Ken Medlin

Conferences, expand with caution

Posted September 4, 2011

The NCAA dodged a bullet in 2010, but history’s not likely to repeat itself this time.

Rumors abound concerning conference realignment scenarios. Just click on a sports-related website, and you’re likely to see a headline speculating on the next big move.

Texas A&M to the SEC... Oklahoma to the Pac-12... Texas to their own planet...

It does appear a major change in the collegiate athletics landscape is on the way, with the charge being led by the SEC and the Pac-12.

The conventional wisdom outside of this area is that any ACC school offered to join the SEC will jump. One story after another is hitting the web speculating one school after another breathlessly awaiting an SEC call.

In the past two weeks, I’ve seen Miami, FSU, Georgia Tech, Clemson, NC State, Carolina, Duke, Virginia, Virginia Tech and Maryland bantered about as potential SEC targets.

That’s everyone but Wake and BC... If that really the case, just merge the conferences to form a “Conference of the South,” and secede from the NCAA. The South really would rise again... in football.

But before anyone rushes to judgement and screams bloody murder because the ACC is not leading the expansion charge, consider the past.

The ACC’s move from nine to twelve teams has yielded mixed results, but at the time many of the same pundits currently drooling over 16-team superconferences were heralding the ACC as the new top conference in football.

In the words of one presidential hopeful, “How’s that working out for you?”

The ACC focused more on adding large markets, and less on large fan bases. The conference was enamored with Miami and Boston College because of their positions in major population centers.

But in adding the ‘Canes and Eagles, the ACC added two schools with microscopically-small alumni bases.

When Miami is rolling, fans will watch in droves. The ACC thought they were adding a powerhouse in Miami. But when “The U” is merely above average -- they don’t have the built-in fan base to sustain the interest.

The schools currently being kicked around in realignment talks – Texas A&M, Oklahoma and Missouri, for example – are all large schools with large fan bases. They’re relevant in good times, and in bad.

Only Virginia Tech fit that bill during the ACC’s expansion. The Hokies have been the best addition by far, even if it took Virginia’s legislature to get them into the ACC.

If the ACC does feel the need to expand – an option I’d only consider if the conference title game or BCS bid is in jeopardy – I’d look at Pitt and Syracuse first. Both bring large media markets and large fan bases, and they make sense in terms of geography. If you need a longer list, throw Rutgers in there. Notre Dame isn’t happening, and the ACC missed the boat on Penn State twenty years ago.

West Virginia makes sense in terms of its regional rivalries and large, passionate fan base. I’d love to see the Mountaineers in the ACC, but that’s not likely either. WVU’s academic profile just doesn’t hold up to ACC standards, and the school presidents/chancellors will turn up their noses.

In truth, I don’t think 16-team superconferences will be good for the game. All I see is a further dilution of the regional rivalries that are the very foundation of college football. Is anyone excited about an Oklahoma-Washington State game? How about Texas A&M-Kentucky? (I could also use Boston College-Clemson as an example)

As frustrating as it may be to watch the ACC wait out the current wave of expansion rumors, it may well be the best course of action – as long as the current 12 members stay put.
 

3 Comments

Please to add a comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • VT1994Hokie Sep 8, 2011

    I'm still hoping for Ken D to write his thoughts on this one.

  • VT1994Hokie Sep 5, 2011

    Miami, BC, and Wake don't bring much to the table with monies. But, you will never see Wake leave the ACC. No one wants them to join another conference; anyway. The reason is that people at Wake like the standards in academics; just like Duke.

    The ACC They will not lower it to make money like some of these sleazy SEC schools. A degree at Wake, UNC, Duke, VT, BC, NC State, and others means something. The alumni that give monies to build huge football stadiums, basketball arenas care about this. Oh. But there are some that want to win at all costs too. Keep a crooked coach with the chance to win a NC. This is what creates a double-edge sword.

    The elderly (huge donors) care more about academics than winning. With the monies being tight as they are today. We need to simply wait until some want to come crawling to the ACC.

  • VT1994Hokie Sep 5, 2011

    OK Ken Medlin. I kinda like this one. It makes sense to me. I know that this is all about huge monies starting with the SEC. And. Most of some other schools will be as greedy to get the multi-millions from TV revenues. I see it. Money and greed. Look at this from the big picture with all Professional sports, the NCAA, and all others.

    I especially liked what you stated about my school. VT has brought more to the ACC than anyone of late. Our fans bring it to away games. Our basketball team is on the rise too. We aren't greedy like some of the teams out there. We spend money in support of our school.

    Texas A&M did it for money. They will get kicked to the curb in a few years. I truly hope that they will fall on their azz. Fall on it really hard, and they can pick up the pieces and start all over again. They will not make it in the SEC.

