Ken Medlin

Dueling underdogs could signal new era

Posted March 30, 2011

Call it the Year of the Underdog.

This weekend's Final Four will be historic in a number of ways. With no team seeded higher than No. 3, this will be the lowest-seeded grouping ever in a Final Four. And, as an 11-seed, Virginia Commonwealth ties George Mason (2006) and LSU (1984) as the lowest-seeded team ever to make it this far.

But it doesn't stop there. The Butler-VCU matchup will, at the least, produce the lowest seed ever in the finals as well. UCLA (1980) and Villanova (1985) were both #8 seeds, so Butler would tie them -- and VCU would blast the record into infinity.

I don't think this is any great coincidence. College basketball is enjoying its most widespread parity in history. So-called "mid-majors" are able to challenge "high-majors" with regularity now, and that is not likely to end any time soon.

While it's true the traditional power schools tend to win recruiting battles for the truly elite players, those "superstars" don't last very long. We need only look down I-40 to see that in action as Duke (Kyrie Irving) and Carolina (Harrison Barnes) await decisions from their talented freshman stars.

Mid-majors are able to engage in "program-building" in ways their larger foes are not normally able to do. This is not to say the mid-majors are at advantage -- there isn't a college basketball coach in this county that would turn down a chance to have Irving or Barnes on their team -- but it makes for an interesting set of circumstances.

High-majors used to have their cake and eat it too, so to speak. They brought in the top players and kept them for 3-4 years. But gone are the days of Dean Smith having to convince James Worthy and Michael Jordan to turn pro, and gone are the days of Coach K being able to count on Grant Hill and Christian Laettner lasting through their senior seasons. Great players leave. It's a fact.

It's hard enough to win a national championship in the first place, but the power teams now have shorter championship windows. Georgetown had four years of Patrick Ewing back in the 1980's -- and they were dominant -- but the Hoyas' only title came in the big guy's junior season. it's doubtful a player like that would be around that long in today's game.

So with the elites trying to "time" their title runs, it creates a bit of a vacuum for other teams to rush into. Butler and VCU are proof positive that well-coached teams with good systems have create havoc in the tournament regardless of seeding. They're making March Madness just a little bit madder, and I think it's great.

11 Comments

Please to add a comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • hokies94vt@gmail.com Apr 2, 9:31 p.m.

    Hey. VCU and Butler are not underdogs any longer. Write it down. For the non-readers... go to ESPN firstly. Read all that you can. You will find it first there.

  • Tackman792000 Apr 1, 12:36 p.m.

    Cragsdale, thanks for your common sense approach post. I strongly agree with you that smaller schools (Mid-Majors) are making their presence felt. It only takes 5 players at at time. They all put their uniforms on the same way and with all the summer camps for players & coaches, all the touring teams during the summer, you got some kids at smaller schools making a name for themselves and their schools. When you get a kid like Jamie Skeen who played at Wake Forest then transferred to a smaller school, a player of that caliber elevates your team.

  • hokies94vt@gmail.com Mar 31, 6:32 p.m.

    We are not talking about football in this one. These schools are basketball schools. Just read a little folks before you make comments about football. These schools have something called guts, pride, belonging, a dream, and all of the facets that get any team to the Final Four.

    Obviously. These coaches recruit a heckeva lot better than most today. I would hope that Seth Greenberg can set his eyes on some that VCU is getting these days. Stevens is as bright as any young coach in the land. As 34 he is going to make some noise at a top notch school one day. I am pulling for them to win it all.

  • prez23062 Mar 30, 7:34 p.m.

    great read. it's rather bittersweet to fans like me. i wasn't even thought of when people like MJ and Ewing were in college, so i never got to see the huge impacts of the greats who stayed their entire college career. it is nice to see the underdogs getting their chance in the big dance, and i've gained loads of respect for the likes of stevens and smart. but it also sucks wondering what might have been when you have players leaving after 1 or 2 years. i always jump when people say we need a "three years college stay" rule in bball, but this article almost makes it seem like the one and done rule balances out with the seniority of teams that may not hold the future's nba stars.

  • dbd2014 Mar 30, 6:56 p.m.

    Thank you Ken, for a surprisingly well written, analytical article. Maybe you should lay a copy on the desks of Hall and Ovaries.

  • Cragsdale Mar 30, 5:14 p.m.

    oh, and Go Butler!

  • Cragsdale Mar 30, 5:13 p.m.

    I think it more a sign of how bad the NCAA was this season than a sign of how wonderful the... View More

    — Posted by Barely

    while I concede you your opinion, I have to disagree Just Because Duke didn't make it past the sweet 16, or whatever Major school you are pulling for didn't make it ion doesn't make the NCAA weak. It's been a great season as a whole for a lot of schools. Butler and VCU just showed up to play and didn't take their opponents lightly on game day. They played with heart and grit and gave everything they had. They won. Get over it.

  • RaleighPirate Mar 30, 2:57 p.m.

    Yes, the high-majors really showed the effect of early departures this year IMHO. I think this season showed how some mid-major and low-major teams with jr. and sr. laden squads were able to prevail over high-major teams without that leadership make-up.

  • Honesty first Mar 30, 2:47 p.m.

    All you need is a couple of really good players and then some role players and you have a chance. In football you need many more so the parity will never be there.

  • Barely Mar 30, 2:27 p.m.

    I think it more a sign of how bad the NCAA was this season than a sign of how wonderful the mid-major teams have become.

