Ryan Craig

Favre not to blame for Vikes' loss

Posted January 25, 2010

I know a lot of people want to blame Minnesota’s 31-28 loss to New Orleans Sunday night on 40-year old number four, but the real number they should be focusing on is five.

Five times the Vikings put the ball on the carpet, or field turf as the case may be, Sunday night, a number that many would consider high for an entire month, much less a three-hour period.

If you’re Adrian Peterson, how can you be the best running back in football and fail to secure the ball on a regular basis?

Sure, the third-year back out of Oklahoma didn’t lose either of his two fumbles to the Saints, but the worries they caused had an effect on play calling, personnel choices, and team confidence.

You not only lose yards when you cough up the pigskin, you lose options.

Vikings head coach Brad Childress didn’t feel comfortable giving the ball to his franchise player at critical moments of the NFC Championship Game, so he was forced to employ Percy Harvin in the backfield – the same Harvin that was questionable to even make the trip to the Bayou because of migraine headaches, and a guy who was catching screen passes from Tim Tebow last season.

Sure enough, it took Harvin exactly two plays, and one lost fumble, as the feature back to prove why most teams don’t like to lean too hard on rookies deep in the playoffs.

But, I have no sympathy in this situation for Childress – after all, despite the epic case of fumble-itis his team developed Sunday night, it was his own mismanagement of team personnel late in the game that cost his side a chance to win.

There will be hundreds of replays of Brett Favre’s ill-advised across-the-body throw ending up in Tracy Porter’s hands and not Sidney Rice’s with less than 30 seconds left in Sunday's game.

And, there’s no hiding the fact the pass immediately ended any chances of Minnesota kicking a game-winning field goal in regulation, and eventually robbed Favre of an opportunity to add another piece of jewelry to an already Hall of Fame career.

But, a lot fewer people will recall what led to that fateful toss, and that’s what takes me back to the number five - the number of yards a team is penalized for having “too many men in the huddle.”

Staring at a 3rd and 10 from the New Orleans 33-yard line, Minnesota was called for having 12 players in its huddle – just after spending a timeout.

That’s like a basketball coach calling a T.O. and then sending six players back on the court only to get nailed with a technical foul.

Apparently, Childress was trying to trick the Saints by starting with additional personnel on the field, but is that really the time to get cute?

Sure enough, the five yards Minnesota lost because of the infraction moved their possible field goal attempt from a distance of 50 yards, which was inside kicker Ryan Longwell’s range, to 55 yards, a much trickier ask.

From the 33-yard line Minnesota could run the ball up the middle, accept their likely minimal gain, and then take a shot from 150 feet away.

From the 38, you’re in a position where you need to gain yardage. Running the ball probably isn’t going to get the job done because you know the Saints are going to stack the line of scrimmage, so you’re best option is to pass.

And the rest, as they say, is history.

As a head coach you’re job is to put your players in the best possible position to win – Childress’ failure in that regard late in Sunday’s game was as visible as the bright yellow flag his ineptitude brought out of the referee’s pocket.

Those that want to blame Favre for the Vikings heading home will find their reasons, but for my money the number one reason is actually the number five.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • SEC Baby!!! Jan 25, 2010

    This was a game that was dominated by the Vikes, but Farves' surrounding players caused the game to be close. Also, Farve should have ran on their last drive.If the Saints have to depend upon turnovers against the Colts, it will be a blowout in the Super Bowl. I will say this. If the Vikes could be mistake free, they could be the best in the NFL.

  • TREESE1978 Jan 25, 2010

    Regardless of all the mistakes, they were in position to possibly win the game. They still had a chance and he messed it up with a bad decision. It's really no surprise... He has more interceptions than any QB for a reason.

    You people can go back to every play of the game and find something wrong with it if you want to, but going back to a fumble in the last qtr or the last drive or the last game had nothing to do with the interception he threw at that time. They still had a chance regardless of the penalty. He needed to make a play then and it didnt work.

    I think the bigger problem here is NFL's OT rules. In the era of this salary cap, its hard to put a lot of money into a stellar offense and have anything left for defense. Both teams should have a chance.

  • Baba Booey Jan 25, 2010

    Really the thing that lost the game for the Vikings was in the inexplicable 12 men in the huddle penalty that cost them five yards when they were in a very make-able field goal range!

    That mistake led to the Vikings having to get back into field goal range via a passing play.

    Previous to that play, the Vikes were running the clock without much interest in gaining yards.

    Another game where one team lost the game rather than the other winning it.

    Statistically a romp by the Vikings... the Saints only had 77 yards total in the second half of the game.

    Great win for the Saints... in a city that needs some good news.

  • Wheelman Jan 25, 2010

    Yes! A stupid boneheaded move cost them the game. Plus the Reggie Bush TD that wasn't a TD. I couldn't see that it ever crossed the line while it was inbounds. Wrong game for this kind of call!

  • StunGunn Jan 25, 2010

    EXACTLY right! It was the STUPID, STUPID penalty of having too many men in the huddle that cost the Vikings the win, not necessarity Favre. Too bad Favre will take the heat, but take away that penalty, and the Vikes had a chance.

  • College World Series: Teams TBD

    Tomorrow at 7:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

  • College World Series: Teams TBD

    Tuesday at 7:45 pm on 99.9 The Fan

Minor League Baseball
International League
Lehigh Valley4Final
Charlotte 2:05 PT3:05 MT4:05 CT5:05 ET3:05 MT5:05 ET10:05 GMT6:05 北京时间
Indianapolis 3:05 PT4:05 MT5:05 CT6:05 ET4:05 MT6:05 ET11:05 GMT7:05 北京时间
Travelers Champ (PGA)
1J. Spieth - z-12F
2D. Berger - y-12F
3tC. Hoffman-10F
3tD. Lee-10F
5tP. Reed-9F
5tP. Casey-9F
5tB. Weekley-9F
8tK. Streelman-8F
8tT. Merritt-8F
8tW. Simpson-8F
View Full Leaderboard
z = Won in Playoff   y = Lost in Playoff
NW Ark Champ (LPGA)
1S. Ryu-18F
2tM. Jutanugarn-16F
2tA. Yang-16F
4tS. Lewis-13F
4tM. Wie-13F
6tM. Lee-12F
6tI. Park-12F
8tM. Alex-11F
8tN. Broch Larsen-11F
10tC. Choi-10F
View Full Leaderboard
ATP Scoreboard
Sunday, Jun. 25
AEGON Championships (ATP)
(4) M. Cilic6 62 68   
F. Lopez4 77 710   
Gerry Weber Open (ATP)
(1) R. Federer6 6    
(4) A. Zverev1 3    
AEGON International (ATP/WTA)
Antalya Open (ATP)
First Round
D. Istomin4 77 4   
S. Darcis6 65 6   
(7) B. Coric5 4    
A. Mannarino7 6    
WTA Scoreboard
Sunday, Jun. 25
AEGON Classic Birmingham (WTA)
(7) P. Kvitova4 6 6   
A. Barty6 3 2   
Mallorca Open (WTA)
(2) A. Sevastova6 3 6   
J. Goerges4 6 3   
AEGON International (ATP/WTA)
First Round
C. Suarez Nav6 6    
E. Makarova3 1    
A. Riske6 7    
A. Cornet4 5    
L. Tsurenko3 6 4   
H. Watson6 4 6   
T. Babos1 1    
E. Mertens6 6    
M. Lucic-Baro4 7 5   
M. Niculescu6 5 7   
Y. Putintseva4 77 1   
L. Arruabarre6 62 2   
A. Konjuh4 0    
M. Barthel6 1