pm Today
FATL
ODU
12:00pm Today
IND
PURD
12:00pm Today
LATU
RICE
12:00pm Today
CLEM
SCAR
12:00pm Today
ISU
WVU
12:30pm Today
TROY
LALAF
12:30pm Today
UNC
NCSU
12:30pm Today
BC
SYR
1:00pm Today
COL
UTAH
2:00pm Today
APPST
IDAHO
2:00pm Today
GASTATE
TXST
3:00pm Today
ARKST
NMST
3:00pm Today
NMU
WYO
3:30pm Today
TTU
BAY
3:30pm Today
FSU
UF
3:30pm Today
PSU
MSU
3:30pm Today
WISC
MINN
3:30pm Today
MISS
MSST
3:30pm Today
USC
ND
3:30pm Today
MD
RUTG
3:30pm Today
SDST
SJST
3:30pm Today
SMISS
UAB
4:00pm Today
MEM
UCONN
4:00pm Today
KST
KU
4:00pm Today
VANDY
TENN
4:30pm Today
CAL
BYU
6:00pm Tonight
GASO
LAMON
7:00pm Tonight
FRES
HAW
7:00pm Tonight
UTEP
MTST
7:00pm Tonight
MIAMI
PITT
7:00pm Tonight
DUKE
WAKE
7:45pm Tonight
ALA
AUB
8:00pm Tonight
ORST
OREG
10:15pm Tonight
BSU
UTST
10:30pm Tonight
UNLV
NEV
10:30pm Tonight
WASU
WASH
Final
NCCU 65
EILL 40
Final
KU 82
TENN 67
Final
TEXAM 87
NO 65
 
Final
NCAT 57
RAD 65
 
Final
GEOR 58
BUT 64
Final
BRO 81
PVU 71
Final
RIU 66
SCU 44
Final
NARZ 70
SOUTH 63
Final
DART 68
MAST 67
Final
WRST 59
FIU 61
Final
XAV 73
UTEP 77
Final
OSU 73
JMU 56
Final
TXSOU 71
LAM 59
 
Final
TAMCC 75
MVSU 66
 
Final
AKAN 51
MIZST 55
Final
BUCK 80
PSU 88
 
Final
PROV 72
YALE 66
Final
UGA 62
MINN 66
Final
WISC 69
OKLA 56
Final
Terriers 70
NORST 72
 
Final
PEAY 62
STEPH 83
Final
FSU 58
CSOU 47
 
Final
VALPO 66
DRAK 46
Final
CIN 69
MTST 51
Final
SDU 75
PRIN 65
Final
WASU 76
RICE 74
Final
CSFU 64
USCU 79
Final
GT 61
RIDE 54
Final
TXPA 79
ALAST 91
Final
NCSU 60
BSU 54
Final
TCU 57
BRAD 49
Final
WAKE 65
DELST 72
 
Final
HART 83
EMERSON 50
 
Final
STJ 66
GONZ 73
Final
CLEM 62
HIGH 59
 
Final
SYR 72
HC 48
 
Final
MD 61
MON 56
Final
JVST 74
SAV 71
 
Final
MIAMI 87
SALA 75
Final
RUTG 68
VANDY 65
Final
PETE 66
TENST 58
Final
MARS 59
CLST 68
Final
JST 56
HOF 86
 
Final
INDST 62
MEM 72
Final
UF 64
UNC 75
Final
LATU 77
SAMF 64
Final
TULA 71
SELA 61
 
Final
NEB 75
TENNM 64
Final
MISS 75
CREI 68
Final
PORT 64
MURST 61
Final
MARQ 68
MSU 79
Final
ARK 89
UNT 73
Final
NCOL 82
STET 62
 
Final
IND 87
UNCG 79
Final
SJST 60
WMICH 79
Final
MNTST 104
TXARL 81
Final
UVA 64
LAS 56
Final
STLU 50
MSST 75
Final
COLST 75
PAC 64
Final
UTAH 90
NDAK 53
Final
ILL 62
BAY 54
 