More...

 

 

  • ACC: NC State at Georgia Tech

    Tomorrow at 12:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • SEC: Arkansas at Florida

    Tomorrow at 2:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • PGA: Waste Management Phoenix Open

    Tomorrow at 3:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • Big 10: Michigan at Michigan State

    Sunday at 1:00 pm on WRAL-TV

  • NHL: Hurricanes vs. St. Louis

    Tonight at 7:00 on 99.9 The Fan

  • ACC: NC State at Georgia Tech

    Tomorrow at 12:00 pm on WRAL-FM

  • NHL: Carolina Hurricanes at NY Rangers

    Tomorrow at 7:00 pm on 99.9 The Fan

Scoreboard
Local
7:00pm Tonight
CAR
STL
 
Final
ORL 100
MIL 115
Final
IND 103
NYK 82
Final
MEM 99
DEN 69
4th
LAL 84
CHI 83
 
7:00pm Tonight
PHI
MIN
 
7:30pm Tonight
BOS
HOU
 
7:30pm Tonight
ATL
POR
 
7:30pm Tonight
CLE
SAC
 
7:30pm Tonight
BRK
TOR
 
8:00pm Tonight
MIA
DAL
 
8:00pm Tonight
NOP
LAC
 
9:00pm Tonight
UTA
GSW
 
10:30pm Tonight
PHO
CHI
 
Final
PROV 83
DEP 72
Final
RUTG 51
MSU 71
Final
ARMY 71
BU 67
 
Final
RFLSH 75
BRY 68
 
Final
MERC 75
CHAT 72
 
Final
LIU 67
CCST 55
 
Final
TOWS 74
COC 70
 
Final
UMASS 66
DAY 64
Final
FUR 59
ETST 55
 
Final
ODU 71
FIU 56
Final
RMU 87
FD 65
 
Final
CHAR 86
FATL 61
Final
LIB 53
HIGH 72
 
Final
UNF 86
KNST 67
 
Final
FLGC 78
LIP 62
 
Final
OSU 80
MD 56
Final
Terriers 73
MNTER 67
 
Final
STET 85
NKENTUCKY 75
 
Final
WAGN 75
SHU 64
 
Final
GMAS 68
STLU 60
Final
JVU 65
USCU 78
 
Final
VMI 70
WCU 85
 
Final
LATU 69
WKENT 56
Final
UNCG 42
WOFF 58
 
Final
DET 93
YOUNG 87
 
Final
GSOUT 83
APP 46
 
Final
TENNM 81
EILL 51
 
Final
GHND 64
HC 54
 
Final
CIN 70
UCONN 58
Final
NDST 61
DEN 54
 
Final
SD 55
MAST 66
 
Final
UWMIL 71
ILLCH 65
 
Final
BEL 103
JVST 82
 
Final
SMISS 54
MARS 69
Final
TXSA 69
MTST 58
Final
PETE 49
RIDE 58
 
Final
SEMIZ 61
SIUE 75
 
Final
TENST 64
TENT 56
 
Final
NDAK 60
WEBER 67
 
Final
SALA 89
LALAF 85
 
Final
ARKST 65
ARKLR 75
 
Final
TROY 55
LAMON 58
 
Final
TXARL 74
UGST 88
 
Final
MURST 85
EKENT 78
 
Final
NCOL 79
IDST 76
 
Final
MIZZ 53
KENT 69
Final
GONZ 64
PORT 46
Final
UTEP 71
UAB 69
Final
GRCN 78
UMKC 57
 
Final
WLVRN 78
CHIST 62
 
3rd OT
USC 94
COL 95
 
Final
UCI 67
CPSL 57
 
Final
CSNO 73
HAW 84
 
Final
PAC 43
PEPP 50
 
Final
SDU 69
SCU 64
 
Final
UCD 70
UCSB 64
 
Final
UCLA 69
UTAH 59
 
Final
PORST 54
MONT 73
 
Final
SACST 75
MNTST 59
 
2nd
CSFU 71
LBSU 68
 
Final
GAELS 68
LMU 54
 
2nd
WASU 42
CAL 46
 
2nd
BYU 48
USF 45
 
6:00pm Tonight
PRIN
HARV
 
7:00pm Tonight
CORN
BRO
 
7:00pm Tonight
PENN
DART
 
7:00pm Tonight
NIAG
MAR
 
7:00pm Tonight
CAN
QUIN
 
7:00pm Tonight
MAN
SIENA
 
8:00pm Tonight
WILL
IUPUI
 
8:00pm Tonight
FAIR
MON
 
8:00pm Tonight
ARST
OREG
 
8:00pm Tonight
CLMB
YALE
 
10:00pm Tonight
BUF
KSU
 
10:00pm Tonight
ARZ
ORST
 
Final
NYI 2
BOS 5
Final
NYR 0
MON 1
Final
PHI 5
WIN 2
Final
TOR 1
ARI 3
Final
FLA 3
CLB 2
Final
TAM 5
DET 1
Final
STL 5
NAS 4
Final
CAL 0
MIN 1
Final
EDM 3
BUF 2
3rd
SJS 6
ANA 2
 
7:00pm Tonight
NJD
PIT
 
7:00pm Tonight
CAR
STL
 
9:00pm Tonight
COL
NAS
 
10:00pm Tonight
VAN
BUF
 
10:00pm Tonight
ANA
CHI