    UNC, Duke, State, and WF will not leave the ACC. VT isn't going to leave either anytime soon. Once we win in basketball on the National scene we will be ready to go. MY opinion is that more teams will want to obtain status in the ACC. We have the best Conference in all of basketball in America. They can't change this.

    We wanted to be in the ACC for years, until the Governor did his real deal. No way we leave with winning in football like we have since we entered. I would venture to say that some schools will be attracted to the ACC after the dust has settled. The ACC is solid. Wait and see.

  • ACC: Syracuse at NC State

    Saturday at 12:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • SEC: Florida at Kentucky

    Saturday at 2:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • Pac 12: Stanford at Arizona

    Saturday at 4:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NHL: Hurricanes vs. Minnesota

    Tomorrow at 8:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
Local
Final
ECU 56
TEMPL 70
 
2nd
NCCU 64
NCAT 58
 
Final
DET 4
ATL 6
 
Final
TAM 2
BAL 3
 
Final
PIT 1
NYY 2
 
Final
HOU 6
PHI 3
 
Final
MIA 1
STL 4
 
Final
SFG 8
CHC 6
 
Final
CIN 3
CLE 9
 
Final
CWS 1
LOS 6
 
Final
ANA 3
MIL 2
 
Final
CHC 2
OAK 2
 
Final
SEA 9
SDP 4
 
Final
KAN 5
TEX 4
 
Final
ARI 4
COL 3
 
Final
WAS 5
NYM 4
 
6th
MIN 8
BOS 8
 
8th
BAL 5
TOR 0
 
3rd
CHI 57
OKC 56
 
10:30pm Tonight
POR
DAL
Final
MDES 89
MRGST 76
 
Final
SIENA 71
NIAG 54
Final
LEH 62
AMER 68
 
Final
SCAR 74
ARK 78
 
Final
LAF 89
BU 64
 
Final
PETE 63
FAIR 33
Final
BUCK 90
HC 83
 
Final
UNF 71
LIP 57
 
Final
TENNM 65
MORE 76
Final
COL 72
NAVY 62
 
Final
ECU 56
TEMPL 70
 
Final
FATL 62
UAB 59
 
Final
FLGC 62
USCU 63
 
Final
CHAR 84
WKENT 88
 
Final
MINN 63
WISC 76
Final
MIZST 48
SILL 55
 
Final
COPST 92
DELST 104
 
Final
FIU 59
MTST 54
 
2nd
HAMP 63
NORST 71
 
2nd
NCCU 64
NCAT 58
 
2nd
COOK 70
SCST 56
 
Final
APP 67
TXST 64
 
Final
GSOUT 76
TXARL 64
 
2nd
LAMON 39
UGST 33
 
2nd
ODU 60
MARS 46
 
2nd
TXSA 66
RICE 70
 
2nd
FAM 31
SAV 34
 
2nd
LATU 56
SMISS 45
 
Half
JST 42
ALAAM 28
 
1st
GRAM 17
ALAST 30
 
1st
TXSOU 38
ALCOR 27
 
2nd
NICST 40
CARK 24
 
2nd
TAMCC 46
HOUB 35
 
2nd
NARZ 28
PORST 31
 
1st
LAM 21
SHSU 27
 
2nd
ARKST 37
SALA 57
 
1st
PVU 20
SOUTH 17
 
Half
LALAF 32
ARKLR 27
 
1st
NO 34
SELA 31
 
1st
INCWORD 4
ABCHRIST 11
 
9:00pm Tonight
MVSU 0
ARKPB 0
 
1st
ARZ 29
CAL 16
 
Half
WASH 17
COL 30
 
1st
WEBER 33
IDAHO 25
 
1st
UCONN 17
MEM 24
 
1st
UTEP 38
UNT 22
 
1st
STEPH 39
NWST 25
 
1st
SUTAH 35
SACST 34
 
1st
DAVID 31
VCU 13
 
1st
IDST 26
EWASH 41
 
1st
QUIN 16
MAR 29
 
1st
BEL 25
EILL 9
 
1st
DRAK 3
BRAD 3
 
10:00pm Tonight
LBSU
CSNO
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCI
CSFU
 
10:00pm Tonight
UCD
UCR
 
11:00pm Tonight
ARST
STAN
11:00pm Tonight
WASU
UTAH
1st OT
BOS 3
CAL 3
 
Final
WAS 1
MIN 2
 
Final
PHI 3
STL 1
 
3rd
FLA 3
DAL 2
 
3rd
TAM 3
TOR 1
 
2nd Intermission
NAS 1
NYI 2
 
1st
ARI 0
VAN 0
 
10:30pm Tonight
LOS
MON