Final
UAB 76
UCLA 88
2nd
WASH 62
LBSU 59
 
Half
UCSB 25
MERC 20
 
11:30am Today
NCAT
MVSU
 
12:00pm Today
KNST
CHAT
 
12:00pm Today
SOUTH
EILL
 
1:00pm Today
ND
CHIST
 
1:00pm Today
IUPUI
UGST
 
1:00pm Today
NAVY
RFLSH
 
1:00pm Today
UMBC
TOWS
 
1:00pm Today
CITA
WWLSN
 
2:00pm Today
GWEBB
BREV
 
2:00pm Today
BING
CORN
 
2:00pm Today
DAY
ILLCH
 
2:00pm Today
SFLA
JVU
 
2:00pm Today
MORE
KYCHR
 
2:00pm Today
HARV
UMASS
 
2:00pm Today
DAVID
UNCW
 
2:00pm Today
DUQ
YALE
 
2:00pm Today
NEOM
NEV
 
2:00pm Today
USB
STTHOM
 
2:00pm Today
NIAG
BONA
 
2:00pm Today
RAD
TAMCC
 
2:00pm Today
ODU
VCU
 
2:07pm Today
IOWA
LONG
 
2:30pm Today
NARZ
NCCU
 
2:30pm Today
GSOUT
SCST
 
3:00pm Today
NE
FAIR
 
3:00pm Today
OU
TOL
 
3:00pm Today
WICHS
TULSA
 
3:00pm Today
ILLST
YOUNG
 
3:30pm Today
CSFU
FIU
 
4:00pm Today
UCR
ABCHRIST
 
4:00pm Today
CLMB
AMER
 
4:00pm Today
ARKLR
CARK
 
4:00pm Today
UWMIL
CONCORDSP
 
4:00pm Today
SHU
GWU
 
4:00pm Today
HOW
GWYNEDD
 
4:00pm Today
FORD
MDES
 
4:00pm Today
GMAS
MAN
 
4:00pm Today
NWST
MOVAL
 
4:00pm Today
MICH
NICST
 
4:00pm Today
WAGN
PENN
 
4:00pm Today
AKAN
TBA
 
4:05pm Today
SILL
OLIV
 
4:15pm Today
CAN
BUF
 
4:30pm Today
PBY
BOBJONES
 
4:30pm Today
TBA
TBA
 
4:30pm Today
WMARY
WOFF
 
5:00pm Tonight
STET
FAM
 
5:30pm Tonight
SHSU
USW
 
6:00pm Tonight
CMICH
GRCN
 
6:00pm Tonight
DRAK
PORT
 
6:00pm Tonight
TBA
TBA
 
6:00pm Tonight
NDAK
TXPA
 
6:00pm Tonight
USCU
WRST
 
6:15pm Tonight
TBA
MIZST
 
6:30pm Tonight
UNLV
GTDNS
 
6:30pm Tonight
WYO
NMST
 
7:00pm Tonight
SEMIZ
ALAAM
 
7:00pm Tonight
OHIO
BEL
 
7:00pm Tonight
KSU
LOYC
 
7:00pm Tonight
GHND
SIENA
 
7:00pm Tonight
TBA
TBA
 
7:00pm Tonight
TBA
TBA
 
7:30pm Tonight
WVU
COC
 
8:00pm Tonight
HOUB
DCHR
 
8:00pm Tonight
LSU
MCNST
 
8:05pm Tonight
WILL
GVIL
 
8:05pm Tonight
UMKC
WMJEWELL
 
8:30pm Tonight
TBA
TBA
 
8:30pm Tonight
MURST
VALPO
 
9:00pm Tonight
UTAH
ALAST
 
9:00pm Tonight
ARST
COL
 
9:00pm Tonight
TBA
TBA
 
9:30pm Tonight
BYU
EKENT
 
9:30pm Tonight
TBA
TBA
 
10:00pm Tonight
SEAT
CSNO
 
10:00pm Tonight
GAELS
CPSL
 
10:00pm Tonight
IDAHO
NKENTUCKY
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCD
WLVRN
 
11:00pm Tonight
LMU
UCI
 
11:30pm Tonight
TBA
TBA
 
Final
PHI 0
NYR 3
Final
ANA 1
CHI 4
Final
WAS 5
NYI 2
Final
PIT 2
CAR 4
Final
NJD 4
DET 5
Final
BUF 2
MON 1
Final
CLB 0
VAN 5
Final
BOS 2
WIN 1
Final
FLA 3
OTT 2
Final
STL 4
EDM 3
Final
DAL 4
MIN 5
1:00pm Today
NYR
PHI
 
7:00pm Tonight
MON
BUF
 
7:00pm Tonight
NYI
NJD
 
7:00pm Tonight
TAM
OTT
 
7:00pm Tonight
CAR
PIT
 
7:00pm Tonight
TOR
WAS
 
8:00pm Tonight
NAS
CLB
 
8:00pm Tonight
MIN
STL
 
9:00pm Tonight
COL
DAL
 
10:00pm Tonight
ARI
CAL
 
10:00pm Tonight
LOS
CHI
 
10:30pm Tonight
SJS
ANA